Overview
Title
To direct the Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of Agriculture to encourage and expand the use of prescribed fire on land managed by the Department of the Interior or the Forest Service, with an emphasis on units of the National Forest System in the western United States, to acknowledge and support the long-standing use of cultural burning by Tribes and Indigenous practitioners, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to use fire on purpose to help take care of forests, especially in the West of the U.S., by learning from Native cultures that have done this for a long time. It gives money and support to make this happen safely, but needs to be careful with spending and safety rules.
Summary AI
S. 4424 aims to expand the use of prescribed fire by the Department of the Interior and the Forest Service, particularly focusing on the National Forest System in the western U.S. The bill supports the traditional fire management practices of Tribes and Indigenous practitioners. It establishes frameworks for collaboration, funding, and workforce development to increase the use of prescribed fire and related activities. Additionally, it encourages coordination between federal, state, and tribal agencies to facilitate these practices while providing education and addressing liability concerns.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The National Prescribed Fire Act of 2024 is a legislative proposal aimed at improving forest management and reducing wildfire risk through the use of prescribed fires. This bill directs the Secretaries of the Interior and Agriculture to expand prescribed fire practices, acknowledging cultural burning by Tribes and Indigenous communities as integral. While seeking to manage land effectively, improve ecosystem health, and cut down wildfire risks, the bill allocates substantial funding and proposes a series of collaborative and educational initiatives.
General Summary of the Bill
The bill encompasses a comprehensive framework for employing prescribed fires. It includes setting up prescribed fire accounts with a yearly budget, enforcing policies and practices to increase prescribed fires, establishing a collaborative fire program, enhancing human resources, and conducting environmental reviews. It also lays out liability protections for fire managers and sets up a prescribed fire education program. The overarching goal is to foster a safer, more proactive approach to fire management across federal lands, emphasizing cooperation among various agencies and stakeholders.
Summary of Significant Issues
One of the key concerns is the substantial financial budget of $300,000,000 allocated annually without clear oversight and performance measures, potentially leading to financial mismanagement. Another issue is the environmental review section, which grants exemptions for prescribed fires over 1,000 acres from certain pollution controls, raising the risk of potential environmental harm. Moreover, the bill provides significant legal indemnities to fire managers except in cases of gross negligence, which could suggest leniency toward safety protocols.
Additionally, the bill mandates a 10% annual increase in prescribed fires without solid ecological justification, which may create unnecessary environmental impacts. The proposed human resource strategies, such as converting seasonal to permanent employees with potential bonuses, lack clear criteria, possibly leading to inequitable treatment or favoritism.
Potential Impact on the Public
The general public could benefit from reduced wildfire risks and improved air quality in the long term due to better land management practices. By encouraging the use of prescribed fires, the bill aims to alleviate future fire suppression costs and promote healthier ecosystems. However, the public may have concerns about potential environmental impacts due to the mandated increase in fire activities and the exemptions from pollution controls.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Federal and State Agencies: The bill requires extensive collaboration across federal, state, and local levels, which could strain resources and require significant coordination efforts.
Tribal and Indigenous Communities: The recognition and support for cultural burning practices bring a positive acknowledgment of Indigenous contributions to ecological management, potentially fostering greater inclusion and collaboration.
Fire Management Professionals: The liability protections and potential bonuses could attract and retain skilled individuals in the fire management workforce. However, they risk facing public and legal scrutiny if safety standards are perceived as compromised.
Environmental Groups: These organizations might express concern over potential ecological impacts due to increased and larger-scale fires, especially with exemptions from pollution control regulations.
Local Communities: While prescribed fire practices could protect communities from severe wildfires, there may be apprehension about smoke and air quality issues, particularly if large-scale fires are exempt from oversight.
Overall, the bill attempts to address critical issues in forest management but demands careful implementation and robust oversight to balance the diverse interests of stakeholders while mitigating potential risks.
Financial Assessment
The bill S. 4424 includes several financial allocations and appropriations designed to support the implementation of prescribed fire practices on Federal and associated lands. This commentary highlights these allocations and their relation to identified issues with the bill.
Summary of Financial Allocations
The bill authorizes $300,000,000 annually for establishing "Prescribed Fire Accounts" with the Department of Agriculture and the Department of the Interior. This funding is intended to support prescribed fire activities, including environmental reviews, public outreach, staffing, equipment, and post-fire activities.
Additionally, the bill sets a cap of $20,000,000 per fiscal year for the "Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program," a program aimed at funding prescribed fire projects. Each individual project within this program may receive up to $1,000,000 per fiscal year.
There is also a provision for up to $1,000,000 to be allocated under a memorandum of agreement to address liability protection and state legislation incentives.
