Overview
Title
An Act To establish the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument in the State of Oklahoma, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
In this bill, they want to make a special place in Oklahoma to remember an important part of history called Black Wall Street and a very sad event, the Tulsa Race Massacre. They plan to make a park to learn about what happened, and people connected to those stories will help decide how it’s done.
Summary AI
S. 3543 aims to establish the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument in Oklahoma as part of the National Park System. This Monument will preserve and share the history of the Greenwood District, Black Wall Street, and the Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921. The bill allows for the acquisition of land through donations, purchases, or exchanges, and the Secretary of the Interior will oversee its management and development. An advisory commission will be established to assist the Secretary, with a majority of its members being descendants of individuals from the Greenwood District of 1921.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill in question, titled the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Establishment Act, proposes the creation of a National Monument in Oklahoma to commemorate and educate the public about the historic Greenwood District, often referred to as Black Wall Street, and the tragic events of the Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921. This initiative seeks to preserve an important part of both Oklahoma's and the United States' history, ensuring that the stories and lessons of the past are passed down to future generations.
General Summary
The primary aim of this legislative measure is to establish the Historic Greenwood District as a National Monument. The responsibility for acquiring the necessary land, mapping out the monument's boundaries, and devising educational programs falls primarily to the Secretary of the Interior. Additionally, an advisory commission will provide guidance on the monument's development and ongoing management. This commission is composed of descendants from the Greenwood District, historical preservation experts, and a member recommended by Tulsa's mayor.
Significant Issues
Several concerns arise from the bill's wording and provisions. Firstly, the requirement for a "sufficient quantity of land" is subjective and could lead to challenges in determining when conditions for establishing the monument are met. Additionally, vague details on budget allocations or spending caps raise the possibility of financial extravagances or mismanagement.
The makeup of the advisory commission could also be scrutinized, given its emphasis on descendants from the Greenwood District. Although their inclusion is crucial for historical accuracy and integrity, this could be perceived as favoritism without explicit justification.
Moreover, the plan for the monument's management is set on a timeline that might be considered drawn-out, potentially deferring timely and effective implementation. The bill does not clearly outline a process for public involvement, which might exclude local community input that could be indispensable for the monument's acceptance and success.
Public Impact
For the general public, this bill represents both an opportunity and a challenge. On one hand, it presents a chance for broader awareness and acknowledgment of a significant historical event. It promises educational resources and potentially increases tourism, benefitting local economies. However, the vagueness surrounding budgetary and management details could lead to disputes or inefficiencies in how these aims are achieved.
Stakeholder Impact
For stakeholders such as the descendants of Greenwood District residents, this bill may offer a long-awaited recognition of their history and an avenue for healing and remembrance. The emphasis on descendants in the commission suggests a platform for their voices, but it also raises expectations that could result in dissatisfaction should their influence prove limited or symbolic.
Local Tulsa residents and businesses might experience both positive and negative effects. While the creation of a national monument could boost tourism and business opportunities, it may also result in changes to property landscapes and the local community dynamic, potentially leading to civic unrest or opposition if not managed delicately.
In conclusion, while the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Establishment Act is commendable in its intent to preserve and honor vital history, it is crucial for its execution to be transparent, inclusive, and fiscally responsible to realize its potential benefits without unintended adverse outcomes.
Issues
The section establishing the 'Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Advisory Commission' (Section 5) may be seen as preferential because the Commission is primarily composed of descendants from the Greenwood District. This could lead to concerns about potential bias unless adequately justified (Section 5(c)(1)).
The funding specifications are vague as the bill does not detail a budget or cap for land acquisition, administration, or preparation of a management plan, which could lead to uncontrolled spending (Sections 3 and 4).
The lack of clarity around the 'sufficient quantity of land' required to establish the National Monument could lead to ambiguities in decision-making, potentially causing delays or disputes over the land acquisition process (Section 3(a)(2)(A)).
The provision for travel expenses for Commission members (Section 5(g)(2)) could potentially lead to misuse if not closely monitored, as it authorizes per diem rates and travel expenses akin to those for federal employees.
The timeframe for preparing a management plan is set at 3 years, which could be considered excessive and not responsive enough to the needs and urgency of establishing the National Monument (Section 4(b)(1)).
There is no provision for public involvement or transparency measures in the preparation of the management plan, which might raise concerns among stakeholders interested in the Monument (Section 4(b)).
The process for addressing vacancies on the Advisory Commission lacks specific details, potentially leading to confusion or delays during transitions (Section 5(c)(3)).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Establishment Act is introduced as the official title of this law.
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions for terms used in the Act, such as "Commission," which refers to the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Advisory Commission, "Map," referring to a specific map with proposed boundaries, "National Monument," which denotes the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument, and "Secretary," meaning the Secretary of the Interior.
3. Establishment of Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill establishes the Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument in Oklahoma to protect and teach about the area's historical significance, including the Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921. The Secretary of the Interior is responsible for acquiring land, creating agreements for educational and administrative purposes, ensuring the property's boundaries are defined, and respecting private property rights within the area.
4. Administration Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary is responsible for overseeing the National Monument and must follow both the specific legislation for the monument and the general laws for National Park System areas. Within three years of receiving funds, the Secretary must create a management plan for the monument and consult with the Commission during its preparation.
5. Establishment of Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Advisory Commission Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill establishes an advisory commission called the "Historic Greenwood District—Black Wall Street National Monument Advisory Commission" to assist with the development and management of a new National Monument. The commission will have 11 members, including descendants of those from Tulsa's Greenwood District in 1921, historic preservation experts, and a member recommended by the Mayor of Tulsa. Members will serve 5-year terms without compensation, and the commission will disband 10 years after the monument is established.