Overview
Title
To establish the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site in the State of Maryland as an affiliated area of the National Park System, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 791 is a plan to make a special place to remember Thurgood Marshall, a famous lawyer, at a school in Baltimore. This place will be part of the places protected by the park system, but another group will help take care of it.
Summary AI
S. 791 aims to establish the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site in Baltimore, Maryland, as part of the National Park System. The site will be at Public School 103, where Thurgood Marshall received his elementary education. The bill designates the Beloved Community Services Corporation as the management entity and clarifies that the Secretary of the Interior may assist with marketing and preservation but will not own or financially manage the site. It also authorizes funding to support these efforts.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation named the "Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site Establishment Act of 2025" seeks to designate a particular school in Baltimore, Maryland, as the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site. The bill aims to honor Justice Thurgood Marshall's significant contributions to civil rights and the legal field by preserving the school he attended during his elementary years, Public School 103. This site will be affiliated with the National Park System but will be owned and managed by the Beloved Community Services Corporation, a nonprofit organization. The Secretary of the Interior may assist in funding certain initiatives related to the site but is not given financial or operational control.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several important issues arise from the provisions outlined in the bill, particularly concerning the management and financial aspects:
Potential Favoritism and Conflict of Interest: The Beloved Community Services Corporation is designated as the management entity, which could suggest preferential treatment. There is potential for this nonprofit organization to benefit financially or enhance its status due to this designation.
Lack of Financial Clarity: The bill does not provide detailed guidelines on financial planning or oversight. The vagueness in funding provisions, such as authorizing "such sums as are necessary," could lead to unchecked or even excessive spending without appropriate accountability.
Limited Federal Oversight: The bill restricts federal financial responsibility and ownership, which could result in management practices at the site that might not align with the broader standards expected of the National Park System, potentially affecting quality and consistency.
Implications for the Public
For the public, this bill could enhance cultural and historical education by preserving an important site associated with a pivotal figure in American civil rights history. This could boost tourism and educational initiatives in Baltimore, enhancing public historical knowledge.
However, the lack of detailed financial guidelines and oversight may lead to public concerns over government expenditure efficiency. Without specific checks and balances, there's a risk of inefficient allocation of taxpayer funds, potentially leading to public dissatisfaction about fiscal accountability.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Beloved Community Services Corporation: This nonprofit stands to gain significantly, both in terms of prestige and possibly financially, from managing a site designated as part of the National Park System. This could boost their operational scope and influence.
Local Community: The local community in Baltimore may benefit from potential increases in tourism and educational opportunities, driving economic and cultural growth in the area. However, if mismanagement were to occur due to the lack of oversight, it could lead to missed opportunities for local growth and development.
Government and National Park System: The limited role of the Secretary of the Interior may help conserve federal resources but could also place more pressure on local entities to maintain high standards without federal intervention. This might lead to challenges in maintaining consistency with the National Park System's standards.
Overall, while the bill seeks to honor Justice Thurgood Marshall's legacy and boost educational opportunities, careful attention to the identified issues could improve its execution and ensure a positive outcome for all stakeholders involved.
Issues
The designation of the Beloved Community Services Corporation as the management entity for the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site (Section 4(c) and Section 4(e)) may suggest potential favoritism or conflict of interest, as the corporation continues to own, operate, and manage the site, possibly benefiting financially or through increased prestige.
The lack of a detailed financial plan in Section 4 raises concerns regarding potential wasteful spending or mismanagement, as the section does not specify how the financial assistance provided by the Secretary will be monitored or regulated.
Section 5 authorizes appropriations with vague terminology such as 'such sums as are necessary', without specifying clear limits or guidance on the amount of money, which could lead to unchecked or excessive spending.
The absence of a detailed accountability or oversight mechanism in Section 5 regarding the use of appropriated funds might result in inefficiencies or deviations from the intended purpose.
The limited federal oversight as outlined in Section 4(g) could result in inconsistent management practices that do not align with the standards applied to other units of the National Park System.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section names the act as the "Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site Establishment Act of 2025."
2. Findings and purposes Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress finds that Thurgood Marshall made significant contributions to civil rights and served in various important legal and judicial positions, including as the first African American Supreme Court Justice. The Act aims to honor his legacy by designating his elementary school as a national historic site to preserve its history and significance for future generations.
3. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The definitions in this section clarify key terms related to the Act: the "management entity" is the organization managing the National Historic Site; the "National Historic Site" refers to the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site; the "School" is Public School 103 in Baltimore; and the "Secretary" is the Secretary of the Interior.
4. Establishment of the Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Justice Thurgood Marshall National Historic Site is being created as part of the National Park System, focusing on a school depicted on a specific map. While the Beloved Community Services Corporation will manage and own the site, the Secretary may assist but will not take on financial or ownership responsibilities.
5. Authorization of appropriations Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section permits the allocation of any necessary funds to implement the objectives of the Act.