Overview
Title
To support National Science Foundation education and professional development relating to artificial intelligence.
ELI5 AI
The bill is like a big plan to help more people learn about robots and computers. It gives money for school and says schools should work with tech companies to teach people about smart machines, especially in places where there aren't many schools.
Summary AI
S. 4394 aims to enhance education and professional development in artificial intelligence (AI) across the United States. The bill proposes various initiatives through the National Science Foundation, including scholarships and fellowships for students and professionals in AI-related fields. It encourages the development of partnerships between educational institutions and industry for AI education and emphasizes the importance of AI in rural and underserved areas. Additionally, the bill supports research on AI teaching models, the establishment of AI centers of excellence, and guidance on AI introduction in schools.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The NSF AI Education Act of 2024 is a legislative proposal aimed at enhancing education and professional development in the field of artificial intelligence (AI) through a series of scholarship programs, fellowships, grants, and outreach initiatives led by the National Science Foundation. The bill seeks to encourage the study of AI and its applications across various disciplines and sectors, such as agriculture, education, and advanced manufacturing. Additionally, it addresses emerging technologies like quantum hybrid computing and quantum information science. The legislation intends to foster collaboration between educational institutions and industry while prioritizing outreach to underserved and rural areas.
General Summary
The bill introduces several scholarship programs targeting both undergraduate and graduate students wishing to study AI and related fields. For undergraduates, scholarships cover tuition and other expenses for up to four years, with a preference for students from rural or Tribal institutions. Similarly, graduate scholarships offer funding for three years, focusing on AI applications in agriculture and manufacturing. The bill also lays out plans for professional development fellowships to bridge the gap between academia and industry in AI and emerging technologies.
To enhance AI education, the bill proposes establishing Centers of AI Excellence at community colleges and vocational schools. It supports AI training programs at land-grant colleges and universities and seeks to increase the availability of quantum-related educational opportunities. Moreover, it mandates a nationwide outreach campaign to promote AI and quantum education, with emphasis on reaching underserved communities.
Significant Issues
The bill presents several notable issues. Firstly, Sections 3, 4, 5, and 7 grant extensive discretion to the National Science Foundation's Director in awarding scholarships and fellowships, lacking detailed criteria for merit-based or need-based decisions. This could result in inconsistencies or favoritism. The definitions section heavily references external legislation, which might limit its accessibility to those unfamiliar with legal jargon. Terms like "quantum hybrid computing" and "prompt engineering" are used without clear elaboration, potentially leading to varied interpretations.
The outreach focus on underserved and rural areas is commendable, yet the bill does not define clear criteria for identifying these regions, risking inconsistent resource allocation. Budgetary matters across various sections lack specified limits, raising concerns about potential financial mismanagement. Finally, the restriction on funding entities found in violation of civil rights since 2020 is sensible but lacks an effective monitoring mechanism.
Potential Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill could positively impact education and expertise in AI, providing individuals with financial support to pursue these fast-growing fields. By investing in a tech-savvy workforce, the legislation could drive innovation and potentially create job opportunities in AI-related sectors. Such developments could enhance the U.S.'s competitiveness in global technology arenas.
Yet, the bill's execution requires careful attention to transparency and fairness to ensure it benefits a diverse population. If poorly managed, discretionary funding could lead to perceptions of bias or inequity, potentially undermining trust in the program.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
The bill may benefit students pursuing AI education by easing financial burdens and enhancing career prospects. Educational institutions, especially community colleges and land-grant universities, could gain resources to expand their AI offerings and infrastructure. Industry partners may have the opportunity to collaborate with academia on cutting-edge research, gaining a competitive edge.
However, stakeholders in urban areas might feel overlooked due to the prioritization of rural and Tribal regions. Without clear definitions and fair implementation criteria, smaller institutions might struggle to compete effectively for these resources. Additionally, without substantial oversight, there remains a risk that influential organizations could disproportionately benefit from donations or partnerships enabled by the bill.
In summary, while the bill proposes significant advancements in AI education and development, the issues outlined call for careful implementation and ongoing evaluation to ensure equitable and effective outcomes.
Issues
The bill provides significant discretion to the Director of the National Science Foundation in awarding scholarships and fellowships without specific criteria detailed in Sections 3, 4, 5, and 7, potentially leading to inconsistencies, favoritism, or bias in the distribution of funds.
The definitions in Section 2 rely heavily on external laws and acts, like the William M. (Mac) Thornberry National Defense Authorization Act and the Higher Education Act, which can hinder accessibility and comprehension for stakeholders not familiar with these legal references.
The lack of specified eligibility criteria or minimum qualifications for applicants under Sections 4 and 7 may result in inequity or misuse of funds, as deserving candidates might be overlooked in favor of less qualified ones.
Sections 5 and 9 do not define key terms such as 'prompt engineering' and 'focus area,' which could lead to varied interpretations and implementation outcomes, potentially affecting fairness and consistency in application processes.
The references to 'quantum hybrid computing' and 'quantum-related positions' in Sections 4 and 7 are vague, without clear definitions or guidelines, possibly confusing stakeholders about what is covered under these terms.
