Overview
Title
To require the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information to audit Federal spectrum.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants a special helper in the government to check all the radio waves used by different parts of the government, and they have to tell Congress which parts are used, if they're shared, and if any are unused. They also need to work with another group to make sure they’re not doing the same job twice.
Summary AI
S. 794 requires the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information to conduct an audit of the electromagnetic spectrum used by various federal entities. Within 18 months of the bill's passage, a detailed report must be submitted to Congress outlining the specific frequency bands used, their purposes, geographic allocations, and whether they are shared or exclusively used by federal or non-federal entities. The report will also highlight any portions of the spectrum not currently in use. Additionally, the Assistant Secretary is required to coordinate this audit with similar efforts by the Department of Transportation to avoid duplication.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled S. 794, aims to mandate an audit of the electromagnetic spectrum utilized by federal entities. This task is to be undertaken by the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information. The bill outlines that an audit must be conducted and a report delivered to Congress within 18 months of the bill's enactment. The report should specify the spectrum bands in use, their applications, geographic allocation, exclusivity details, and highlight any unused spectrum. Though the report would be unclassified, it may contain a classified annex, potentially limiting public access to some information. Coordination with the Department of Transportation is also required to avoid overlapping efforts.
Significant Issues
One primary concern is the absence of provisions detailing the funding or budget source for executing the audit. This omission could lead to execution challenges or inadequate resource allocation, potentially affecting the quality and thoroughness of the audit. Additionally, while the specified timeline for reporting is set at 18 months, this duration might be perceived as lengthy, particularly if the audit results could lead to timely and beneficial actions. This pacing could delay responses to findings that may be pressing.
Another issue is the terminology used in the bill. The definition of "Federal entity" is referenced from an external piece of legislation, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration Organization Act, making it less accessible and potentially confusing for those unfamiliar with this act.
The need for coordination with the Department of Transportation introduces a risk of duplicating efforts, which might slow down the audit and complicate the process. Lastly, the possibility of including a classified annex with the report raises transparency concerns, as it may limit or complicate public and Congressional oversight.
Impact on the Public
For the broader public, this bill could lead to more efficient use of the electromagnetic spectrum, which is a crucial resource for modern communication technologies. By identifying underutilized or inefficiently used spectrum bands, the audit may prompt reallocation or optimization strategies, potentially enhancing telecommunications services nationwide. However, the potential lack of transparency due to classified information could hinder public understanding of all the findings, impacting trust in government processes.
Impact on Stakeholders
Federal entities utilizing spectrum resources are directly impacted, as they could face scrutiny or pressure to justify their usage and dispose of underutilized bands if recommended. This audit might positively lead to better resource allocation among federal bodies and enhance communication capabilities. However, it could also bring challenges, such as pressure to relinquish control over certain spectrum segments.
The telecommunications industry might benefit from the findings if the audit results in the re-allocation of spectrum that becomes available for private sector use, enabling innovation and expansion in services. Conversely, non-federal entities currently sharing spectrum with federal counterparts could face uncertainties or changes in access due to audit-driven changes, affecting their operations.
Overall, while the bill holds potential benefits for resource optimization, attention must be paid to the issues raised to ensure it delivers improvements efficiently and transparently.
Issues
The section on Federal spectrum audit does not specify a budget or funding source for conducting the audit, which might lead to unclear or insufficient funding arrangements, potentially affecting the audit's execution. (Section 1)
The timeline set for the audit report is 'not later than 18 months,' which may be considered lengthy given the potential urgency or importance of the audit results, thereby delaying necessary actions. (Section 1(b))
The term 'Federal entity' relies on the definition from the National Telecommunications and Information Administration Organization Act, necessitating cross-referencing, which may cause confusion or misunderstandings. (Section 1(a)(2))
There is potential for overlap or duplication in efforts due to the requirement for the Assistant Secretary to coordinate with the Department of Transportation, which could complicate and delay the audit process. (Section 1(e))
The report on the audit 'may include a classified annex,' raising potential transparency issues as it is unclear how much information may be withheld from public scrutiny, impacting public and Congressional oversight. (Section 1(d))
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Federal spectrum audit Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information to audit the electromagnetic spectrum used by federal entities and report the findings to Congress within 18 months. The report must detail the specific spectrum bands each entity uses, their purposes, geographic areas, exclusivity, and any unused portions, and it should be unclassified with a possible classified annex.