Overview
Title
To create an Office of Cybersecurity at the Federal Trade Commission for supervision of data security at consumer reporting agencies, to require the promulgation of regulations establishing standards for effective cybersecurity at consumer reporting agencies, to impose penalties on credit reporting agencies for cybersecurity breaches that put sensitive consumer data at risk, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The Data Breach Prevention and Compensation Act of 2024 is a plan to help keep people's information safe on the internet by making sure businesses that collect lots of personal data, like credit report companies, follow strong protection rules and tell people if their data gets lost. If these rules are broken, the companies have to pay money, which is used to help fix the problem and possibly give money to the people affected.
Summary AI
The bill, titled the Data Breach Prevention and Compensation Act of 2024, aims to establish an Office of Cybersecurity within the Federal Trade Commission to oversee data protection at consumer reporting agencies. It requires these agencies to follow strict cybersecurity standards and notify authorities and consumers if a data breach occurs. The bill outlines penalties for breaches, with fines based on the number of affected consumers, and allocates funds from these penalties to research and compensate affected individuals. Additionally, the bill allows the FTC to enforce compliance and seek court-ordered security measures if necessary.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The legislation in question, titled the "Data Breach Prevention and Compensation Act of 2024," aims to bolster cybersecurity standards for consumer reporting agencies by establishing an Office of Cybersecurity under the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The bill mandates the creation of cybersecurity standards, sets requirements for timely notification in the event of data breaches, and introduces penalties for non-compliance. The overarching objective is to mitigate the risk of sensitive consumer data exposure and enhance consumer protection through stringent regulatory oversight and reporting mechanisms.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several noteworthy issues arise from the proposed bill. Firstly, the threshold for defining a "covered consumer reporting agency," set at earning a minimum of $7 million annually, may inadvertently exclude smaller agencies that still possess significant consumer data. This threshold decision and its implications lack a clear rationale. Furthermore, the bill grants significant discretion to the Director of the newly formed Office of Cybersecurity, particularly concerning the definition of "personally identifying information." This could lead to arbitrary determinations without clear guidelines.
Another concern involves potential overlaps with existing cybersecurity oversight, raising questions about redundancy and efficient use of resources. The ambiguities in defining what constitutes a "covered breach" might pose compliance challenges for agencies, affecting consistent enforcement. The penalty framework, which bases fines on fixed amounts per consumer affected, lacks flexibility and could result in disproportionate penalties based on the scale or impact of breaches.
The significant funding appropriated by the bill—$100 million—raises concerns about transparency and oversight, lacking clarity on its specific use, leading to potential waste. Finally, the provision allowing notification delays for law enforcement purposes is open-ended, potentially enabling indefinite information withholding from affected consumers.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill's impact on the public hinges on its effectiveness in mitigating data breaches and enhancing consumer data security. By creating a specialized cybersecurity office and setting clear standards, it aims to protect consumers' sensitive information more robustly. However, its success in achieving these aims depends largely on the precise implementation of its provisions.
For consumers, effective enforcement of this bill could mean fewer data breaches and better protective measures from agencies handling their data. The compensation clause promises monetary redress, potentially providing some relief to affected individuals.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Consumer reporting agencies are directly impacted stakeholders. Larger agencies must comply with new, potentially costly cybersecurity measures, but the regulatory burden appears more substantial for smaller agencies or those close to the revenue threshold. These could face challenges in meeting the sophisticated technical and governance requirements specified in the bill.
For government entities like the FTC and cybersecurity researchers, the act promises increased funding and influence but also adds layers of responsibility and accountability. The prospect of overlapping jurisdictions may lead to inefficiencies, and robust inter-agency cooperation will be crucial to avoid redundant efforts.
Overall, while the bill sets an ambitious agenda for data protection, its efficacy and fairness will depend on addressing these significant issues, providing clear guidelines, and ensuring accountability across all involved parties.
Financial Assessment
The Data Breach Prevention and Compensation Act of 2024 incorporates several financial references and appropriations aimed at addressing cybersecurity issues within consumer reporting agencies. This commentary will explore how these financial elements are structured and relate to the identified issues.
Funding and Financial Appropriations
The bill specifies a significant financial appropriation with the authorization of $100,000,000 to implement its mandates. This allocation is designed to remain available until expended, indicating that it is intended for long-term use and stability in the oversight and enforcement of cybersecurity measures. The financial appropriation is intended to ensure the establishment and operation of the new Office of Cybersecurity within the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
Penalties and Consumer Compensation
A key financial aspect of the bill is its penalty framework for data breaches. The bill imposes civil penalties of $100 for each consumer whose personal identifying information is exposed, plus an additional $50 for each uncovered piece of information. These penalties are notably structured as fixed amounts per consumer, which raises concerns about their rigidity and the potential for disproportionate financial impact on consumer reporting agencies based on the scale of breaches.
Half of the collected penalties are earmarked for cybersecurity research and inspections, while the other half is allocated to compensate affected consumers. This allocation demonstrates an intent to both bolster cybersecurity measures and provide direct financial compensation to consumers harmed by data breaches.
