Overview
Title
An Act To require the purchase of domestically made flags of the United States of America for use by the Federal Government.
ELI5 AI
The government wants to buy American flags that are made only in the United States using materials from the U.S., but there are some exceptions, like if the flags cost too much or there aren’t enough available. The President can also let the government buy flags from other places if there's a special agreement, but they have to tell everyone within 30 days.
Summary AI
S. 1973, known as the "All-American Flag Act," requires the federal government to purchase only U.S.-made American flags. Specifically, these flags must be entirely manufactured in the United States with materials that are also 100% sourced or made in the country. There are exceptions, such as when flags of satisfactory quality or quantity cannot be found at reasonable prices, for purchases by vessels in foreign waters, for resale in military stores, or for transactions under a certain dollar threshold. The President can waive this requirement if necessary to comply with trade agreements, with any such waivers needing to be publicly announced within 30 days.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Overview of the All-American Flag Act
The All-American Flag Act (S. 1973) aims to ensure that flags of the United States purchased by federal government agencies are made entirely within the United States. This legislation mandates that agencies may only use appropriated funds to procure American flags that are 100% manufactured from domestically produced materials. However, there are specific situations where this requirement may not apply. These include instances where U.S.-made flags are not available at reasonable quality and quantity, when purchasing flags for certain overseas services, and for minor purchases that do not exceed a specified financial threshold. Furthermore, the President holds the authority to waive this requirement to uphold international trade agreements, with any waivers being published in the Federal Register.
Significant Issues
Restrictive Manufacturing Requirement
The bill's insistence on using only domestically manufactured flags could present practical challenges. If U.S.-produced flags are more expensive or in limited supply, this requirement could strain government budgets and, by extension, taxpayer funds.
Broad Presidential Waiver
The provision allowing the President to waive the domestic manufacturing requirement to comply with trade agreements might conflict with the act’s intent to boost U.S. manufacturing. Without clear criteria, this broad discretion could undermine the law's intended economic benefits.
Subjective Determination of Quality
One key issue is the subjective nature of determining what constitutes "satisfactory quality" for flags that can be sourced domestically. This ambiguity might lead to inconsistent application across different agencies, potentially jeopardizing the law's goals.
Simplified Acquisition Threshold Loophole
There is a concern that the exception for small-scale procurement—purchases under the simplified acquisition threshold—could be a loophole allowing a significant number of purchases to bypass the domestic mandate, especially if the threshold amount is substantial.
Lack of Oversight on Waivers
The statute requires public notice of any waivers in the Federal Register but does not stipulate any specific oversight or accountability measures to challenge or review these waivers. This absence of oversight may raise concerns about transparency and potential misuse.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
Broad Public Impact
For the general public, particularly taxpayers, this act could potentially lead to increased government spending if domestic flags are more costly. However, there may also be broader economic benefits by stimulating local manufacturing and supporting American workers.
Stakeholders
Flag Manufacturers: U.S. flag manufacturers stand to benefit significantly, as this bill creates a guaranteed market for their products. This could also encourage new investments and expansion within the domestic manufacturing industry.
Government Agencies: Agencies might face budgetary constraints if forced to purchase more expensive domestic flags. This could affect other funding priorities unless compensatory budget adjustments are made.
International Relations: The waiver provision reflects the necessity of balancing domestic economic goals with existing international trade commitments. This balance will be crucial to maintaining diplomatic and trade relationships broadly.
By understanding these aspects, it becomes evident that while the All-American Flag Act prioritizes national economic interests, it must also navigate various practical and diplomatic challenges to effectively fulfill its legislative intent.
Issues
The requirement that all United States flags procured by agencies must be 100% manufactured in the United States from domestically produced materials could be overly restrictive. This might lead to increased costs if domestic options are limited or more expensive, impacting both taxpayers and governmental budgets. (Section 2, subsections a and b)
The broad Presidential waiver provision could potentially conflict with the bill's objective of promoting domestic manufacturing. This provision allows waivers to comply with trade agreements but lacks clear criteria for its application, which could undermine the integrity of the requirement. (Section 2, subsection d)
The term 'satisfactory quality' in the availability exception is subjective and can lead to inconsistent determinations regarding the procurement of domestically made flags, risking the potential dilution of the bill's intent. (Section 2, subsection b)
The provision allowing exceptions for procurements under the simplified acquisition threshold might enable a significant number of flag purchases without adhering to the domestic production requirement. This could be a potential loophole if the threshold is too high. (Section 2, subsection c)
The lack of a clear mechanism for oversight or challenge to waivers that are published in the Federal Register may reduce transparency and accountability, raising concerns about potential abuse of the waiver capability. (Section 2, subsection d)
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this act states that the official title is "All-American Flag Act."
2. Requirement for agencies to buy domestically made United States flags Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the bill, U.S. government agencies are required to buy only American-made United States flags, unless there are specific exceptions like lack of availability or a presidential waiver due to trade agreements. This rule applies to contracts made 180 days after the act becomes law.
6310. Requirement for agencies to buy domestically made United States flags Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress requires that funds from federal agencies can only be used to purchase American flags that are entirely made in the U.S. from U.S.-grown or manufactured materials, but there are exceptions if U.S.-made flags are unavailable, for certain overseas or resale purchases, and for small-scale acquisitions. Additionally, the President can waive this requirement to comply with international trade agreements, and such waivers must be published in the Federal Register.