Overview
Title
To require the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior to prioritize the completion of the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants two important people, the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior, to finish making a big walking path called the Continental Divide Trail before 2028, and it says they need to work together and talk with local people about it.
Summary AI
S. 594 directs the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior to focus on completing the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail by November 2028. The bill requires the creation of a joint team from the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management to handle tasks like acquiring lands or easements to fill in gaps and publish maps of the completed Trail corridor. The bill emphasizes working with local communities and stakeholders and ensures land acquisition is done with willing participants without using eminent domain. It also calls for annual progress reports to Congress until the trail is fully completed.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
This bill, known as the “Continental Divide Trail Completion Act,” aims to ensure the completion of the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail. It requires the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior to prioritize these efforts. The intention is to create a continuous trail by November 10, 2028, while ensuring alignment with various statutory requirements. The process emphasizes coordination between federal agencies and consultation with stakeholders, which includes setting up a Trail Completion Team. The Act also involves developing a comprehensive plan to close trail gaps and outlines the methods for acquiring necessary lands, explicitly prohibiting eminent domain.
Summary of Significant Issues
A primary issue is the ambitious timeline set for completing the trail by November 2028. Given administrative and logistical challenges, this may be difficult to achieve. There’s also a lack of clarity in roles for the involved Secretaries, which can lead to organizational inefficiencies. Another critical concern is the prohibition on using eminent domain for land acquisition, which could hinder efforts if willing sellers are not easily found. Additionally, the bill does not outline a specific budget or cost estimates for the activities, possibly leading to challenges in financial oversight.
The notion of "optimal location review" within the trail's planning phase is somewhat subjective and might lead to disagreements on trail placements. Moreover, public consultations and stakeholder engagements could be underemphasized, potentially resulting in insufficient community involvement or support.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, the public might benefit from the successful completion of the Trail, which can enhance outdoor recreational opportunities and preserve significant natural and cultural landscapes. Completing the trail could increase tourism and local economic activity, benefiting nearby communities. However, if resources are mismanaged or the project faces delays, public trust and expected benefits could be compromised.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For federal agencies tasked with executing the bill's provisions, the lack of role clarity and potential budgetary constraints could complicate effective implementation. Local landowners potentially affected by the trail's completion might face uncertainties, particularly due to the prohibition on eminent domain, which could limit negotiating power or delay the trail's completion.
Nonprofit organizations and volunteers who advocate for the Trail might see increased opportunities for involvement, yet they might also lack specific guidelines on how these partnerships will be formed. Conversely, misuse or inefficient allocation of funds due to any budgetary ambiguities could lead to missed opportunities for effectively harnessing public and private investment in trail infrastructure.
Ultimately, achieving the trail's planned completion by the deadline with clear and open communication to all stakeholders will be crucial for the bill’s success.
Issues
The timeline for ensuring the completion of the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail by November 10, 2028, may be ambitious and challenging, depending on the current state of progress and resource availability. This is outlined in Section 3(a)(1).
The lack of clarity regarding roles and responsibilities of the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Interior in Sections 3 and 3(b) could lead to confusion in implementation and administerial inefficiencies.
Section 3(d)(2) prohibits the use of eminent domain for acquiring necessary lands, potentially causing delays or increased costs if willing sellers cannot be found.
The term 'optimal location review' in Section 2(3) and its application in Section 3 could lead to subjective interpretations, possibly causing disagreements about proper trail placements.
Section 4 does not specify a clear budget or cost estimations for the Trail Completion Team, raising concerns about oversight and accountability of spending.
Section 5 lacks detail on public consultation or stakeholder involvement in developing the comprehensive plan, which could result in insufficient community support or awareness.
Financial management concerns arise from the lack of mentioned budget allocation or funding in Sections 2, 3, and 5, which could lead to fiscal irresponsibility or wasteful spending.
The ongoing reporting requirement in Section 3(f) might become an administrative burden, diverting resources away from actual trail completion tasks.
Legal terminology in Section 7 might not be easily understandable to the public, complicating the understanding and enforcement of the bill's provisions.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that the Act can be called the “Continental Divide Trail Completion Act.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions of key terms used in the Act, such as "acequia," which is a type of community ditch in New Mexico, and "land grant-merced," referring to certain community land grants recognized by New Mexico law. It also defines roles like "Secretaries" and "Secretary" related to government positions, as well as terms like "Team" and "Trail," which refer to groups and trails involved in land management.
3. Continental Divide National Scenic Trail Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a plan for completing the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail by November 10, 2028. The Secretaries of the relevant departments will establish a team to acquire land and make necessary adjustments to eliminate gaps in the Trail, optimize its route, and consult with stakeholders. The plan involves working with various organizations and ensuring no land is taken by eminent domain, with regular reports to Congress on progress and expenditures.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The title of this Act is the “Continental Divide National Scenic Trail Completion Act”.
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines key terms used in the Act: "Secretary" refers to the Secretary of Agriculture, "Trail" is the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail, and "Trail Completion Team" is a joint team from the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management responsible for completing the Trail, established under section 4(a).
3. Completion of Continental Divide National Scenic Trail Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section explains that the Secretary and the Secretary of the Interior are responsible for trying to finish the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail, making it a complete path by its 50th anniversary, as long as they have the necessary funding.
4. Trail Completion Team Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Trail Completion Team, made up of the Secretary, the Secretary of the Interior, and the Forest Service-Bureau of Land Management, is formed to help finish and improve a trail and aid in creating a detailed development plan. They will work with other government entities, local groups, and interested parties to achieve this.
5. Comprehensive development plan for the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Secretary to complete a detailed development plan for the Continental Divide National Scenic Trail within three years after the Trail Completion Team is set up. This plan must identify missing parts of the trail due to land not being acquired, explore options to use easements from willing sellers to finish the trail, and outline both general and specific development strategies with estimated costs.
6. Partnerships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary and the Secretary of the Interior are instructed to work together to form agreements with volunteer and nonprofit groups to help manage and finish the Trail.
7. Effect Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section clarifies that this Act does not give new authority to acquire land for the Trail beyond what is already allowed under the National Trails System Act. It also states that obtaining land for the Trail is not prioritized over other land acquisition needs.