Overview
Title
An Act To award a Congressional Gold Medal collectively to 60 diplomats, in recognition of their bravery and heroism during the Holocaust.
ELI5 AI
This bill wants to give a special award to 60 brave people who helped save many others during a very bad time in history, known as the Holocaust. It plans to make a shiny gold medal for them and show it in a special museum.
Summary AI
The bill, S. 91, aims to collectively award a Congressional Gold Medal to 60 diplomats for their courageous efforts to save Jewish people during the Holocaust. These diplomats defied orders from their own governments to issue passports and visas, allowing many Jews to escape Nazi persecution. The gold medal will be presented to the families of the honored diplomats and will later be displayed at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Additionally, the bill authorizes the production and sale of duplicate bronze medals to cover the costs.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The bill, referred to as the “Forgotten Heroes of the Holocaust Congressional Gold Medal Act,” aims to collectively award a Congressional Gold Medal to 60 diplomats. These individuals demonstrated remarkable bravery and heroism by taking significant risks to save Jewish people during the Holocaust. The act acknowledges their courageous deeds during World War II, including issuing passports and travel visas against government instructions and setting up safehouses. The gold medal will be designed and struck by the Secretary of the Treasury and displayed at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. The act also allows for the creation and sale of duplicate bronze medals to help cover costs.
Summary of Significant Issues
The bill, while noble in its intentions, presents several issues that need careful consideration:
Financial Oversight and Budgeting: There is a notable absence of detailed information regarding the costs associated with creating and awarding the Congressional Gold Medal. The lack of a specific budget or funding source may lead to concerns about fiscal responsibility. It is crucial for the bill to outline clear financial planning to avoid potential wasteful spending.
Vague Language and Ambiguity: Terms such as "appropriate locations associated with Holocaust remembrance" are somewhat vague. More specific criteria or examples would help avoid misinterpretation and ensure that the medal is displayed in suitable locations. Additionally, the bill does not specify who the "Secretary" refers to, potentially leading to confusion in execution.
Lack of Timeframe and Oversight Mechanisms: The bill does not stipulate a specific timeframe for transferring the gold medal to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. This could result in delays in honoring the diplomats. Furthermore, there is no oversight mechanism mentioned to ensure the appropriate use of funds from the United States Mint Public Enterprise Fund, which raises accountability concerns.
Demand for Bronze Medals: The authorization to produce and sell duplicate bronze medals lacks an assessment of potential demand. Producing these medals without sufficient demand could lead to unnecessary spending and misallocation of resources.
Impact on the Public
The bill aims to honor and bring attention to the heroic actions of diplomats during a dark period in history, potentially fostering a greater appreciation and understanding among the public. By commemorating these individuals, the bill encourages current and future generations to reflect on the importance of courage and moral action in the face of injustice.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Positive Impacts on Holocaust Remembrance Institutions: The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, and potentially other Holocaust remembrance venues, would benefit from the display of the Congressional Gold Medal, serving as a powerful symbol of courage and humanitarianism during the Holocaust. This could enhance the educational experience offered by these institutions.
Impact on Descendants of Honorees: The act of honoring these diplomats provides recognition and pride for the descendants and communities affiliated with the honorees, highlighting their family members' contributions to saving lives during one of history’s gravest times.
Financial Management and Government Accountability: The Treasury and institutions tasked with the medal's design, creation, and distribution may face challenges related to financial management and accountability given the lack of specific financial guidelines within the bill. Ensuring transparency and due diligence will be crucial for maintaining public trust and the effective implementation of the bill's intentions.
Issues
Lack of cost or budget specification for creating and awarding the Congressional gold medal (Section 3). This could raise concerns about potential wasteful spending and financial accountability.
Absence of a funding source or financial plan for the Congressional Gold Medal (Section 1) could lead to questions about fiscal responsibility and budgetary impacts.
Vague language regarding 'appropriate locations associated with Holocaust remembrance' for displaying the medal (Section 3). This may require more explicit definitions or examples to avoid misinterpretation and ensure the medal is displayed in suitable locations.
Ambiguity regarding the determination of amounts necessary for the costs of the medals (Section 6), which may lead to financial oversight issues.
No specific timeframe mentioned for when the medal should be transferred to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (Section 3), potentially leading to delays in honoring the diplomats.
Lack of an oversight or review mechanism for ensuring the appropriate use of funds from the United States Mint Public Enterprise Fund (Section 6), which might raise concerns about accountability and transparency.
Production and sale of duplicate medals in bronze without sufficient demand assessment (Section 4), which could lead to unnecessary spending and resource allocation.
Unclear who the 'Secretary' refers to in the context of authority and accountability for striking medals (Section 4), potentially leading to confusion in the execution of duties.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill is titled "Short title." It states that the Act can be referred to as the “Forgotten Heroes of the Holocaust Congressional Gold Medal Act”.
2. Findings; sense of Congress Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, Congress acknowledges a group of diplomats from various countries who undertook heroic actions during World War II to save Jewish people fleeing from the Nazis, often risking their own safety and careers. It emphasizes the importance of honoring these individuals with the Congressional Gold Medal and notes that future recognition may be given to others who also performed such acts of bravery during the Holocaust.
3. Congressional gold medal Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section authorizes the Speaker of the House and the President pro tempore of the Senate to present a single gold medal to honor 60 diplomats for their courageous efforts in saving Jews during World War II. The medal will be displayed at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum and may be shown in other places to remember the Holocaust.
4. Duplicate medals Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary is allowed to make and sell bronze copies of a gold medal described in a previous section, and the sale price must cover all costs, including materials and labor.
5. Status of medals Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section specifies that medals created under this law are considered "national medals" according to certain laws in the United States Code. It also states that these medals are treated as collectible items, known as "numismatic items," under other specific sections of the United States Code.
6. Authority to use fund amounts; proceeds of sale Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides that the U.S. Mint can use funds from the United States Mint Public Enterprise Fund to cover the costs of making medals. Additionally, money earned from selling bronze duplicates of these medals must be put back into the same fund.