Overview
Title
To require the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information to establish a working group on cyber insurance, to require dissemination of informative resources for issuers and customers of cyber insurance, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 245 is like making a special team to help understand and explain cyber insurance, which is a type of protection for things on the internet. This team will share easy-to-understand information to help people and companies know more about buying and using this kind of insurance.
Summary AI
S. 245 aims to enhance the understanding and use of cyber insurance by establishing a working group led by the Assistant Secretary of Commerce. This group will analyze and explain insurance policies to make them more understandable for customers, gather inputs from various stakeholders to improve insurance offerings, and provide recommendations on how to effectively use cyber insurance. Additionally, the bill mandates the dissemination of resources and information to help both issuers and customers better understand cyber insurance products and practices. The bill also specifies that the working group's recommendations are voluntary and hold no regulatory power.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled the "Insure Cybersecurity Act of 2025," seeks to enhance the landscape of cyber insurance in the United States. It tasks the Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information with establishing a working group dedicated to cyber insurance. This group is expected to create and disseminate resources that will help issuers of cyber insurance and their customers understand the nuances of cyber insurance policies and the types of coverage they offer. The aim is to make these policies more comprehensible to consumers and to suggest improvements for insurers in offering extensive coverage. Additionally, the bill mandates the publication and dissemination of these resources to the public, ensuring that critical information reaches relevant stakeholders.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several notable issues arise from the bill's text and proposed plan. A primary concern is the potential inconsistency in the definitions of key terms such as "cyber insurance," which could lead to confusion among stakeholders. The bill also lacks a clear framework for evaluating the success of the working group's activities, as well as mechanisms for accountability and transparency. This absence raises questions about the effectiveness and governance of the group's operations.
Additionally, there is no designated budget or funding source for the dissemination of informational resources, casting doubt on the feasibility of the outreach efforts. The vagueness surrounding the nature of these informational resources and the outreach strategy may result in ineffectual communication among intended beneficiaries.
Furthermore, the bill does not require the adoption of the working group's recommendations, which may undermine the purpose of the group's activities. The termination of the group after its report submission without plans for follow-up or continued oversight further challenges the long-term sustainability of the initiative.
Impact on the Public Broadly
For the general public, especially consumers of cyber insurance, this bill could potentially demystify the often complex and opaque terms found in policies, making it easier to understand and evaluate them. This, in theory, could empower customers to make more informed decisions about the types and levels of coverage they purchase, thereby fostering a more knowledgeable market base.
However, the success of these outcomes rests heavily on the clarity, accessibility, and dissemination of the resources produced by the working group. Without a clear requirement for adopting the group's recommendations or a mechanism for evaluating success, the broader impact could be limited.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Issuers, agents, and brokers stand to benefit positively if the resources created by the working group indeed clarify the terms and scope of cyber insurance. This could enhance trust and ease communication with clients, possibly leading to an increase in cyber insurance adoption and sales.
Conversely, these stakeholders might face challenges if the definition of "cyber insurance" becomes inconsistent or if the recommendations are not heeded, leading to disconnects between what is promised and what is delivered. Small businesses, often with fewer resources to tackle such complexities, may find both improvements and inconsistencies acutely impactful, potentially altering their approach to cybersecurity risk management.
State regulators and legal entities may find themselves navigating additional complexities due to potential discrepancies in definitions and the non-mandatory nature of the working group's outcomes. This could lead to a fracturing of insurance standards across state lines, complicating regulatory compliance and enforcement.
In conclusion, while the intentions behind the "Insure Cybersecurity Act of 2025" seem grounded in promoting better understanding and usage of cyber insurance policies, the execution as proposed may encounter several hurdles that could dilute its intended benefits.
Issues
The lack of clear metrics or criteria to evaluate the success or impact of the working group's activities in Section 3 could lead to difficulties in assessing the effectiveness and accountability of its outcomes.
The potential inconsistency in definitions of 'cyber insurance' between Sections 2 and 3 might confuse stakeholders and could lead to legal and practical disparities in understanding coverage specifics.
The absence of oversight or auditing measures for the working group in Section 3 raises concerns about accountability and transparency in the execution of its duties.
There are no clear guidelines or mechanisms for public consultation and stakeholder engagement in Section 3, which could result in inadequate input and reduced effectiveness of the working group's proceedings.
Section 4's dissemination of informative resources lacks a specified budget or funding source, introducing uncertainty regarding financial implications and the feasibility of achieving its outreach goals.
The vagueness of the terms 'informative resources' and 'outreach strategy' in Section 4 could lead to ineffective communication and understanding among cyber insurance stakeholders.
The rule of construction in Section 3(f) provides no requirement for the adoption of the working group's recommendations, potentially nullifying the working group's contributions and impacting its overall impact.
The termination of the working group upon report submission in Section 3(e) without provisions for follow-up actions may hinder the long-term sustainability and responsiveness of the initiative.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill provides its official name, stating that it may be referred to as the "Insure Cybersecurity Act of 2025."
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section provides definitions for several key terms used in the Act, such as “Assistant Secretary,” which refers to a specific position in the Commerce Department, “critical infrastructure” and “cyber incident” based on existing legal meanings, and terms like “customer,” “cyber insurance,” “issuer,” “policy,” “small business,” and “working group” as they relate to cyber insurance.
3. Working group on cyber insurance Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes a working group within 90 days to focus on cyber insurance, comprising members from various federal agencies, a state insurance regulator, and chaired by the Assistant Secretary. The group will analyze and simplify cyber insurance policies for customers, gather feedback from stakeholders, and submit a report with recommendations to Congress within one year, after which the group will be dissolved.
4. Dissemination of informative resources for cyber insurance stakeholders Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Assistant Secretary to provide and publicly share helpful information resources about cyber insurance within 90 days after receiving a report. These resources should include recommendations from the report, be useful for diverse stakeholders like issuers and customers, and may have case studies. They will be available on a public website, with outreach efforts to ensure broad awareness, but their use is optional.