Overview
Title
To provide for accurate energy appraisals in connection with residential mortgage loans, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 4340 is a bill that wants to add information about how energy-efficient a home is when people are figuring out how much a house is worth for a loan. This means they need to consider things like solar panels and good insulation, which might help people get a better loan deal if they have these features in their home.
Summary AI
S. 4340 aims to ensure accurate energy appraisals are considered when assessing residential mortgage loans in the United States. It mandates that lenders provide borrowers with energy-related information about their properties as part of the appraisal process, potentially affecting the appraised value. From March 1, 2026, appraisers must consider energy efficiency and renewable energy features when appraising a property, given borrower consent. The bill also establishes guidelines for creating and using energy reports, involving consultation with an advisory committee of industry stakeholders.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The Getting Renewable and Energy Efficient Neighborhoods Appraisals Act of 2024, or the "GREEN Appraisals Act of 2024," aims to integrate energy efficiency into the appraisal process for residential mortgage loans. Introduced in the U.S. Senate by Senator Bennet, the bill seeks to ensure that the energy efficiency features and renewable energy components of homes are appropriately valued during the appraisal process, thus influencing the mortgage lending decisions.
General Summary of the Bill
The GREEN Appraisals Act requires lenders, particularly those involved in government-backed mortgage programs, to disclose information related to a property's energy efficiency to borrowers and appraisers. By doing so, the bill intends to make energy-efficient and renewable energy characteristics part of the property valuation process. This could lead to adjusted property values based on their energy performance, potentially affecting a borrower's ability to secure a loan.
Summary of Significant Issues
One important issue is the potential financial burden placed on smaller creditors, as they are required to provide energy reports free of cost to prospective borrowers. This could disproportionately affect their operations and the services they offer. Another concern is the complexity in defining what constitutes an energy report, with multiple approved methods that may lead to confusion among lenders and appraisers.
Moreover, the bill lacks clear accountability measures or consequences for non-compliance, which could result in inconsistent application across different entities. The directive for appraisers to consider energy efficiency information is somewhat ambiguous, potentially leading to varied interpretations and appraisals. Additionally, the bill presumes familiarity with specific federal acts and codes, which may limit its transparency and accessibility to the general public.
Public Impact
Broadly speaking, the bill could lead to increased awareness and valuation of energy-efficient and renewable energy investments in residential properties, promoting more sustainable living preferences. By factoring energy efficiency into property appraisals, homeowners could see increased property values, while buyers may be more inclined to invest in energy-efficient homes knowing that their investments would be recognized financially.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For real estate professionals and appraisers, the bill presents both challenges and opportunities. Appraisers may need to undertake additional training to incorporate energy efficiency data effectively, which could initially narrow the pool of qualified professionals. However, for those who adapt, it may lead to new business opportunities in a growing market segment.
Lenders and creditors, especially smaller institutions, might face operational challenges due to the cost implications of providing free energy reports. However, accommodating energy efficiency in appraisals could potentially lead to more secured loans, as properties with lower energy costs might be seen as less risky due to the potential for cost savings.
Homeowners with energy-efficient properties stand to benefit from possibly higher property values, while prospective buyers may gain more comprehensive insights into long-term energy costs. Conversely, properties lacking in energy efficiency might become less attractive, impacting their marketability and value.
Overall, while the bill aims to integrate energy considerations into mortgage and appraisal practices comprehensively, its success will largely depend on how effectively its measures are implemented and the ability of stakeholders to adapt to these new requirements.
Issues
The definition of 'covered agency' does not include state-level entities, raising concerns about the integration and interaction of state and federal systems (Section 2(a)).
The requirement for creditors to provide energy reports at no cost to borrowers could impose financial burdens on smaller lenders, potentially affecting their operations (Section 2(e)).
The lack of specifications regarding accountability or consequences for non-compliance by covered agencies or creditors may lead to inconsistencies in the implementation of the bill (Section 2(f)).
The necessity for guidance and coordination with advisory committees may lead to delays in implementation due to the need for cross-agency collaboration and stakeholder coordination (Section 2(f)).
The complex definition of 'energy report' and the various approved methods for conducting these analyses could cause confusion over which standards are preferred or required, potentially affecting clarity for both creditors and appraisers (Section 2(g)(4)).
The potential impact on property value and loan eligibility due to consideration of energy reports is noted, but the exact influence on borrowing terms remains ambiguous and may impact the real estate market (Section 2(b)).
The directive to appraisers on how to consider information in energy reports lacks clarity and may result in inconsistencies or misunderstandings among appraisers (Section 2(f)(1)(C)).
The use of terms from federal codes, such as the Truth in Lending Act, presumes reader familiarity, which could limit the accessibility and transparency of the bill for the general public (Section 2(g)(2)).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it can be officially called the "Getting Renewable and Energy Efficient Neighborhoods Appraisals Act of 2024" or simply the “GREEN Appraisals Act of 2024.”
2. Getting renewable and energy efficient neighborhoods accurate energy appraisals Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the bill, lenders making home loans through certain government-backed programs must provide borrowers with information on energy reports for their properties, which can be used by appraisers in assessing a home's value. This initiative aims to ensure that features like energy efficiency and renewable energy are considered, potentially affecting the property's appraised value and the borrower's ability to secure a loan.