Overview
Title
To prohibit the appointment of former fossil fuel executive officers and fossil fuel lobbyists as the heads of certain departments, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 170 is a new rule that says people who used to work for or help big oil and gas companies can't be in charge of important government groups, like the ones that deal with energy and defense, to make sure they don't have any recent ties to those companies.
Summary AI
S. 170 aims to prevent individuals who have been executives of fossil fuel companies, fossil fuel lobbyists, or executives from fossil fuel trade associations from being appointed as heads of certain governmental departments or political appointees. This restriction applies to positions like the Secretary of Energy, Secretary of Defense, and other key roles in the administration. The bill targets individuals who have been involved with fossil fuels in these roles for the last 10 years, with the goal of ensuring that these departments are not led by individuals with recent ties to the fossil fuel industry.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill titled "Banning In Government Oil Industry Lobbyists from the Cabinet Act" or "BIG OIL from the Cabinet Act," introduced in the U.S. Senate, aims to bar individuals tied to the fossil fuel industry from holding key governmental positions. Specifically, it prohibits former executive officers of fossil fuel companies, fossil fuel lobbyists, or executives from fossil fuel trade associations from being appointed as department heads or political appointees in certain government agencies. This restriction applies to those who have served in these roles at any point over the ten years preceding their potential appointment.
Summary of Significant Issues
One of the primary issues with the bill is the potential for the 10-year prohibition period to be considered overly restrictive. It could exclude well-qualified individuals based solely on their past associations with the fossil fuel industry, without considering their current stance or capabilities. Moreover, the bill's definitions in Section 2 are extensive but might cause confusion in enforcement due to their breadth, especially "covered department head" and "executive officer." There's also concern about a loophole that may permit significant influence from fossil fuel affiliated persons in renewable roles within those companies. The section referring to fossil fuel lobbyists invokes the Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995, which may require additional legislative interpretation for the layperson.
Potential Impact on the Public
For the public, the bill represents an effort to ensure that decision-making positions in key governmental departments are free from potential conflicts of interest associated with the fossil fuel industry. This can foster policies that align more closely with sustainable energy goals and environmental protection. The broad exclusion could be seen positively, potentially leading to more impartial governance.
However, the stringent criteria could also mean that the government is unable to appoint skilled individuals who understand the energy sector's complexities, including renewable technologies, simply due to prior associations. This might create challenges in staffing critical positions with experienced and knowledgeable personnel.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Environmental Advocates: Likely to view this bill favorably, as it aligns with reducing fossil fuel influence in governmental decision-making, thereby promoting green and sustainable policy developments.
Fossil Fuel Industry and Lobbyists: This group would be negatively impacted, as their pathways to influence government policy through direct appointments are effectively blocked. It may also push them to reconsider and reform their business models.
Government Hiring Bodies: The provision may impose additional burdens in terms of the vetting process for new hires for key positions. It requires a detailed investigation into the past ten years of potential candidates’ careers, potentially complicating and prolonging the hiring process.
Potential Appointees: Individuals who have spent significant portions of their careers, even in minor roles, within the fossil fuel sector could find themselves unqualified for certain government roles despite their otherwise relevant expertise and competence.
Overall, the bill establishes a clear stance on minimizing fossil fuel industry influence in government positions to potentially bolster environmental and energy policies. It also raises substantial concerns regarding its breadth and the execution of these new hiring limitations.
Issues
Section 3: The prohibition of appointments extends to individuals who have been associated with fossil fuel entities, lobbyists, or trade associations in any capacity during the last 10 years. This might be seen as overly restrictive, potentially excluding capable individuals without clear justification for such an exclusion period.
Section 3: The definitions of 'fossil fuel entity' and 'fossil fuel lobbyist' are essential but absent from this section, which could lead to ambiguity and inconsistent application of the prohibition.
Section 2: The definition of 'covered department head' includes a wide range of positions across various agencies, potentially leading to ambiguity and challenges in interpretation, which can complicate enforcement and compliance.
Section 2: The exclusion of certain employees from the definition of 'executive officer,' specifically those involved in renewable energy within fossil fuel entities, might create a loophole that allows significant influence from the fossil fuel sector under the guise of renewable energy roles.
Section 2: The definition of 'fossil fuel lobbyist' references the Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995, requiring additional understanding of that Act, which can complicate comprehension for those unfamiliar with it.
Section 3: The prohibition includes acting capacities but does not clarify whether this restriction applies to temporary or emergency appointments, which could potentially disrupt urgent staffing needs.
Section 2: The term 'executive officer' is broad as it includes any officer performing policy-making functions. This might need clearer boundaries to avoid unintended exclusions or inclusions.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this bill states that it can be referred to as the "Banning In Government Oil Industry Lobbyists from the Cabinet Act" or simply the "BIG OIL from the Cabinet Act."
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, the bill defines key terms such as "covered department head," which includes various top government officials, "covered political appointee," which refers to specific positions at several government agencies, and "executive officer," which describes leading figures in a business. It also includes definitions for terms like "fossil fuel," "fossil fuel entity," "fossil fuel lobbyist," and "fossil fuel trade association," relating to the fossil fuel industry and associated lobbying activities.
3. Prohibition of appointment of fossil fuel executives and lobbyists Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section prohibits anyone who has been an executive in a fossil fuel company, fossil fuel lobbyist, or executive in a fossil fuel trade group from being appointed as a department head or political appointee in the government if they worked in those roles during the last 10 years. They also can't do these jobs temporarily.