Overview
Title
To provide for certain improvements to the housing and workforce programs of Federal land management agencies, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill helps make sure people who take care of parks and forests have nice places to live and work by building houses and making it easier for the agencies to hire people. It also tries to keep things fair and checks if the spending is done wisely.
Summary AI
The proposed bill, titled the "Land Manager Housing and Workforce Improvement Act of 2024," aims to enhance housing and workforce programs for federal land management agencies. It authorizes actions like developing workforce housing both within and outside national park boundaries and empowers agencies like the National Park Service and Forest Service with improved leasing and partnership abilities. The bill also includes provisions for recruiting and supporting both permanent and seasonal employees, as well as reports and oversight measures to assess housing needs and improve housing policies.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The "Land Manager Housing and Workforce Improvement Act of 2024" aims to enhance the housing and workforce programs of several federal land management agencies, including the National Park Service and the Forest Service. This legislative proposal introduces measures to improve housing options, create partnerships for workforce support, and conduct oversight on housing needs. It seeks to ensure both permanent and seasonal staff have adequate living conditions while leveraging resources efficiently.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several challenges arise from the bill's current structure. Notably, there is concern over the direct appointment authority granted to the Secretary of the Interior or Agriculture under Section 301. This provision allows bypassing traditional competitive hiring processes, potentially leading to favoritism and inconsistencies across different agencies. Additionally, the bill's numerous references to "appropriate committees of Congress" in Sections 401 and 402 are vague, potentially obscuring oversight and weakening accountability mechanisms.
Furthermore, Section 403, which addresses emergency spending, lacks clarity about when such spending is justified. This omission raises concerns about accountability and potential misuse of funds. Sections 201 and 202 introduce partnerships and philanthropic agreements for housing development but lack specific criteria and safeguards, risking conflicts of interest and favoritism. Moreover, Sections 101 and 102 are criticized for their ambiguous references to "related infrastructure and amenities," possibly resulting in unrestrained or wasteful expenditures.
The bill's flexibility in land acquisition for workforce housing, especially near National Park units as detailed in Section 102, could lead to inefficient land use if purchases exceed actual needs. Finally, the definitions section fails to provide sufficient context, creating uncertainty about the terms' applications throughout the act.
Public Impact
Overall, the bill aims to address housing shortages for federal land management employees, which could improve recruitment and retention by ensuring staff has access to necessary living conditions close to their work sites. This enhancement could lead to more effective management of public lands and better services for visitors.
However, the potential bypassing of regular hiring processes might undermine public trust in fair employment practices. The broad and sometimes vague language used in various sections could also result in resource mismanagement, ultimately impacting taxpayers if funds are not spent effectively.
Impact on Stakeholders
For federal employees within the National Park Service and the Forest Service, the bill could provide expanded housing opportunities and more flexible rental options, improving overall job satisfaction and stability. Including philanthropic support might increase available resources for housing, provided it is managed transparently.
However, land acquisition flexibility and unchecked spending could negatively impact local communities if these decisions do not align with community needs or environmental considerations. Additionally, the ambiguities in committee reporting and the lack of concrete guidelines might complicate oversight processes, leaving some stakeholders uncertain about accountability measures.
In summary, while the bill presents valuable opportunities to bolster federal workforce housing, it requires careful revisions to address potential issues of favoritism, inefficient land use, and oversight to ensure it serves the public and stakeholders effectively.
Issues
The authority in Section 301 for direct appointments by the Secretary of the Interior or Agriculture could bypass standard competitive hiring processes, leading to potential favoritism and inconsistency in hiring practices across agencies.
Section 401 and Section 402 both contain vague descriptions of 'appropriate committees of Congress' for reporting, which could lead to ambiguity in oversight and accountability regarding workforce housing needs and programming.
Section 403's procedures for 'Justifying emergency spending' may lack clarity in terms of the criteria under which emergency subsistence payments are justified, raising concerns about accountability and potential misuse of funds without proper oversight.
In Section 201 and Section 202, the use of partnerships and philanthropic agreements to address workforce housing lacks detailed criteria and safeguards, potentially leading to favoritism or conflicts of interest without transparency in fundraising or partner selection.
Sections 101 and 102 raise concerns about the lack of specificity concerning 'related infrastructure and amenities,' which might result in unnecessary or wasteful spending without clear guidelines.
