Overview
Title
To modernize the business of selling firearms.
ELI5 AI
The bill, called the "Federal Firearm Licensee Act," is about updating the rules for people who sell guns. It wants them to keep better records, follow new security rules, and have more inspections, while also making sure they and their employees pass background checks.
Summary AI
S. 4706, also known as the "Federal Firearm Licensee Act," aims to modernize the firearm sales business by updating regulations for firearm dealers in the United States. The bill seeks to improve security measures at firearm premises, establish more stringent record-keeping and electronic databases, and increase penalties for dealers who violate federal laws. It also calls for frequent inspections of high-risk firearm dealers and mandates background checks for both dealers and their employees. Additionally, the bill proposes the repeal of certain outdated provisions, offering enhanced enforcement capabilities to curb illegal firearm sales and trafficking.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill under consideration, titled the "Federal Firearm Licensee Act," seeks to modernize and enforce stricter regulations on the business of selling firearms. Introduced by Senator Dick Durbin and other co-sponsors, the bill covers various aspects related to firearm dealers, including enhancing physical security measures, mandating electronic record keeping, increasing penalties for violations, and expanding reporting requirements. The bill aims to update federal firearm laws, which have remained largely unchanged for over three decades, to better align them with contemporary challenges in firearm trafficking and violence prevention.
Summary of Significant Issues
One notable issue in the bill is the increase in licensing fees for firearms importers, manufacturers, dealers, and collectors. The bill doubles these fees but does not provide clear justification or explain how the additional revenue will be used, which raises concerns about fairness and the financial burden on smaller operators. Additionally, the bill mandates new security measures for firearm dealers, such as physical protections, which might be financially challenging for small to medium enterprises.
Furthermore, the bill introduces specific inspection schedules for firearm dealers without clearly defining what constitutes a "high-risk" dealer. This lack of clear criteria could lead to biases or inconsistent enforcement. Moreover, there is concern over the broad powers given to the Attorney General, particularly in hiring additional investigators and expanding enforcement operations without providing sufficient justification or details on the necessity of such measures.
Potential Impact on the Public
Overall, the bill could have a significant impact on how firearms are sold and regulated in the United States. The updated regulations and increased oversight aim to reduce illegal firearms transfers and enhance public safety by preventing instances where firearms are diverted into criminal hands. By requiring more comprehensive record-keeping and physical security measures for firearm dealers, the bill seeks to address vulnerabilities in the current system that could potentially lead to theft and misuse of firearms.
However, the increased costs associated with compliance could be passed on to consumers, potentially raising firearm prices. The changes might also lead to privacy concerns, given extended data retention periods mandated for background check records, which could affect citizens' perceptions of their personal data security.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For firearm dealers, especially small businesses, the bill's heightened security and compliance requirements could result in increased operational costs and administrative burdens. The increased licensing fees might disproportionately affect smaller dealers and collectors, who may have limited resources compared to larger entities. This could potentially result in market consolidation, where larger companies dominate due to their ability to absorb these new costs.
For regulatory agencies, the bill could enhance their ability to monitor and enforce compliance within the firearm industry. The addition of 650 industry operation investigators could improve oversight but may also lead to significant financial expenditures without clear guidelines on their deployment.
On the enforcement side, the bill proposes heavier penalties and extended authority for inspections and record-keeping, which could strengthen law enforcement efforts in tracing firearms and preventing illegal sales. However, this expanded authority might lead to concerns over due process and fair treatment, particularly if the criteria for determining liability and enforcement actions remain ambiguous.
Overall, the impact of the "Federal Firearm Licensee Act" appears to be a double-edged sword, aiming to enhance public safety and regulatory compliance while also imposing new challenges for stakeholders within the firearm industry. Balancing these objectives with fairness and transparency will be essential in ensuring the bill serves its intended purpose without causing undue harm or burden.
Financial Assessment
The proposed legislation, S. 4706, known as the "Federal Firearm Licensee Act," endeavors to modernize the business of selling firearms in the United States. Within this framework, there are several noteworthy financial aspects that merit consideration.
Licensing Fees
The bill notably proposes an increase in licensing fees for various firearms-related activities. For example, licensed importers, manufacturers, and dealers will see the fee rise from $1,000 to $2,000, while fees for other subcategories increase as well, such as from $50 to $100 and $10 to $20 depending on specific classifications. Similarly, the fees for licensed collectors are proposed to increase from $10 to $20. These raised fees likely aim to cover administrative costs associated with the updated regulatory requirements but may raise issues of fairness and financial hardship, particularly for small businesses or operators with limited financial means.
