Overview
Title
To amend the mission statement of the United States Military Academy to include the phrase “Duty, Honor, Country”.
ELI5 AI
The MACARTHUR Act wants to change the United States Military Academy's mission statement to say "Duty, Honor, Country," so that all the students there remember these important values.
Summary AI
S. 5550 seeks to modify the mission statement of the United States Military Academy by adding the phrase “Duty, Honor, Country.” The bill emphasizes the importance of these principles being ingrained in the institution's culture and instilled in all cadets. Sponsored by Senator Cruz, along with Senators Scott and Britt, it mandates the Secretary of the Army to implement this change within 30 days of the law's enactment. The act is titled the "Maintaining Academy Culture and Assuring Retention of Tradition, Honor, and Unity of the Republic Act" or "MACARTHUR Act."
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill titled "S. 5550," also known as the "Maintaining Academy Culture and Assuring Retention of Tradition, Honor, and Unity of the Republic Act" (MACARTHUR Act), seeks to amend the mission statement of the United States Military Academy to include the phrase "Duty, Honor, Country." Introduced by Senator Cruz and co-sponsored by Senator Scott of Florida and Senator Britt, the bill was referred to the Senate Committee on Armed Services.
General Summary
The primary aim of the bill is to formally incorporate the values of "Duty, Honor, Country" into the mission statement of the United States Military Academy. This phrase is historically associated with the institution and signifies the ethical standards and responsibilities expected of its cadets. The bill requires the Secretary of the Army to complete this amendment within 30 days of the bill's enactment.
Summary of Significant Issues
Redundancy of Proposed Amendment: One of the significant issues identified is that the phrase "Duty, Honor, Country" is already deeply ingrained in the tradition and ethos of the United States Military Academy. Therefore, its formal addition to the mission statement could be seen as redundant.
Implementation and Enforcement Challenges: The bill does not specify how the amendment process will be tracked or enforced, nor does it outline any consequences if the Secretary of the Army fails to meet the 30-day deadline. This lack of accountability measures could undermine the effectiveness of the mandate.
Ambiguity of Bill's Title: The naming of the act, MACARTHUR Act, while creative, is considered ambiguous. The title does not clearly convey the bill's intent or objectives, which might lead to confusion without reading the text of the bill itself.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
Broad Public Impact: For the general public, this bill might not seem to have an immediate or direct impact. However, by reinforcing core values at the United States Military Academy, the bill aims to reaffirm the traditional values in military service, which can indirectly impact public perception by promoting a sense of pride and trust in military institutions.
Impact on the United States Military Academy and Its Cadets: The bill directly influences the United States Military Academy and its stakeholders. For cadets and faculty, the formal inclusion of these principles in the mission statement might reinforce an already existing culture of honor and duty. Yet, the lack of accountability measures might lead to questions about the effectiveness and necessity of such legislative actions.
National Sentiment and Military Culture: From a broader perspective, the bill may serve to reaffirm national values associated with military service, potentially fostering enhanced morale and unity among service members. However, critics might argue that legislative efforts should focus on tangible improvements within military training and resources rather than symbolic gestures.
Overall, while the bill seeks to enshrine a quintessential part of United States Military Academy ethos, the redundancy of the change, coupled with the lack of clear enforcement strategies, raises questions about its practical impact and necessity.
Issues
The amendment of the mission statement to include the phrase 'Duty, Honor, Country' may be considered redundant, as this phrase is traditionally associated with the United States Military Academy and might already be an implicit part of its values. (Section 3)
The section does not provide any details on how the implementation of the amendment will be monitored or enforced, which might lead to lack of accountability or follow-through. (Section 3)
The section does not specify the consequences if the Secretary of the Army fails to amend the mission statement within the specified 30-day period, which might render the mandate less effective. (Section 3)
The name of the Act, 'Maintaining Academy Culture and Assuring Retention of Tradition, Honor, and Unity of the Republic Act (MACARTHUR) Act', while creative, might be considered ambiguous as it does not clearly convey the purpose or objective of the legislation without additional context. (Section 1)
The section provided is simply the short title of the Act and does not include any substantive provisions or details related to funding or implementation, making it difficult to audit for specific issues at this stage. (Section 1)
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this Act provides its short title, which is the “Maintaining Academy Culture and Assuring Retention of Tradition, Honor, and Unity of the Republic Act”, abbreviated as the MACARTHUR Act.
2. Sense of Congress Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress expresses the belief that the values of "Duty, Honor, Country" should be a core part of the culture at the United States Military Academy and should be taught to every cadet.
3. Modification of united states military academy mission statement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of the Army is required to update the United States Military Academy's mission statement within 30 days to add the words “Duty, Honor, Country.”