Overview
Title
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to increase the threshold amounts for inclusion of Social Security benefits in income.
ELI5 AI
S. 358 wants to make sure that people who get money from Social Security don’t have to pay taxes on it unless they earn a lot more money. It also wants to make sure that the money needed to make this change doesn’t take away from other important things the government spends money on.
Summary AI
S. 358, also known as the "RETIREES FIRST Act," proposes changes to the Internal Revenue Code to increase the income threshold for including Social Security benefits in taxable income. The bill sets new base amounts of $34,000 for single people and $68,000 for joint filers, with inflation adjustments starting in 2025. It also plans to protect the Social Security trust funds from losing money due to these changes by reallocating federal discretionary appropriations. The amendments would take effect for tax years beginning after December 31, 2025.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed legislation, titled the "Reducing Excessive Taxation and Inefficiencies by Reforming Elder Exemptions to Support Fairness, Inflation Relief, and Simpler Taxes Act" or the "RETIREES FIRST Act," seeks to amend the way Social Security benefits are taxed and reallocates certain discretionary government funds to support retiree tax relief. Introduced in the Senate, this bill aims to increase the income threshold for taxation of Social Security benefits, adjust this threshold for inflation, and ensure that Social Security trust funds remain unaffected by these changes.
General Summary
The RETIREES FIRST Act proposes to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 by increasing the threshold amounts at which Social Security benefits become taxable. For individual taxpayers, the base amount would be $34,000, while for joint filers it would be $68,000, with an inflation adjustment mechanism starting in 2025. Furthermore, the bill plans to reallocate non-security discretionary appropriations beginning in fiscal year 2027 to offset the cost of reducing tax liabilities for retirees. The bill also mandates annual reports by the Office of Management and Budget on these budgetary changes starting in 2028.
Significant Issues
One major issue with the bill is the potential for ambiguity, particularly regarding financial terms and definitions. For example, it is unclear how frequently the inflation adjustment will occur after 2025, which could create uncertainties for taxpayers planning their future finances. Additionally, the broad language regarding Treasury appropriations could lead to perceptions of unrestricted government spending, potentially impacting other budget areas.
Another concern is the lack of a detailed implementation plan post-2025, which might result in administrative challenges. The bill’s complex language regarding fiscal appropriations and rescissions could be difficult for the general public to understand, complicating transparency and oversight.
Potential Impact on the Public
For the general public, particularly retirees, this bill could provide significant tax relief by increasing the taxable income thresholds for Social Security benefits. This change could alleviate financial stress for many retirees living on fixed incomes, allowing them to retain more of their Social Security benefits.
However, the lack of clarity around fund appropriations and potential reliance on unrestricted Treasury resources might raise concerns about the bill's long-term fiscal sustainability. As discretionary appropriations are rescinded to fund these changes, other non-security areas, potentially including essential public services, might experience budget cuts.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Retirees stand to benefit most directly from this bill. By raising the taxable income ceiling, many retirees could enjoy a more substantial tax break, increasing their disposable income and reducing financial strain.
On the other hand, government agencies reliant on non-security discretionary funding could face budgetary constraints as funds are reallocated to cover the cost of these tax breaks. This could result in reduced services or resource reallocation in affected areas, potentially impacting communities dependent on such services.
Overall, while the RETIREES FIRST Act aims to offer valuable tax relief to retirees, issues related to interpretation, implementation, and fiscal sustainability warrant careful consideration to ensure the proposed benefits are realized without unintended negative consequences.
Financial Assessment
Summary of Financial Provisions
S. 358 outlines several key financial changes aimed at adjusting the treatment of Social Security benefits in taxable incomes. The base amounts for taxable Social Security benefits are set to $34,000 for single individuals and $68,000 for joint filers. These thresholds determine when Social Security benefits become taxable, with an intention to make the tax system fairer for retirees. Furthermore, beginning in 2025, these base amounts will be adjusted annually for inflation, potentially affecting taxpayers’ planning and understanding of future liabilities. The mechanism through which inflation adjustments will be applied is specified, yet the frequency and precise calculation method are not entirely clear.
Appropriations and Trust Fund Provisions
A significant feature of the bill is to hold the Social Security and Railroad Retirement trust funds harmless from any financial losses resulting from these tax code amendments. Funds considered for these adjustments are specified to be out of "any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated." This is an important financial provision as it denotes the source of funding intended to cover potential shortfalls in these trust funds. However, the broad language may contribute to a perception of unrestricted use of Treasury funds, raising concerns about impacts on other budget areas and priorities.