Financial Allocation Issues
Lack of Performance Benchmarks
One of the major concerns is the substantial allocation of $300,000,000 annually without clear performance benchmarks. The bill includes no specific criteria to evaluate how this money will be spent or the expected outcomes, raising concerns about potential financial mismanagement. Proper accountability measures are essential to ensure that funds are used effectively and efficiently, fulfilling the bill's intended purposes.
Liability and Indemnities
The bill provides financial support to address liability concerns but permits significant indemnities against legal actions, except in cases of gross negligence. This aspect, lacking the accompanying financial implications, could inadvertently lead to less rigorous safety standards, with funds being used less prudently than might be desired.
Prescribed Fire Education Program
There are financial allocations mentioned for an education program, but the bill lacks detailed guidance or metrics for success. Without specific budget allocations or expected outcomes, there is a risk of uncontrolled spending that fails to yield meaningful benefits or improve practices related to prescribed fire.
Incentives and Workforce Retention
The bill proposes using funds for salaries and bonuses as incentives, particularly in converting seasonal firefighters to permanent positions. While aimed at retention, the absence of clear guidelines could result in inequitable distribution of resources, and possibly favoritism, rather than a strategic enhancement of the workforce.
Project Funding Limitations
The funding caps set at $1,000,000 per project under the Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program may not be sufficient for large-scale projects that span multiple jurisdictions, potentially limiting the scope and effectiveness of what can be achieved with these financial allocations.
In conclusion, while S. 4424 provides significant financial resources for prescribed fire activities, it also raises questions about financial management, sustainability, and the strategic use of funds. Ensuring clarity in performance measures, liability protocols, and workforce incentives is crucial to achieving the bill's objectives and maintaining prudent financial oversight.
Issues
The bill authorizes a significant amount of funding ($300,000,000 annually) under 'Sec 101: Prescribed fire accounts' without specifying clear performance benchmarks or accountability measures for how this money will be spent or the expected outcomes, raising concerns about potential financial mismanagement.
The section on 'Environmental Review' (Sec 205) outlines exemptions for large prescribed fires which could lead to insufficient oversight and potential environmental harm, as fires over 1,000 acres are exempt from certain pollution control requirements.
The 'Liability of Certified Prescribed Fire Managers' (Sec 203) allows for significant indemnities against legal actions, except in cases of gross negligence. This may encourage less rigorous safety protocols, potentially leading to legal and ethical issues if fires escape control.
The 'Human Resources' section (Sec 202) proposes using salaries and bonuses as incentives without clear guidelines, potentially leading to wasteful spending or inequitable distribution, notably as it aims to convert seasonal to permanent employees, risking favoritism.
The 'Policies and Practices' section (Sec 102) mandates an annual 10% increase in prescribed fires without clear scientific or ecological justification, potentially leading to unnecessary environmental impacts or budgetary strain.
The bill lacks detailed guidance on 'Prescribed Fire Education Program' (Sec 206) implementation, including budget specifics or metrics for success, which could lead to uncontrolled spending and ineffectiveness.
There is potential concern about the consistency of definitions across sections, for example, 'Federal Land' and 'National Forest System' rely heavily on external references which may confuse stakeholders without legal expertise.
The 'Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program' (Sec 104) sets funding caps per project at $1,000,000 which may not be adequate for extensive prescribed fire projects requiring greater financial support across multiple jurisdictions.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title; table of contents Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The "National Prescribed Fire Act of 2024" outlines a comprehensive framework, including a short title and table of contents, which organizes various sections such as the use of funds, cooperative agreements, human resources, liability issues, environmental reviews, education programs, and detailed reporting provisions related to prescribed fires.
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress has identified that a significant amount of U.S. forest land is at high risk for wildfires and notes the benefits of cultural and prescribed burning in reducing wildfire costs and health impacts. They highlight the need for better education, regulation, and liability frameworks across different states to promote the responsible use of prescribed fires.
3. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions for terms used in the Act, such as "Federal land," which includes public lands and areas like national parks and forests, and "landscape-scale prescribed fire plan," a document for managing fire on certain federal lands. It also defines "National Forest System," excluding national grasslands, "prescribed fire" as controlled burning to manage land, and explains who the "Secretaries" and "Secretary" refer to in the context of the Interior and Agriculture departments.
101. Prescribed fire accounts Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes prescribed fire accounts for the Departments of Agriculture and the Interior, authorizing $300 million annually to manage prescribed fires, which are controlled burns used to improve ecosystem health and reduce wildfire risk. It requires collaboration with state, local, and Tribal governments to develop fire strategies, prioritize funding for important areas, and track progress, while also allowing for support of fire management on non-federal lands.