Penalties and Fines
The legislation introduces substantial penalties for non-compliance with its provisions. For instance, the Attorney General is empowered to impose a civil penalty of up to $5,000 on licensees who fail to comply with inventory certification requirements, as detailed in Section 5. Furthermore, for knowing transfers of firearms without conducting background checks, the amendments call for a potential civil fine of $20,000.
In Section 20, facilitators of firearm transfers will also face a licensing fee of $1,000 per year. This new category of licensure and its associated financial requirement may be seen as another layer of regulation that could strain individuals or small entities entering the marketplace for firearm transactions.
Civil Enforcement
In terms of civil enforcement, financial penalties for engaging in the business without proper licensure range between $2,500 and $20,000. This enforcement mechanism underscores the bill's emphasis on strict compliance but poses a substantial risk of financial burden, particularly for small, possibly inadvertent offenders who may not fully understand the regulatory landscape.
Budget for Personnel
The legislation further outlines the hiring of additional personnel to enforce these new standards. It authorizes the Attorney General to hire 650 industry operation investigators for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives. While this appears to strengthen enforcement capabilities, it raises questions about the financial implications and budgetary considerations required to support such a significant increase in workforce, as highlighted in Section 26 of the issues.
Concerns and Implications
Overall, while the bill aims to enhance regulatory oversight and safety in firearm transactions, the financial ramifications bear heavily on several fronts. Small businesses may feel the pinch from increased fees and potential penalties, affecting their operations and competitiveness. The need for extensive resources to implement and enforce these new regulations may also stretch existing financial allocations without clear justifications or identifiable funding sources.
These financial components, if not addressed with due clarity and balance, could pose challenges in achieving the bill's objectives without unduly burdening the very entities it seeks to regulate.
Issues
The bill mandates increased licensing fees for firearms-related activities without providing justification or details on how the additional revenue will be used, potentially raising concerns about fairness and financial burden on smaller operators (Section 13).
The amendment results in significant changes to the federal laws governing firearm dealers, which have not been updated in over 30 years. This lack of updates may have longstanding implications for law enforcement efforts, creating potential gaps in regulating modern firearms commerce (Section 2).
The bill establishes new security requirements for firearms dealers, including physical security measures that might be financially challenging for SMEs (Small to Medium Enterprises), potentially disadvantaging them (Section 5).
The introduction of mandatory annual inspections for high-risk licensed dealers and quinquennial inspections for others does not clearly define 'high-risk', leading to potential biases or inconsistent enforcement (Section 11).
The requirement for the Attorney General to hire 650 additional industry operation investigators could result in significant financial expenditure without clear justification, especially when considering potential overlaps with existing personnel (Section 26).
The bill expands reporting requirements to cover semiautomatic rifles and shotguns, increasing administrative burdens and potentially leading to privacy concerns due to extended data retention periods (Section 9).
The bill does not specify the criteria for what constitutes 'good cause' in various contexts, including license revocation stay and authorizing continued operations while a relief application is pending, leading to potential inconsistencies and subjective assessments (Sections 14 and 16).
The change of liability standards from 'willfully' to 'knowingly' lowers the threshold for proving wrongdoing, which could broaden the scope of liability and raise concerns over due process and fair treatment (Section 22).
The bill repeals limitations placed on firearms trace data use, raising concerns about transparency and how changes might impact privacy and data handling (Section 25).
The newly mandated security measures and civil enforcement provisions impose penalties up to $20,000, raising concerns about proportionality and potential adverse effects on small-scale businesses (Section 23).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title; table of contents Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the “Federal Firearm Licensee Act” introduces the Act's title and lists the topics covered in the Act, including regulations and requirements for firearm licensing, sales, record-keeping, and inspections among other provisions regarding firearm transactions and dealer responsibilities.
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress highlights several issues with firearm dealer regulations, noting that current federal laws are outdated, protect dealers engaging in illegal activities, and hinder law enforcement. It also points out that the Tiahrt Amendments limit vital data sharing and enforcement measures. Furthermore, there are no federal requirements for securing firearms at dealerships, leading to increased thefts. Repealing these amendments and updating laws could improve efforts to stop illegal firearms.
3. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text provides definitions related to firearms, including terms like "facilitator," which refers to someone running a marketplace for gun transactions, "occasional," defining transactions fewer than five times a year, and descriptions of firearms parts like "frame" and "receiver." It also clarifies when a firearm is considered part of a "personal collection" and describes what constitutes a "business inventory firearm."
4. Repeal of temporary Brady provision Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section repeals a temporary provision from the Brady law, specifically subsection (s) of Section 922 in the United States Code. It also updates related sections in the law to ensure consistency by removing references to the repealed subsection and clarifying the definition of "chief law enforcement officer."
5. Physical security of licensee premises Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the bill, it requires firearm dealers to submit a security plan for protecting their business premises, which must be approved for license renewal, and mandates an annual certification to confirm compliance with security regulations. If these rules are not followed, the dealer faces possible fines and suspension of their license.
Money References
- — “(1) IN GENERAL.—Each licensed manufacturer, licensed importer, and licensed dealer shall— “(A) annually certify to the Attorney General that each premises from which the licensee conducts business subject to license under this chapter is in compliance with the regulations prescribed under section 926(d); and “(B) in the case of a licensed dealer, include with the certification under subparagraph (A)— “(i) the results of a reconciliation of the resale firearms then in the business inventory of the licensee against the resale firearms in the business inventory of the licensee at the time of the most recent prior certification (if any) under this paragraph; and “(ii) all dispositions and acquisitions of resale firearms in the year covered by the certification, identifying and reporting any missing firearm. “(2) CIVIL PENALTY.—The Attorney General shall impose a civil penalty of not more than $5,000 on, and may suspend the license issued under this section to, a licensee who fails to comply with paragraph (1).”. (2) APPLICABILITY.—In the case of a person who, on the date of enactment of this Act, is a licensee referred to in section 923(m) of title 18, United States Code (as added by paragraph (1)), such section 923(m) shall apply to the person on and after the date that is 1 year after the date on which regulations are prescribed under subsection (d) of section 926 of that title (as added by subsection (c)(1)). (c) Regulations.— (1) IN GENERAL.—Section 926 of title 18, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following: “(d) Securing premises from theft.—The Attorney General shall prescribe such regulations as are necessary to ensure that any premises at which a licensee referred to in section 923(m) conducts business is secure from theft, which shall include requiring— “(1) compliance with the security plan submitted by the licensee pursuant to section 923(d)(1)(G)(ii)(I), if applicable; “(2) the use of locked metal cabinets and fireproof safes; “(3) security systems, video monitoring, and anti-theft alarms; “(4) security gates, strong locks, and site hardening; “(5) concrete bollards and other access controls, if necessary; and “(6) the use of any other security-enhancing features appropriate for the specific circumstances of the licensee.”
6. Business inventory firearms Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines new requirements for licensed firearms dealers, manufacturers, and importers. They now must transfer firearms from personal collections to their business inventory before selling them and conduct quarterly physical inventories, reporting any missing firearms to authorities. Previous restrictions preventing mandatory inventory checks have been repealed, and new regulations will be established to ensure compliance.
7. Electronic records Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed changes to U.S. law in this section focus on enhancing the management and tracking of firearm sales and records. They include requiring electronic record-keeping and searchable databases for firearms records, mandating video surveillance at gun selling premises, increasing penalties for record-keeping violations, and removing restrictions on centralizing records.
8. Notification of default transfers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends U.S. law to require that when a firearm is transferred under certain conditions, the licensee must inform the Attorney General by the end of the business day that the transfer has occurred.
9. Multiple firearm sales records and reports Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed changes to the law aim to expand the reporting requirements for multiple firearm sales to include semiautomatic rifles and shotguns with high-capacity magazines, require retention of instant criminal background check records for 90 business days, and instruct the Attorney General to report multiple sales to persons not licensed. It also mandates longer retention of records related to crime guns to aid in investigations.
10. Safety devices and warnings to purchasers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed changes to Section 922(z) of title 18, United States Code, require licensed firearm dealers to post and distribute safety warnings to buyers, as per state and local laws. Additionally, the Attorney General will create and supply materials on topics like suicide prevention and secure storage, which dealers must share when selling firearms.
11. Inspections Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill outlines new inspection requirements for licensed firearm dealers, mandating annual checks for high-risk dealers and every five years for others. It also removes previous limits on inspecting dealer records, introduces mandatory security inspections for dealers reporting lost or stolen firearms, and gives the Attorney General authority to oversee compliance with firearm sales laws.
