Overview
Title
To provide for the conveyance of certain Federal land at Swanson Reservoir and Hugh Butler Reservoir in the State of Nebraska, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
This bill is about giving some land near two big water places in Nebraska to two local areas so they can take care of it and use it for fun and helping nature. The people in charge promise to use the land for good things like playing, exploring, and keeping it nice for everyone.
Summary AI
The bill S. 4347 aims to authorize the transfer of specific federal lands located at Swanson Reservoir and Hugh Butler Reservoir in Nebraska to Frontier County and Hitchcock County. Under the bill, these lands, including facility and cabin sites, would be conveyed through title transfer agreements, ensuring they are used for similar or public purposes like recreation, conservation, and public access. The counties must demonstrate the ability to manage these lands and comply with existing environmental and safety regulations. Additionally, any future transfer of these lands must be to public entities that will maintain their intended uses.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill presented for consideration in Congress, titled the Swanson and Hugh Butler Reservoirs Land Conveyances Act, proposes the transfer of federal lands located at Swanson Reservoir and Hugh Butler Reservoir in Nebraska to local county authorities, specifically Hitchcock County and Frontier County. The primary aim is the conveyance of these lands for management and conservation purposes. The legislation includes specific definitions regarding the lands and management agreements, and it outlines the procedures and responsibilities associated with the title transfers.
General Summary of the Bill
The bill initiates a legal framework to transfer federal land to Hitchcock County and Frontier County within Nebraska. In doing so, it provides mechanisms for evaluating the fair market value of the land, entering into title transfer agreements, and establishing requirements for land management post-transfer. The legislation highlights specific land parcels such as Swanson Permitted Cabin Land and Red Willow Permitted Concession Land, among others, detailing conditions for their conveyance. It mandates compliance with environmental and preservation laws during and post-transfer, emphasizing the continued public accessibility and conservation of the lands.
Significant Issues
Several critical issues emerge from the bill:
Complexity in Fair Market Value: The definition of "fair market value" is intricate and may lead to disputes during appraisals. The lack of clarity might complicate the calculation of compensations, potentially affecting the economic dealings between federal and local entities.
Criteria for County Capacities: The bill does not provide explicit criteria to evaluate the technical and financial capabilities of the counties to manage these lands. This absence could lead to inconsistencies and misunderstandings during the evaluation process, affecting the effectiveness of land management.
Undefined Costs and Process Transparency: Legal, survey, and compliance costs are unspecified, potentially leading to financial burdens on the counties. The transparency in appraisal processes and subsequent reconveyance is also lacking, potentially opening the door to favoritism and inefficiency.
Vague Legal Parameters for Flooding: The legislation states that temporary flooding will not be considered a governmental taking but does not specify how such determinations will be made, possibly leading to legal confusion or disputes.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
Public Impact: The transfer of these lands and their subsequent management by local counties could lead to positive environmental and recreation outcomes, as the regions are preserved for public access and natural habitats. However, with intricate appraisal and procedural elements, there may be delays or financial obstacles that could hinder immediate public benefits.
Stakeholder Impact: For Hitchcock County and Frontier County, the bill presents both opportunities and challenges. On one hand, acquiring these lands can enhance their recreation sectors and community engagement in local natural resources. On the other hand, undefined management criteria and cost responsibilities may strain their administrative capacities if not resolved transparently and efficiently.
Environmental and Recreation Interests: Positively, the bill mandates compliance with significant environmental laws, preserving the area's natural character and ensuring habitats are maintained. Nonetheless, without clear procedural guidelines, environmental organizations might express concerns about sufficient oversight and consistent management practices.
Conclusion
The Swanson and Hugh Butler Reservoirs Land Conveyances Act is poised to make significant changes to the management of federal lands in Nebraska. While it aims to enhance local control and conservation, ensuring that fair processes and transparent criteria are upheld is vital to its success. This legislative effort must address the outlined issues to effectively serve the public interest and meet the goals of sustainable regional management.
Issues
The bill lacks specificity on the criteria for evaluating Hitchcock County and Frontier County’s technical and financial capabilities to manage the lands, which could lead to subjective assessments and potential mismanagement. This issue is primarily found in Section 3.
The definition of 'fair market value' in Section 2 is complex and could be interpreted in various ways, potentially leading to disputes in the appraisal and compensation process when calculating fair market value for land conveyances.
The absence of a detailed timeline for compliance with State fire, safety, and health codes post-conveyance in Section 3 might lead to confusion and non-compliance, which could pose safety risks.
The reliance on multiple technical terms and references, like the 'Flood Control Act of 1944,' might lead to misunderstandings among stakeholders, as noted in Section 2. This could complicate public understanding and participation in the legislative process.
The lack of clarity on how temporary flooding or flood damage would not be considered a taking in legal disputes, as outlined in Section 4, raises potential legal issues that may affect property owners.
Legal, survey, and administrative costs associated with the conveyances are not capped (Section 3), which might result in excessive or unchecked expenditures, financially impacting the Counties involved.
The legislation mandates processes for compliance with multiple federal laws but fails to outline potential costs related to these processes, as noted in Section 6. This could result in unanticipated financial burdens for the Counties.
Definitions referring to existing management agreements and contractual terms suggest potential biases towards specific operators and are not clearly explained in Section 2, potentially leading to favoritism in contractual dealings.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Act is officially named the “Swanson and Hugh Butler Reservoirs Land Conveyances Act.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions for various terms related to land management and agreements in Nebraska, such as what constitutes "fair market value," specific land areas like "Hugh Butler Reservoir" and "Lakeview Lodge Permitted Concession Land," as well as the roles of officials like the "Secretary of the Interior" and the counties involved in the management agreements.
3. Conveyances of Federal land to Hitchcock County and Frontier County, Nebraska Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill outlines a plan for transferring specific federal lands in Nebraska to Hitchcock County and Frontier County, detailing requirements like prohibiting land subdivision, establishing agreements for roles and responsibilities, ensuring management capabilities, and addressing costs and management methods for these lands to maintain public purposes and natural preservation. Additionally, it restricts further land reconveyance, except to publicly recognized entities, emphasizing public access and consistent land use.
4. Effect on reservations, easements, and other rights Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
A conveyance under this bill, related to the Swanson and Hugh Butler Reservoirs, must respect existing rights and reservations, including those for mineral rights and easements. The United States is not liable for flood damages unless caused by its actions before the bill's enactment, and entities accepting land must protect the U.S. from related claims. Temporary flooding isn't considered government property taking.
5. Interim requirements Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that until the requested Federal land is transferred as described in earlier parts of the bill, the agreements and permits related to Lakeview Lodge, Red Willow, and Swanson will continue to be valid and enforced.
6. Compliance with other laws Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Before any federal land is given away, the Secretary must follow certain environmental and historic preservation laws, like the National Environmental Policy Act and the Endangered Species Act. Once the land is transferred, Hitchcock County and Frontier County have to follow all related federal, state, and local laws to manage the land properly.