Overview
Title
To adjust the boundaries of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area to include the Scarper Ridge property.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to change the size of a park called the Golden Gate National Recreation Area by adding a new piece of land called Scarper Ridge. It's like drawing a bigger circle around the park on a map to make it bigger.
Summary AI
S. 4851 aims to change the boundaries of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area to include a location known as the Scarper Ridge property. The bill proposes an amendment to Public Law 92–589, specifically by adding a new subsection that describes the newly included land, which is identified on an official map dated July 2024. The bill was introduced by Mr. Padilla and reported by Mr. Manchin without any amendments.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Overview of the Bill
The bill, titled the "Scarper Ridge Golden Gate National Recreation Area Boundary Adjustment Act of 2024," seeks to adjust the boundaries of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area to include the Scarper Ridge property. It was introduced in the Senate and reported by the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources without amendment. The bill accomplishes its goal by amending existing legislation, specifically Public Law 92–589, to incorporate new land as depicted on a specific map.
Summary of Significant Issues
One significant issue with the bill is its reliance on a map to define the new boundaries of the recreation area. The description of the land addition in the text is vague, referencing only a map entitled "Golden Gate National Recreation Area Proposed Boundary Addition." Without clear physical boundary details, this reliance could lead to disputes or misunderstandings about the actual extent of the boundary adjustment. If the map is not easily accessible or changes over time, this could further complicate interpretation or lead to legal challenges.
Another issue with the bill is the lack of a clear explanation for the necessity of the boundary adjustment. The bill does not provide justification or specific reasoning for including the Scarper Ridge property, which could lead to questions about its merit or importance. This omission could affect garnering support from stakeholders and the public.
Furthermore, the mention of an effective date in July 2024 could introduce potential delays or confusion. If the referenced map is updated or if other legislative changes occur before or after this date, it could impact the planned implementation of the boundary adjustment.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, the inclusion of Scarper Ridge into the Golden Gate National Recreation Area could mean expanded recreational opportunities and increased access to protected natural landscapes. However, the ambiguity in the bill's description of the land could lead to uncertainty among residents and visitors regarding the areas that are open for public use.
There is also a possibility that the bill could lead to better preservation and conservation of natural habitats and provide ecological benefits. On the downside, if the process of adjusting the boundaries encounters delays due to the reasons mentioned, the public might face confusion or frustration over the availability and regulation of recreational lands.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Specific stakeholders, such as local communities, environmental groups, and land use planners, might experience both positive and negative impacts from the bill. Environmental groups may view this boundary extension as a win for conservation efforts, potentially leading to stronger protection for ecosystems within Scarper Ridge.
Conversely, those with economic or development interests in the Scarper Ridge area may oppose the boundary change, fearing restrictions on land use and potential impacts on property values. Additionally, local landowners or stakeholders seeking to develop land near the new boundaries might find themselves facing more stringent regulations and oversight.
The unclear rationale for the boundary adjustment means stakeholders lack insight into the government's long-term plans for the area, which could lead to skepticism and challenge in formulating reactions or aligning their strategies with the proposed changes. The effectiveness of addressing these concerns depends largely on how accessible and transparent the map and accompanying guidance are to the affected parties.
Issues
The amendment's description of the land addition in Section 2 is vague, as it relies solely on a map reference without clarifying physical boundary details. This lack of specificity could lead to disputes or misunderstandings about the exact extent of the boundary adjustment.
The reference to a map for land depiction in Section 2 could lead to ambiguity if the map is not readily accessible or if it changes over time, which may result in interpretation issues or legal challenges regarding the area to be incorporated.
There is no clear explanation or justification provided in Section 2 for why the boundary addition of Scarper Ridge is necessary. This omission could lead to questioning the merit or necessity of the boundary adjustment, impacting support from stakeholders or the public.
The effective date of July 2024 mentioned in Section 2 could cause delays or confusion if the map of the proposed boundary addition is updated or if additional legislative changes occur before then, which could impact planning and implementation processes.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides the short title of the Act, which is called the "Scarper Ridge Golden Gate National Recreation Area Boundary Adjustment Act of 2024."
2. Scarper Ridge boundary adjustment Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Section 2 of the bill amends Public Law 92-589 to include additional land, as shown on a specific map, into the Golden Gate National Recreation Area. The newly added land is labeled as "Proposed Boundary Addition" on this map, which is numbered 641/193973 and dated July 2024.