12. Authority with regards to license issuance and renewal Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text outlines modifications to Section 923 of title 18 in the United States Code, granting the Attorney General more authority to deny, revoke, or suspend firearm licenses if they pose a public safety risk or if the applicants are not suitable, and repeals certain funding restrictions related to denying licenses due to inactivity. It also extends rule-making authority to allow for broader regulation of firearms licenses.
13. Increased licensing fees Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill proposes to double the licensing fees for importers, manufacturers, and dealers of firearms and ammunition. It also increases the fees for licensed collectors of firearms.
Money References
- (a) Fees for licensed importers, manufacturers, and dealers in firearms and importers and manufacturers of ammunition.—Section 923(a) of title 18, United States Code, is amended— (1) in paragraph (1)— (A) in subparagraph (A), by striking “$1,000” and inserting “$2,000”; (B) in subparagraph (B), by striking “$50” and inserting “$100”; and (C) in subparagraph (C), by striking “$10” and inserting “$20”; (2) in paragraph (2)— (A) in subparagraph (A), by striking “$1,000” and inserting “$2,000”; and (B) in subparagraph (B), by striking “$50” and inserting “$100”; and (3) in paragraph (3)— (A) in subparagraph (A), by striking “$1,000” and inserting “$2,000”; and (B) in subparagraph (B)— (i) by striking “$200” and inserting “$400”; and (ii) by striking “$90” and inserting “$180”. (b) Fees for licensed collectors.—Section 923(b) of title 18, United States Code, is amended by striking “$10” and inserting “$20”. ---
14. Elimination of obligatory stay of effective date of license revocation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the U.S. law regarding the revocation of licenses by changing the rule that previously required an automatic delay if the license holder requested it. Now, a license holder must show a good reason for the delay to be granted.
15. Elimination of relief for dealers indicted for a crime punishable by imprisonment for a term exceeding one year Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section of the bill removes the relief previously available to firearm dealers who were indicted for crimes punishable by over a year of imprisonment. Additionally, it makes conforming amendments to the United States Code and related acts by updating references to the renumbered subsections in Section 925.
16. Elimination of relief while Federal disability relief application pending Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to Section 925(b) of title 18, United States Code, allows the Attorney General to let a licensee continue their business operations while waiting for a decision on their disability relief application, as long as they can show good cause.
17. Presumption of knowledge of State law in sale of long guns to residents of another State Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Section 17 of the bill proposes a change to the United States Code that affects the sale of long guns to people from different states. It removes the phrase "in the absence of evidence to the contrary," which previously suggested that sellers were assumed to know the state's laws unless proven otherwise.
18. Increased penalties for knowing transfer of firearm without conducting a background check Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section increases the penalties for transferring a firearm without a background check. For the first violation, the penalty remains unchanged, but for any further violations, the licensee's license can be suspended or revoked, and they may face a $20,000 fine.
Money References
- Section 922(t)(5) of title 18, United States Code, is amended by inserting before the period at the end the following: “in the case of the first violation and, in the case of a subsequent violation, shall immediately suspend or revoke any license issued to the licensee under section 923 and impose on the licensee a civil fine equal to $20,000”.
19. Unlawful acts upon incurring Federal disability or notice of license suspension, revocation, or denied renewal Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text adds new rules to U.S. law, making it illegal for licensed gun dealers who face federal legal issues or whose licenses are suspended or revoked to move guns from business inventory to personal use or to non-licensed individuals. If the dealer shows a good reason, the Attorney General can allow exceptions. Violators can face up to a year in prison and/or fines.
20. Regulation of facilitators of firearm transfers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill proposes new regulations for facilitators of firearm transfers, requiring them to obtain a license for a fee of $1,000 per year and follow specific duties, such as ensuring firearm sales occur through a licensed dealer and keeping detailed records of transactions. Additionally, violations of these regulations could result in fines or imprisonment, and the bill includes several amendments to existing laws to incorporate the role of licensed facilitators in firearm transactions.
Money References
- (a) Licensing.—Section 923(a) of title 18, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following: “(4) If the applicant is a facilitator of firearm sales, purchases, or other transfers, a fee of $1,000 per year.”
21. Dealer and employee background checks Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines new requirements for background checks before issuing or renewing firearm dealer licenses and allowing dealer employees to handle firearms, stating that the national instant criminal background check system must first confirm there are no legal issues. It also mandates that the NICS system must perform these checks and search the National Data Exchange database.
