Overview
Title
To designate the General George C. Marshall House, in the Commonwealth of Virginia, as an affiliated area of the National Park System, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to make the house where a famous person named George C. Marshall lived in Virginia part of the National Park family, so more people can learn about him. A group will help look after the house, but they won't have to buy the place or pay for everything.
Summary AI
S. 3195 proposes to designate the General George C. Marshall House in Virginia as an affiliated area of the National Park System to honor and promote public appreciation of George C. Marshall's significant historical contributions. The bill outlines that the George C. Marshall International Center will manage this area, with opportunities for cooperative agreements with the Secretary of the Interior for marketing and preservation efforts. Additionally, it specifies that the Secretary will not take on the acquisition of property or the primary financial responsibilities for the area's upkeep.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation aims to designate the General George C. Marshall House, located in the Commonwealth of Virginia, as an affiliated area of the National Park System. This designation is intended to honor and promote public appreciation of the historical contributions of George Catlett Marshall, a notable U.S. military leader and statesman. The bill specifies that the site will be managed by the George C. Marshall International Center, with the Secretary of the Interior authorized to provide technical assistance but not to assume property ownership or financial responsibility for its maintenance.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several key issues emerge from the provision of this bill. First, there is a concern about the lack of a competitive selection process for determining the management entity. By directly designating the George C. Marshall International Center without mentioning alternatives or a formal process, there could be perceptions of favoritism. Additionally, the term "affiliated area" lacks a clear legal definition, which could lead to confusion over what the designation entails. The limited role of the Secretary of the Interior, particularly concerning financial obligations and property acquisition, also raises questions about accountability. Finally, the bill's reliance on the availability of funds to complete a management plan could cause delays and uncertainty.
Impact on the Public
The bill could have varying impacts on the public. By integrating the General George C. Marshall House into the National Park System, the bill seeks to increase public knowledge and appreciation of George C. Marshall's historical significance. This designation can potentially boost tourism and educational opportunities in Virginia, which could translate into economic benefits for local communities. However, if the affiliated area fails to attract sufficient interest or visitors, there is a risk of inefficient use of resources without considerable public gain.
Impact on Stakeholders
Positive Impact:
For historians, educators, and those interested in U.S. military history, the bill represents a step towards preserving and promoting an important historical site. The George C. Marshall International Center, designated as the management authority, stands to benefit from its elevated status and potential funding opportunities, allowing it to further its mission.
Negative Impact:
On the downside, stakeholders concerned with government transparency might view the lack of a competitive process for choosing the management entity as problematic. Furthermore, local taxpayers or entities may express concerns about potential financial obligations or the absence of clear oversight, particularly given the Secretary of the Interior's limited role in financial and operational aspects.
In conclusion, while the bill has the potential to honor an important historical figure and leverage heritage tourism as a community benefit, it raises some transparency issues and operational ambiguities that need careful consideration to optimize its intended outcomes.
Issues
The designation of the George C. Marshall International Center as the management entity without any mention of a competitive selection process raises concerns about potential favoritism and lack of transparency in how management responsibilities are allocated. This issue is embedded in Section 1(d).
The term 'affiliated area' is used without a clear legal definition, leading to potential ambiguity regarding its implications and compliance requirements within the National Park System. This lack of clarity could result in varied interpretations and oversight challenges, as identified in Section 1(a) and (c).
The role of the Secretary of the Interior is notably limited, particularly regarding financial responsibilities and property acquisitions, which may lead to issues regarding who holds ultimate accountability. This limited role might result in funding or management gaps, primarily reflected in Section 1(f).
The potential for the affiliated area designation to result in wasteful spending is linked to uncertainties if the site does not attract sufficient public interest or tourism benefits. This concern intersects with Section 1(a) and (e).
The planning timeline being contingent upon the availability of funds can introduce excessive delays and create long-term uncertainty in the implementation of the management plan for the associated area. This issue is noted in Section 1(g).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Establishment of the General George C. Marshall House as an affiliated area Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The General George C. Marshall House in Virginia is designated as an affiliated area of the National Park System to honor George C. Marshall's historic contributions. The site will be managed by the George C. Marshall International Center, with the Secretary of the Interior able to offer assistance but not take over property ownership or full responsibility for operations.
1. Establishment of the General George C. Marshall House as an affiliated area Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The General George C. Marshall House in Virginia is now part of the National Park System to honor George C. Marshall's significant historic contributions. It will be managed by the George C. Marshall International Center, with agreements in place for cooperation, but the Secretary of the Interior cannot buy the property or handle its overall management costs.