Section 102's flexibility for acquiring land for workforce housing near National Park units could potentially lead to inefficient use if acquired land exceeds housing needs, with a lack of clear criteria for determining when land becomes excess property.
The definitions in Section 2, including 'appropriate committees of Congress' and 'covered agencies,' lack clarity and sufficient context, leading to potential perceptions of bias or ambiguity in their application throughout the act.
Section 104 expands the use of National Park Service rental receipts for various activities, which could lead to increased spending without specific oversight, potentially resulting in budgetary imbalances or mismanagement.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The "Land Manager Housing and Workforce Improvement Act of 2024" aims to improve housing options and support for employees of the National Park Service and Forest Service. It includes initiatives for expanding housing authority, creating partnerships, and overseeing workforce housing needs to ensure both permanent and seasonal staff have adequate living conditions.
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines important terms used in the Act, including "appropriate committees of Congress" which refers to specific committees within the Senate and the House of Representatives, "covered agencies" which includes several federal agencies like the National Park Service and the Forest Service, and "Secretary" which stands for the Secretary of the Interior.
101. Prioritizing National Park Service workforce housing Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section modifies the United States Code to ensure that the National Park Service gives priority to constructing housing for field employees, along with necessary infrastructure and amenities. It also adds a comma to clarify a part of the text.
102. Authorizing the National Park Service to address workforce housing off-park Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section allows the Secretary of the Interior to buy or acquire up to 10 acres of land near national parks to build housing for park employees. If the land is no longer needed, it can be sold, and the money from the sale would be used to fund other employee housing projects.
103. Expanding National Park Service rental options Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends existing U.S. law to expand the purposes for which the National Park Service can use funds related to housing for field employees. It now includes not only management, repair, and maintenance, but also occupancy, development, construction, rehabilitation, or management of these quarters and related infrastructure.
104. Leveraging National Park Service rental receipts for workforce housing programming Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill changes a law so that money from renting National Park Service properties can be used not just for upkeep, but also for building, improving, or managing housing for park staff and related facilities.
105. Empowering the Forest Service to address workforce housing needs Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill empowers the Forest Service by amending existing laws to allow extended or flexible permits for workforce housing, streamline the process for selling or transferring administrative sites, and enable the use of funds for acquiring land or facilities to support the National Forest System and housing for its employees.
201. Engaging partners to address National Park Service workforce housing Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to section 101701(a) of title 54 of the United States Code clarifies that the Secretary’s responsibilities now explicitly include projects for employee housing in National Parks. It also expands the types of organizations and individuals, including those with philanthropic agreements to support Federal agencies, that can be involved as partners, now accounting for associations at the Tribal level as well.
202. Leveraging philanthropic support to address National Park Service workforce housing Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Section 202 modifies a part of the United States Code by allowing the National Park Service to include services, in addition to goods, when leveraging philanthropic support for workforce housing.
301. Supporting the permanent land manager workforce Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary or Secretary of Agriculture can hire people living near certain federal sites directly into specific jobs without the usual competitive process until September 30, 2030. This authority requires compliance with merit-based principles and public notice laws, and it must address a need for housing that the government cannot provide.
302. Supporting the seasonal National Park Service workforce Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that temporary seasonal workers at the National Park Service can be rehired without having to compete for their positions. The requirement for the job to be in the same commuting area is removed, and this rule is valid until September 30, 2030.
401. Quantifying the workforce housing needs of land managers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The given section requires the Secretary and the Secretary of Agriculture to provide a report to Congress within 18 months detailing the housing needs for workers in specific agencies. This report should cover different housing types, occupancy rates, alternative options, and local market conditions.
402. Conducting oversight on the housing programming of land managers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Comptroller General is required to submit a report to Congress within 18 months, examining the impact of various federal guidance on housing for agency workers and suggesting improvements. The report should include recommendations on tenant experience, housing supply, and commuting factors, and covered agencies must implement these recommendations within one year.
403. Justifying emergency spending Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to Section 5 of the Act of August 3, 1956, requires the Secretary of Agriculture to notify Congress 30 days before providing emergency subsistence to Forest Service employees, and to report the number and grade level of employees affected after the action is taken.
5. Emergency subsistence for employees Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that the Department is responsible for providing emergency subsistence to employees.