22. Liability standards Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, the bill proposes changes to the United States Code by replacing the term "willfully" with "knowingly" in various parts of sections 923 and 924 of title 18, which affects how liability is determined in licensing and penalties related to firearms. This change means that in these legal contexts, a person's awareness and understanding of their actions will now be considered, rather than requiring proof that they were done intentionally or purposefully.
23. Civil enforcement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the penalties for violating firearm business regulations. It mandates fines for conducting business without a license and introduces escalating penalties for licensed dealers who repeatedly break rules, including fines, license suspension, or revocation, with harsher penalties for gross negligence and immediate actions if they present a risk to public safety.
Money References
- (a) Fines for engaging in the business without a license.—Section 924(n) of title 18, United States Code, is amended— (1) by inserting “(1)” after “(n)”; and (2) by adding at the end the following: “(2) If the Attorney General finds that a person has engaged in conduct that constitutes a violation of section 922(a)(1)(A), the Attorney General shall— “(A) transmit to the person a written notice specifying the violation, which shall include a copy of the provision of law violated; and “(B) impose on the person a civil penalty in an amount that is not less than $2,500 and not more than $20,000.”
- — “(1) IN GENERAL.—If the Attorney General finds a licensed dealer to be in violation of a regulation prescribed under section 926, the Attorney General shall— “(A) if the violation is not a result of gross negligence by the licensed dealer— “(i) in the case of the first such violation by the licensed dealer, if not preceded by a violation to which subparagraph (B) applies, transmit to the licensed dealer a written notice specifying the violation, which shall include a copy of the regulation violated; “(ii) in the case of the second such violation by the licensed dealer, if not preceded by a violation to which subparagraph (B) applies, impose a civil penalty in an amount that is not less than $2,500 and not more than $20,000; “(iii) in the case of the third such violation by the licensed dealer, if not preceded by a violation to which subparagraph (B) applies, suspend the license to deal in firearms issued to the licensed dealer under this chapter until the violation ceases; “(iv) in the case of the fourth such violation by the licensed dealer, whether or not preceded by a violation to which subparagraph (B) applies, revoke the license; or “(v) in the case of any such violation by the licensed dealer, if preceded by a violation to which subparagraph (B) applies, apply the penalty authorized under this subsection that is 1 level greater in severity than the level of severity of the penalty most recently applied to the licensed dealer under this subsection; or “(B) if the violation is a result of gross negligence by the licensed dealer— “(i) in the case of the first such violation by the licensed dealer, impose a civil penalty in an amount that is not less than $2,500 and not more than $20,000; “(ii) in the case of the second such violation by the licensed dealer— “(I) impose a civil penalty in an amount equal to $20,000; and “(II) suspend the license to deal in firearms issued to the licensed dealer under this chapter until the violation ceases; or “(iii) in the case of the third such violation by the licensed dealer, revoke the license to deal in firearms issued to the licensed dealer under this chapter.
24. Removal of bar on civil proceedings if criminal proceedings terminated Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends U.S. law to remove a part of the law that stopped civil lawsuits from moving forward if there were ongoing criminal cases that had ended.
25. Repeal of certain limitations Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section of the bill removes limits on the use of gun trace data from previous years' appropriations acts, takes away restrictions on consolidating firearm information records, and ensures that criminal background check records are destroyed within 24 hours.
26. Authority to hire additional industry operation investigators for Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Attorney General has the authority to hire 650 new industry operation investigators for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives. These investigators will be distributed across various field divisions to align with the number and location of licensed individuals, in addition to any other necessary personnel.
27. Report on implementation of this Act Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Attorney General is required to provide Congress with a report within two years after this Act becomes law. This report should cover how the Act is being implemented, any additional resources needed, actions for regular inspections, and the enforcement of rules against gun dealers who do not comply.
28. Annual licensed dealer inspections report and analysis Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill requires the Attorney General to submit a yearly report to Congress and the public about inspections of firearm dealers, pawnbrokers, and manufacturers, starting two years after the bill is enacted. The report will detail the number and type of inspections, time spent on inspections, security inspections prompted by reports of lost or stolen firearms, and any violations found, along with actions taken like suspending or revoking licenses.
29. Deadline for issuance of final regulations Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Attorney General is required to issue all necessary regulations to implement this Act and its amendments within two years from when the Act becomes law.