Overview
Title
To require all Federal contractors and subcontractors to enroll in, and maintain compliance with, the E–Verify Program.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants all companies working with the government to use a special system called E-Verify to check that their workers are allowed to work in the country. It's like making sure everyone is playing by the rules to have fair and safe jobs.
Summary AI
The bill S. 5309 aims to ensure that all Federal contractors and subcontractors are enrolled in and comply with the E-Verify Program. It introduces a requirement for entities seeking government contracts to certify their participation and adherence to E-Verify rules. Executive agencies are responsible for checking compliance before awarding contracts and must monitor and report on ongoing compliance. The bill also outlines procedures for dealing with noncompliance and mandates an annual report on E-Verify compliance, aiming to promote secure and fair employment in federal contracting.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed legislation, titled the "Secure And Fair Employment in Federal Contracting Act" or "SAFE Contracting Act," mandates that all federal contractors and subcontractors enroll in and maintain compliance with the E-Verify program. The E-Verify program is a system used to verify the employment eligibility of employees to work in the United States. This bill aims to ensure strict compliance among contractors by requiring certification of enrollment in the E-Verify program and adherence to relevant regulations before they can be awarded federal contracts. Failure to comply could lead to suspension or debarment, imposing severe penalties for noncompliance.
Summary of Significant Issues
One major concern with the bill is the lack of clear guidelines on what constitutes full compliance with the E-Verify Program's regulations and statutes. This ambiguity could lead to inconsistent interpretations and enforcement across different agencies. The bill also permits only a 30-day window for contractors and subcontractors to rectify compliance issues before facing suspension or debarment, which may be perceived as overly harsh, especially without a defined process for appeal or reconsideration.
Additionally, the requirement for continuous compliance monitoring by executive agencies poses a significant administrative burden. Agencies may face resource constraints while attempting to fulfill these rigorous oversight responsibilities. The timeline for implementing these new regulations, particularly the 180-day and 1-year deadlines for various procedural changes, could be challenging to meet, potentially leading to rushed or ineffective implementations.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, this bill seeks to enhance the integrity of the federal contracting process by ensuring that all federal contractors comply with existing immigration laws. This could positively impact U.S. workers by reinforcing legal employment standards and ensuring fair competition among businesses vying for federal contracts.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For government agencies, the increased administrative duties could present a challenge, requiring greater allocation of resources and manpower to ensure compliance. This could potentially slow down the contracting process and affect their operational efficiency.
Businesses engaging in federal contracting could experience significant impacts. Small businesses and new entrants might find the requirements burdensome due to unfamiliarity with the E-Verify Program and the stringent compliance standards set by the bill. Companies could also face reputational risks from the public posting of compliance findings, even if any issues are minor or resolved expediently.
Overall, while the SAFE Contracting Act aims to strengthen the enforcement of employment eligibility laws, it introduces several operational challenges and potential fairness concerns that require careful consideration and possibly further refinement to address stakeholders' needs effectively.
Issues
The bill requires federal contractors and subcontractors to enroll in and comply with the E-Verify Program, yet fails to clarify what constitutes full compliance with 'all statutes, regulations, and policies' governing the E-Verify Program, which could lead to inconsistent interpretations and enforcement (Section 2).
The bill imposes strict consequences for noncompliance, including suspension and debarment proceedings after only a 30-day period to return to compliance, which may be considered too harsh, especially without an opportunity for appeal or reconsideration (Sections 2(f), 4715(f)(2)).
The requirement for continuous compliance monitoring by executive agencies could impose significant administrative burdens, leading to increased resource constraints and potential implementation difficulties (Sections 2(e), 4715(e)(3)).
The timeline for implementing these new regulations and procedures, specifically a 180-day and 1-year deadline for various actions, may be unrealistic given the complexity and number of agencies involved, risking ineffective or rushed implementation (Section 3).
The provision requiring public posting of compliance findings could expose businesses to reputational harm from minor or quickly resolved violations, raising concerns about fairness and the potential impact on business operations (Sections 2(e)(3)(B), 4715(e)(3)(B)).
The bill does not outline an appeals process or reconsideration for contractors or subcontractors facing suspension or debarment, which could raise fairness concerns and limit the ability of businesses to contest potentially erroneous compliance determinations (Section 2(f), 4715(f)(2)).
The lack of specific procedures or criteria for executive agencies to evaluate E-Verify compliance leaves room for inconsistent application across agencies, possibly undermining the uniform enforcement of the bill's requirements (Sections 2(e), 4715(e)).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short titles Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act states that the official short titles are the “Secure And Fair Employment in Federal Contracting Act” and the “SAFE Contracting Act”.
2. E-Verify compliance requirement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that any organization bidding for U.S. government contracts must certify their participation and compliance with the E-Verify Program, which checks the eligibility of their employees to work in the United States. Agencies are required to evaluate and confirm this compliance before awarding contracts, monitor it afterward, and penalize noncompliance, including potential suspension or debarment.
4715. E–Verify compliance requirement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the requirement for any organization bidding for a U.S. government contract to prove they and their subcontractors are using and following the rules of the E-Verify Program, which checks the legal work status of employees. It also explains the procedures for handling noncompliance, including potential suspension or debarment if entities or subcontractors fail to correct violations.
3. Implementation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill requires amendments to the Federal Acquisition Regulation to be made within 180 days to ensure government agencies monitor contractor compliance with the E-Verify Program. Additionally, within one year, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services must create and implement data collection methods to track federal contractors using E-Verify and inform agencies of these methods.
4. Annual report Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill amends Section 1131 of title 41, United States Code, to require the Administrator to submit an annual report, in collaboration with the Director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, about E–Verify compliance, including the number of noncompliant entities referred for further action. Additionally, the section heading is changed from "report" to "reports" and a clerical adjustment is made to the section's table of contents.