Overview

Title

An Act To modify the boundary of the Vicksburg National Military Park in the State of Mississippi, and for other purposes.

ELI5 AI

The bill lets the U.S. government give a small piece of parkland in Mississippi to the state, where people can build things like a visitor center or museum for everyone to enjoy.

Summary AI

S. 4994 is a bill that proposes to change the boundary of the Vicksburg National Military Park in Mississippi. The bill allows the Secretary of the Interior to give certain areas of the parkland to the state of Mississippi. This land, which covers approximately 10.14 acres, can be used by the state for purposes such as a welcome center, interpretive center, museum, or other public uses. The act passed the Senate on December 18, 2024.

Published

2024-12-18
Congress: 118
Session: 2
Chamber: SENATE
Status: Engrossed in Senate
Date: 2024-12-18
Package ID: BILLS-118s4994es

Bill Statistics

Size

Sections:
2
Words:
375
Pages:
4
Sentences:
13

Language

Nouns: 126
Verbs: 20
Adjectives: 17
Adverbs: 2
Numbers: 14
Entities: 32

Complexity

Average Token Length:
4.27
Average Sentence Length:
28.85
Token Entropy:
4.40
Readability (ARI):
16.57

AnalysisAI

The legislation titled the "Vicksburg National Military Park Boundary Modification Act" proposes adjusting the boundaries of the Vicksburg National Military Park located in Mississippi. The primary aim is to transfer specific parcels of federal land to the State of Mississippi without requiring payment. These land parcels are intended for public use, potentially as a welcome center, interpretive center, or museum.

General Summary of the Bill

The bill facilitates the transfer of approximately 10.14 acres of federal land from within the boundaries of the Vicksburg National Military Park to the State of Mississippi. The Secretary of the Interior is responsible for administering this conveyance without financial consideration, meaning no payment is exchanged for the land. After the transfer, the official boundaries of the park will be modified to reflect the changes. The intended use of these lands by the state includes public purposes such as a welcome center, interpretive center, or museum, aligning with the community's cultural and informational needs.

Summary of Significant Issues

One notable issue arising from this bill is the concept of "without consideration," meaning that the state acquires valuable federal property without any financial exchange. Without adequate justification, this poses questions regarding the potential loss of federal assets and whether this represents the best public interest.

Another concern is the vagueness regarding the specific use of the land. Terms like "welcome center or other public use" and "interpretive center or museum or other public use" lack precision. Such ambiguous language could lead to disagreements or legal challenges about the intended use and management of the land.

Additionally, the absence of detailed terms and conditions governing the transfer leaves the transaction open to varying interpretations and inconsistencies in enforcement. This lack of clarity could lead to administrative hurdles or disputes over land use.

Furthermore, the bill does not include mechanisms for accountability or oversight to ensure that the State of Mississippi uses the land in accordance with the bill's intent. This gap raises potential issues around ensuring that the land benefits the public as intended.

Impact on the Public and Stakeholders

For the general public, the bill holds the potential to enhance educational and cultural opportunities in Mississippi through the establishment of new public facilities. Ideally, the proposed welcome center or museum would attract visitors, boost local tourism, and contribute to the regional economy by drawing attention to the historical significance of Vicksburg.

However, by allowing land transfer without financial compensation, there might be concerns about the appropriate use of federal resources. Taxpayers may question if the federal government is adequately safeguarding its assets on their behalf.

For the State of Mississippi, the bill provides a valuable opportunity to expand public infrastructure without incurring additional costs. This could foster state-driven projects aimed at enriching visitor experiences and state tourism. On the other hand, the management and operational responsibilities for any new facility will fall on the state, potentially requiring additional funding that may need to be secured from state resources or through other grants.

The National Park Service, overseeing the Vicksburg National Military Park, might face challenges from the revised park boundaries. While the intention to enhance public access and services aligns with park service goals, the diminished acreage and lack of specified detailed terms for public undertakings could strain resources dedicated to managing remaining park lands.

In summary, while the bill could significantly benefit Mississippi, and particularly the local Vicksburg community, through increased tourism and educational facilities, careful consideration and specification are needed to ensure that the public and all stakeholders' interests are adequately protected and served.

Issues

  • The conveyance of land to the State of Mississippi 'without consideration' could lead to a loss of federal assets without corresponding public benefit, as there is no payment or compensation provided for the transfer. This is particularly significant as there is no explicit justification for the free transfer, which could raise financial concerns over federal property management. [SECTION 2(a)(1)]

  • The purpose of the land use described as 'a welcome center or other public use' and 'an interpretive center or a museum or other public use' is vague, leading to potential legal ambiguities and challenges in ensuring the land is used appropriately. Clearer definitions might be necessary to avoid conflicts over the land's utilization. [SECTION 2(a)(2)(A), SECTION 2(a)(2)(B)]

  • The lack of specified terms and conditions for the conveyance of land could result in inconsistent expectations or oversight regarding how the State of Mississippi may use the land. This lack of clarity might expose the transaction to legal or administrative issues in the future. [SECTION 2(a)(1)]

  • There is no mention of accountability measures or oversight to ensure the State uses the land according to the intended purposes, which could lead to unintended uses of the land contrary to public interest or expectations. This raises ethical and management concerns. [SECTION 2]

Sections

Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.

1. Short title Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section provides the short title for the law, which is the "Vicksburg National Military Park Boundary Modification Act".

2. Vicksburg National Military Park conveyance and boundary modification Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Secretary of the Interior is required to transfer specific pieces of land within the Vicksburg National Military Park to the State of Mississippi without any payment, allowing them to be used for public purposes like a welcome center or museum. Once the land is transferred, the boundaries of the park will be adjusted to account for these changes.