Addressing Issues Related to Financial References
Appropriation Oversight: The bill's appropriation of $100,000,000 lacks detailed guidance on how these funds will be managed or overseen. As identified in the issues, this vagueness could lead to inefficiencies or misuse of the funds, given that there is no explicit mechanism for accountability outlined in the bill.
Penalty Flexibility and Fairness: The penalty structure, being rigid with fixed per-consumer amounts, might not adequately take into account the varying scales and impacts of breaches. This rigidity can lead to disproportionate penalties that may unfairly burden consumer reporting agencies. There is an opportunity for the bill to incorporate a more nuanced penalty framework that considers the specific circumstances of each breach.
Immunity from Nonconstitutional Claims: The provision for delay in consumer notifications raises a potential problem where financial penalties might be obscured due to delayed reporting. The immunity given to agencies for law enforcement-related delays could result in a lack of transparency and accountability, as it might shield the agencies from scrutiny over how quickly they address breaches and levy fines.
In summary, while the bill aims to enforce strict cybersecurity measures through financial penalties and appropriations, the execution of these financial aspects raises questions about flexibility, oversight, and accountability. Balancing financial discipline with fair enforcement practices could ensure that the measures taken are both effective and equitable.
Issues
The definition of 'covered consumer reporting agency' (Section 2) includes a threshold of agencies earning not less than $7,000,000 in annual revenue, which may exclude smaller but potentially equally impactful agencies without clear justification.
The bill allows the Director of the Office of Cybersecurity substantial discretion to define 'personally identifying information' (Section 2), which could lead to arbitrary or inconsistent decisions lacking clear guidelines.
The establishment of the Office of Cybersecurity under the FTC (Section 3) could lead to redundancies and overlaps with existing cybersecurity functions, increasing bureaucracy and potentially wasting resources.
Ambiguities in defining what constitutes a 'covered breach' (Section 4) could create compliance challenges and inconsistent enforcement against consumer reporting agencies.
The penalty framework in Section 4 is rigid, basing penalties on fixed amounts per consumer, and lacks flexibility to account for varying scales and impacts of breaches, potentially leading to disproportionate penalties.
The allocation and oversight of the significant appropriation ($100,000,000) authorized by Section 5 of the bill is vague, which might lead to misallocation or wasteful use of funds.
The provision for delaying consumer notifications for law enforcement purposes in Section 4, without clear limits, could be abused to withhold information from consumers indefinitely.
There is no clear mechanism for ensuring accountability of the Director’s power, particularly concerning the initiation of investigations and suits (Section 3), risking unrestrained discretionary power.
Section 4 provides immunity to agencies from nonconstitutional claims concerning delays in notifications, which could limit agency accountability and transparency.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The act will be officially known as the "Data Breach Prevention and Compensation Act of 2024."
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text defines key terms in a legislative act, such as "affected consumer," which refers to individuals whose personal information is involved in a data breach, and "personally identifying information," which includes sensitive details like social security numbers and unique biometric data. It also clarifies the roles and meanings of various entities and terms, such as "Commission" for the Federal Trade Commission and "Office" for the Office of Cybersecurity.
Money References
- (7) COVERED CONSUMER REPORTING AGENCY.—The term “covered consumer reporting agency” means— (A) a consumer reporting agency described in section 603(p) of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681a(p)); or (B) a consumer reporting agency that earns not less than $7,000,000 in annual revenue from the sale of consumer reports.
3. Cybersecurity standards and FTC authority Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill establishes an Office of Cybersecurity in the Commission tasked with overseeing data security for consumer reporting agencies. The Office will set security standards, examine compliance, investigate breaches, and report to Congress, with authority to take legal action if necessary, while also coordinating with other national cybersecurity entities.
4. Notification and enforcement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text outlines the notification and enforcement rules for consumer reporting agencies when a major data breach occurs. It requires timely notification of breaches to government agencies and affected consumers, sets penalties for not complying with these requirements, and allows for penalties to be used for cybersecurity measures and consumer compensation.
Money References
- — (A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in subparagraph (B), in determining the amount of a civil penalty under paragraph (1), the court shall impose a civil penalty on a covered consumer reporting agency of— (i) $100 for each consumer for whom the first and last name, or the first initial of the first name and last name, and 1 other item of personally identifying information were exposed to an unauthorized party; and (ii) in addition to the penalty imposed under clause (i), an additional $50 for each item of personally identifying information of the consumer, other than an item described in that clause, that was exposed to an unauthorized party. (B) EXCEPTION.— (i) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in clause (ii), in an action commenced under this subsection, a court may not impose a civil penalty in an amount that is more than 50 percent of the gross revenue of the covered consumer reporting agency against which the action is brought for the fiscal year before the fiscal year in which the covered consumer reporting agency became aware of the covered breach that is the subject of the action.
5. Authorization of appropriations Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, the bill allows for $100 million to be set aside and used as needed to implement its provisions.
Money References
- There are authorized to be appropriated $100,000,000 to carry out this Act, to remain available until expended.