The prioritization of outreach to underserved and rural areas in Sections 8 and 9 lacks clear criteria for identifying these regions, which could lead to ineffective implementation and inconsistent targeting of resources.
The budgetary aspects of Sections 5, 6, 8, and 14 are not well-defined, as there are no specified caps or limits, which could lead to uncontrolled spending or financial inefficiency.
Section 15's reliance on sufficient appropriations without clear definition or process for determining sufficiency may cause delays or incomplete implementation if funds are inadequate.
Section 18's restrictions on awarding funds to institutions found in violation of civil rights legislation makes sense but lacks monitoring and enforcement mechanisms, potentially rendering it ineffective.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act declares that it can be officially called the "NSF AI Education Act of 2024".
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section provides definitions for various terms used in the Act, including concepts like "artificial intelligence," "community college," and "STEM," as well as types of institutions such as "emerging research institution," "historically Black college and university," and "Tribal College or University." It also covers specific terms related to labor organizations and advanced technologies like "quantum hybrid computing."
3. Undergraduate scholarships for artificial intelligence education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section details a scholarship program where the Director will award undergraduate scholarships for students to study in fields related to artificial intelligence (AI). These fields include AI development, its application in areas like quantum computing, agriculture, education, and advanced manufacturing. Scholarships will cover tuition and related costs for four years, with special preference for students attending rural or Tribal colleges for agriculture-related studies.
4. Graduate scholarships and fellowships for artificial intelligence education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that the Director will offer merit- or need-based scholarships to graduate students for studying artificial intelligence and its various applications, such as in quantum computing, agriculture, education, and advanced manufacturing. These scholarships will cover tuition, fees, and a stipend, and will be given for three years through grants to universities, with preference for students in rural or tribal institutions.
5. NSF artificial intelligence professional development fellowships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes a program led by the Director to foster collaboration between higher education and industry in artificial intelligence and emerging technologies. It includes offering merit-based fellowships to professionals for training in AI, prompt engineering, or quantum hybrid computing, covering tuition, fees, and a stipend, paid directly to the participating educational institution.
6. Artificial intelligence training for land-grant colleges and universities Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a grant program led by the Secretary of Agriculture and the National Science Foundation that provides funds to land-grant colleges and universities. These funds are intended for developing artificial intelligence (AI) tools and research in agriculture, sharing AI educational resources in rural areas, and integrating AI into farming operations.
7. Quantum fellowships and scholarships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section details a program established by the Director to offer fellowships and scholarships for students in STEM fields to boost exposure and job opportunities in quantum information science and related areas. Eligible participants must be enrolled in or have completed a STEM degree and taken quantum-related courses, with awards being granted through a competitive process, possibly including industry financial support.
8. NSF outreach campaign Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes an outreach campaign by the National Science Foundation (NSF) to inform students across various educational levels about AI and quantum education opportunities. The Director is instructed to focus on underserved and rural areas in these efforts.
9. Community college and vocational school centers of AI excellence Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the creation of "Centers of AI Excellence" at community colleges and vocational schools, partnering with governments, institutions, or industries to advance AI education and research. It also establishes criteria for eligible applicants, mandates geographical diversity, and calls for a focus on areas like agriculture and manufacturing while promoting student pathways to AI-related jobs.
10. Award program for research on AI in education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section authorizes a program where institutions and organizations can apply for funds to research and develop teaching methods for incorporating artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies in education, especially for students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Eligible applicants must demonstrate a comprehensive plan including demographic focus, ethical considerations, and collaboration with educators and other stakeholders.
11. National Science Foundation awards for artificial intelligence resources Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that the National Science Foundation can give awards to schools and colleges, including elementary and secondary schools, universities, and technical schools, to help them provide or improve access to artificial intelligence tools. Additionally, preference for these awards is given to institutions that are either underrepresented geographically or are minority-serving, including historically Black colleges and universities or Tribal Colleges.
12. National Science Foundation National STEM Teachers Corps Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The National STEM Teachers Corps legislation is being updated to include teaching skills related to artificial intelligence. This change aims to help high school teachers learn best practices for AI, developed together with other educators and universities.
13. Guidance for the introduction and use of artificial intelligence in prekindergarten through grade 12 Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires that, within two years of the law being enacted, a team led by the Director, along with the Secretary of Education and other key officials, must create guidelines for using artificial intelligence in schools from prekindergarten to grade 12. These guidelines should address AI use in various communities, including rural and economically disadvantaged areas, and consider its application in both science and arts subjects, developed through consultations with teachers, universities, industry, and organizations.
14. NSF grand challenges relating to artificial intelligence education and training Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section discusses the NSF grand challenges aimed at encouraging innovative solutions for educating and training people in artificial intelligence in the U.S. by 2028. The challenges include training a large number of workers, addressing obstacles in AI education, creating non-displacing training methods, increasing women's participation, and benefiting rural areas.