Rescission and Discretionary Appropriations
The bill introduces a mechanism to reallocate federal discretionary appropriations to support retiree tax relief, starting with fiscal year 2027. This is done through a rescission clause, which involves reducing federal spending on a pro-rata basis from available budgetary allocations to account for the cost incurred by the amendments. This calculation includes any reduction in transfers to the Social Security and Railroad Retirement funds. However, the absence of a specified calculation formula and the complexity of the rescission language might lead to transparency challenges. The general public may find this rescission approach challenging to understand, especially regarding fiscal year details and implementation schedules.
Concerns and Ambiguities
There are several concerns and ambiguities related to the financial references in the bill. The lack of clarity regarding the frequency and methodology of inflation adjustments presents potential issues for taxpayer understanding and financial planning. Additionally, the broad language used regarding Treasury funding appropriations could raise questions about fiscal responsibility. The interpretation of what constitutes "dollar amounts"—whether nominal or adjusted for inflation—may lead to confusion. Finally, the complex language in the rescission provisions may obscure the understanding of reallocations and their broader implications on other federal programs.
Issues
The amendment allows for an inflation adjustment of the base amounts starting in 2025, but it is not clear how frequently this adjustment will occur, potentially affecting taxpayers' planning and understanding of future liabilities. (Section 2)
The language 'out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated' for appropriations to Social Security and Railroad Retirement trust funds is broad, possibly leading to the perception of unrestricted use of funds which could impact other budget areas or priorities. (Section 2)
The bill provides no implementation plan or schedule for the changes after December 31, 2025, which may cause administrative issues around the transition. (Section 2)
The definition of 'base amount' as 'dollar amounts' without specifying whether they are nominal or adjusted for inflation could lead to interpretational issues. (Section 2)
The rescission language in Section 3 is complex and may be difficult for laypersons to understand, particularly the reference to fiscal years and their effective dates, which could create transparency challenges. (Section 3)
There is a lack of specificity about how the proportional reduction in appropriations will be calculated, introducing potential ambiguity or manipulation. (Section 3)
The reliance on an external definition for what qualifies as 'security' without detail could lead to ambiguity regarding which appropriations are excluded from rescission. (Section 3)
The acronym 'RETIREES FIRST Act' in the short title is catchy but may not clearly represent the full title or purpose, potentially leading to misunderstandings. (Section 1)
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section gives the short title of the Act, which is called the "Reducing Excessive Taxation and Inefficiencies by Reforming Elder Exemptions to Support Fairness, Inflation Relief, and Simpler Taxes Act" or simply the "RETIREES FIRST Act".
2. Increase in threshold amounts for inclusion of Social Security benefits in income Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the Internal Revenue Code to adjust the income threshold for taxing Social Security benefits, allowing individuals and couples to exclude a higher base amount from their income calculations. Beginning in 2025, these base amounts will be adjusted for inflation, and the government will ensure that funds for Social Security are not negatively impacted by these changes.
Money References
- In general.—Gross income for the taxable year of any taxpayer described in subsection (b) (notwithstanding section 207 of the Social Security Act) includes Social Security benefits in an amount equal to the lesser of— “(1) 85 percent of the Social Security benefits received during the taxable year, or “(2) 85 percent of the excess described in subsection (b)(1).”. (b) Base amount.—Subsection (c) of section 86 of such Code is amended to read as follows: “(c) Base amount.— “(1) IN GENERAL.—For purposes of this section, the term ‘base amount’ means— “(A) except as otherwise provided in this subsection, $34,000, “(B) $68,000 in the case of a joint return, and “(C) zero in the case of a taxpayer who— “(i) is married as of the close of the taxable year (within the meaning of section 7703) but does not file a joint return for such year, and “(ii) does not live apart from his spouse at all times during the taxable year.
- “(2) INFLATION ADJUSTMENT.— “(A) IN GENERAL.—In the case of any taxable year beginning after 2025, each of the dollar amounts in paragraph (1) shall be increased by an amount equal to— “(i) such dollar amount, multiplied by “(ii) the cost-of-living adjustment determined under section 1(f)(3) for the calendar year, determined by substituting ‘calendar year 2024’ for ‘calendar year 2016’ in subparagraph (A)(ii) thereof.
- “(B) ROUNDING.—If any amount determined under subparagraph (A) is not a multiple of $1,000, such amount shall be rounded to the nearest multiple of $1,000.”. (c) Social Security trust funds held harmless.—There are hereby appropriated (out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated) for each fiscal year to each fund under the Social Security Act or the Railroad Retirement Act of 1974 an amount equal to the reduction in the transfers to such fund for such fiscal year by reason of the amendments made by this section.
3. Reallocating non-security discretionary appropriations to support retiree tax relief Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
For fiscal year 2027 and beyond, the bill requires taking back funds from non-security areas of government spending to help reduce taxes for retirees. The law specifies that this doesn't affect security funding and outlines how the Office of Management and Budget must report these budget adjustments each year starting in 2028.