Money References
- (c) Authorization of appropriations.—There is authorized to be appropriated to the accounts established by subsection (b) a total of $300,000,000 for fiscal year 2024 and each fiscal year thereafter.
102. Policies and practices Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that starting from the first fiscal year after this law is passed, for the next nine years, the Secretaries must carry out more prescribed fires on Federal land, increasing both the number and total size by 10% compared to the previous year.
103. Collaborative prescribed fire program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program established by the Secretary of the Interior to financially assist various entities, such as government agencies and organizations, in conducting prescribed fires on priority landscapes. Limitations are set on funding amounts, and recipients must meet annual targets and provide training while reporting progress and fund usage; appropriations are authorized at $10 million annually from 2024 to 2033.
Money References
- Secretary may not provide more than $20,000,000 in total funding under the program in any fiscal year.
- (2) PROJECT FUNDING.—The Secretary may not provide more than $1,000,000 to any 1 project under the program in any fiscal year.
- — (1) PROJECT REPORTING.—A recipient of financial assistance under the program shall annually submit to the Secretary a report summarizing, at a minimum— (A) the number of acres mitigated with prescribed fire by the recipient under the program; (B) the amount of Federal and non-Federal funds used by the recipient under the program; and (C) the status and progress of any collaborative relationships associated with the project. (2) PROGRAM REPORTING.—Not later than 2 years after the first fiscal year in which funding is made available to carry out prescribed fires under the program, and every 2 years thereafter, the Secretary shall submit to the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources of the Senate and the Committee on Natural Resources of the House of Representatives a report on the program. (g) Authorization of appropriations.—There is authorized to be appropriated to carry out this section $10,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2024 through 2033, to remain available until expended. ---
201. Cooperative agreements and contracts Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section allows the Secretaries to make agreements or contracts with eligible entities such as states, tribes, and NGOs to manage prescribed fires on federal land. These entities can act on behalf of the Secretaries, and contracts can last up to 10 years, but no project can start without written approval from the Secretaries.
202. Human resources Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed bill section aims to develop and support a workforce specialized in prescribed fires by highlighting the need for broad and inclusive training, increasing workforce retention through pay incentives and benefits, and ensuring the hiring and employment opportunities for diverse groups, including women, veterans, formerly incarcerated individuals, and Indigenous organizations. Additionally, it outlines protective indemnity measures for practitioners, plans for new training centers, and the enhancement of cooperation between Federal and non-Federal fire practitioners.
203. Liability of certified prescribed fire managers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines a "covered law" as a state law that sets a higher standard of "gross negligence" for civil suits against certified prescribed fire managers if they follow specific safety measures during a prescribed fire, such as obtaining permits and following fire plans. It also allows for funding up to $1,000,000 for an agreement to host a conference to discuss liability and incentives for states to enact such laws.
Money References
- (c) Funding.—The Secretary may provide not more than $1,000,000 under the memorandum of agreement under subsection (b). ---
204. Prescribed fire claims fund study Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text directs a study to be done within a year of the Act's enactment by key government officials to evaluate the possibility and design of a national fund for prescribed fire claims. This study will look into issues like the fund's feasibility, how it would work alongside existing insurance, how claims would be managed, and State laws regarding practitioner liability.
205. Environmental review Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines policies for smoke management in prescribed fires, emphasizing coordination between federal, state, tribal, and local agencies to ensure health and safety while facilitating these fires. It includes provisions for funding use, exceptional event demonstrations, exemptions for large prescribed fires, approval and enforcement of state or tribal standards, evaluation and research, development of landscape-scale fire plans, and requires collaboration and consultation with various stakeholders, including Indian Tribes, with compliance to environmental laws.
206. Prescribed fire education program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes a national education program about prescribed fires, which will be overseen by the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of the Office of Wildland Fire. The program may include public ads, social media, educational campaigns, commercial licensing, character appearances, and awards.
301. Annual reports to the National Fire Planning and Operations Database Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section mandates that states in the U.S. must report their use of prescribed fires to the National Fire Planning and Operations Database each year to qualify for financial support. If a state fails to report by December 31, it will not be eligible for funding for the prior year.
302. Annual implementation report Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires that within one year of the law being passed, and every year after that, each Secretary must provide Congress with a report detailing what activities have been performed under this law.
1. Short title; table of contents Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The National Prescribed Fire Act of 2024 is a bill that outlines the use of prescribed fires for managing forests and preventing wildfires. It includes sections on how funding should be used, collaboration efforts, legal responsibilities, and educational programs, with the goal of improving fire management practices and reporting.