15. Gift authority Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Director has the authority to accept and use monetary gifts from others, including private entities, to support scholarships and fellowships outlined in the Act.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it will be called the “NSF AI Education Act of 2024.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions for various terms used in the Act, such as educational institutions, artificial intelligence, and STEM. It explains the meaning of terms like “community college,” “Director,” “emerging research institution,” and others, often referencing other laws where the meanings are further clarified.
3. Undergraduate scholarships for artificial intelligence education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a scholarship program where the Director provides financial awards for undergraduate students studying artificial intelligence, quantum hybrid computing, AI in agriculture, AI in education, and AI in advanced manufacturing. These scholarships cover tuition and related costs for up to four years and are paid directly to the student's college, with preference given to certain educational institutions based on location and type.
4. Graduate scholarships for artificial intelligence education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a program where scholarships are given to graduate students for studying artificial intelligence and its applications in various fields like quantum hybrid computing, agriculture, education, and advanced manufacturing. These scholarships can cover tuition, fees, and provide a stipend for up to three years, and preference is given to students at certain types of institutions such as those in rural areas or historically Black colleges.
5. NSF artificial intelligence professional development fellowships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes a program where the Director of the NSF will give fellowships to students, teachers, faculty, and industry professionals to help them learn more about artificial intelligence and related new technologies. These fellowships cover tuition, fees, and provide a stipend, with the payment going directly to the affiliated educational institution.
6. Artificial intelligence training for land-grant colleges and universities Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of Agriculture, in partnership with the Director of the National Science Foundation, will provide grants to land-grant universities for developing and using artificial intelligence in farming. This funding can be used for research, educational materials, and acquiring AI tools to help improve agricultural practices.
7. Quantum fellowships and scholarships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section authorizes the Director to create or use current programs to fund fellowships and scholarships for STEM students interested in quantum information science and related fields. These opportunities, which can involve positions at various institutions, are awarded competitively and may prioritize industry partnerships; participants in Federal agency fellowships must adhere to specific ethics requirements.
8. NSF outreach campaign Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section mandates that the Director of the National Science Foundation (NSF) conducts a nationwide outreach campaign aimed at students and educators to raise awareness about education opportunities in AI and quantum fields. The campaign should focus on underserved and rural areas and can be implemented through new or existing programs.
9. Community college and vocational school centers of AI excellence Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes "Community College and Vocational School Centers of AI Excellence," designating at least five diverse institutions as centers for AI research and education. These centers will partner with various entities to provide AI training and develop best practices, while annual reports will track their performance and contributions, with all activities set to end seven years after the act's enactment.
10. Award program for research on AI in education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text describes a program where eligible entities, like colleges, nonprofits, or partnerships including private organizations, can apply for competitive awards to conduct research on teaching artificial intelligence (AI) in schools. The program focuses on creating tools and training for teachers, especially in low-income, rural, or Tribal areas, to better integrate AI and other emerging technologies into education, with consideration of ethical implications.
11. National Science Foundation awards for artificial intelligence resources Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The National Science Foundation is authorized to give awards to schools and colleges to help them access artificial intelligence tools and applications. Preference will be given to institutions that increase geographic diversity or are underrepresented in research, like community colleges and historically Black colleges and universities.
12. Guidance for the introduction and use of artificial intelligence in elementary and secondary education Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the development of guidelines for using artificial intelligence in elementary and secondary schools within two years of the law's enactment. The guidelines should consider AI's application in rural and economically challenged areas, its use in both STEM and liberal arts, and should be created with input from educators, universities, and private companies.
13. NSF grand challenges relating to artificial intelligence education and training Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes how the National Science Foundation, along with the Secretaries of Labor and Education, will support competitions called "grand challenges" to foster innovation in teaching 1,000,000 people in the U.S. about artificial intelligence by 2028. These challenges will focus on evolving educational methods, overcoming obstacles, ensuring women and rural communities benefit, and incorporating AI education without replacing current workers.
14. Criteria on appropriateness of gift acceptance; principles for public-private partnerships Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines how the Director of the National Science Foundation must set criteria to ensure that accepting gifts or forming partnerships will not harm the Foundation's integrity. It includes safeguards against foreign influence, requires periodic reviews and updates, and mandates reporting these criteria to relevant congressional committees.
15. Activities subject to funding Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The activities mentioned in this section of the Act will only be carried out if there is enough money provided by Congress or made available by other means.
16. Research Security Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section on Research Security states that the activities outlined in the Act must follow certain guidelines and rules set out in specific laws related to research and defense, ensuring adherence to established national security standards.
17. Workforce frameworks for critical and emerging technologies Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the development and continuous updating of workforce frameworks for critical and emerging technologies by the Director of the National Institute of Standards and Technology, including defining terms like "competencies" and "workforce categories." The Director will work with various stakeholders to create resources in multiple languages, update frameworks periodically, and include information to aid nontraditional background individuals in entering these fields, with specific emphasis on fields like cybersecurity and artificial intelligence.
18. Restrictions on awards or scholarships to certain institutions or recipients Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Director cannot give funds or start programs for schools, colleges, universities, nonprofit groups linked with these institutions, or research organizations if they have been found to have discriminated based on ancestry or ethnicity since January 1, 2020, violating the Civil Rights Act.