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this Act, several terms are defined: "congressional committees" refers to specific committees in the Senate and House of Representatives; "Federal land" includes land managed by the Secretary or part of the National Forest System; a "landscape-scale prescribed fire plan" is a document for managing fires in specific natural areas; "National Forest System" has a legal definition but excludes certain lands; "prescribed fire" is a planned fire for managing land; "Secretaries" refers to both the Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of Agriculture; "Secretary" means the Secretary of the Interior; and "Secretary concerned" refers to either the Interior or Agriculture Secretaries depending on the land in question.
101. Definition of prescribed fire Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, the term "prescribed fire" is defined as it is in section 2, but it specifically does not include fires started mainly for the purpose of pile burning.
102. Prescribed fire funding Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section authorizes the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Department of the Interior to use up to 15% of their funds for managing hazardous fuels to support prescribed fire activities, such as contracts, grants, and training, benefiting both Federal and non-Federal lands. It also outlines prioritization criteria for funding projects that cover large areas, involve multiple lands, are near communities or Tribal lands, face high wildfire risks, have critical habitats, or support strategic fire response planning.
103. Policies and practices Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires that starting from the first fiscal year after the act is passed, and continuing for nine more years, prescribed fires must be increased by 10% each year on Federal land. Additionally, the Secretary must collaborate with various governments to create a strategy for each region that identifies fire deficits and the necessary resources to handle them.
104. Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Collaborative Prescribed Fire Program aims to identify and fund forest fire management projects that follow environmental laws and use community collaboration to restore and maintain ecosystems. The project proposals must demonstrate clear plans for reducing wildfire risks, improving wildlife habitats, leveraging non-federal investment, and supporting local economies; selected projects are subject to funding limits and performance targets.
Money References
- — (1) TOTAL FUNDING.—The Secretary concerned shall not provide more than $20,000,000 in total funding for projects under the program in any fiscal year.
- (2) PROJECT SIZE LIMITATION.—The Secretary concerned shall not provide more than $1,000,000 for any 1 project under the program in any fiscal year.
- , the Secretary concerned may use to carry out this section not more than $10,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2025 through 2034.
201. Cooperative agreements and contracts Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines "eligible entities" that can enter into cooperative agreements or contracts with the Secretary, which may include states, Indian Tribes, local governments, fire districts, nongovernmental organizations, and private entities. These agreements allow these entities to plan or conduct prescribed fires on federal land for up to 10 years, and they might subcontract these tasks as long as they follow the Secretary's terms.
202. Human resources Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text outlines plans for improving the prescribed fire workforce, including providing hazard pay, offering incentive payments for specific tasks, and allowing seasonal firefighters to become permanent employees. It also highlights initiatives to employ formerly incarcerated individuals and veterans, enhance training opportunities, and foster cooperation between Federal and non-Federal fire practitioners.
203. Liability of prescribed fire managers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section outlines the definitions and liability protections related to prescribed fire managers, including the roles of Federal and non-Federal entities, and the establishment of a memorandum with Governors to discuss liability laws. It also details training for employees on liability protections, the consideration of non-Federal entities as Federal employees for certain legal purposes, and the requirement for annual funding requests for liability reimbursements.
Money References
- (2) FUNDING.—The Secretary may provide not more than $1,000,000 under the memorandum of agreement under paragraph (1). (c) Indemnity of Federal and Tribal
204. Prescribed fire claims fund study Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section mandates a study on the possibility and design of a national fund to support prescribed fires, which are controlled burns used for land management. It will assess how this fund could improve the use of prescribed fires, consider its design and administration, and explore how it might work alongside private insurance, focusing on making it accessible and fair for all practitioners, while also examining the influence of state liability laws.
205. Environmental review Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section discusses plans to enhance the safe use and management of prescribed fire to prevent wildfires while considering public health and safety. It emphasizes collaboration among federal, state, tribal, and local agencies, investment in research for improving smoke management, and the development of large-scale prescribed fire plans with environmental compliance and input from various stakeholders, including Indian Tribes.
206. Prescribed fire education program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes a program where the Secretaries will conduct a national education initiative about prescribed fires, focusing on their ecological roles and how they are planned and carried out. This program may include elements like public service ads, social media use, educational campaigns, commercial licensing, character appearances, and awards.
301. Annual reports to the National Fire Planning and Operations Database Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires states to report their annual prescribed fire activities to a national database by December 31 each year. If they do not, they will not be eligible for federal funds for the previous year, although they can receive financial help to cover reporting costs if funds are available.
302. Annual implementation report Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Secretaries to submit a yearly report to the congressional committees, detailing the activities conducted under the Act, starting one year after the Act becomes law.