Overview
Title
To redesignate land within certain wilderness study areas in the State of Wyoming, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to change the rules for some special nature areas in Wyoming, making them more protected so people can't use them for certain things like building roads or digging for oil, but still letting scientists see if new fun areas for riding off-road vehicles could be made.
Summary AI
S. 1348 aims to redesignate land within specific wilderness study areas in Wyoming. This bill would officially designate various lands as wilderness areas, manage them under stricter environmental protections, and establish special management areas with different rules regarding land use. It also includes provisions to release certain areas from wilderness study status, thereby allowing more flexible management, and prohibits certain types of energy development on these lands. Additionally, it requires studies to explore the potential for developing new motorized recreation areas while preserving natural and recreational resources.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled the "Wyoming Public Lands Initiative Act of 2023," seeks to redesignate and manage various land areas within Wyoming, focusing on wilderness and special management areas. The bill covers several regions across the state, including Carbon, Fremont, Natrona, Johnson, Campbell, Washakie, and Hot Springs counties. It establishes guidelines for preserving environmental and recreational values across designated lands, including prohibitions on certain activities and usage of natural resources. This initiative also involves studying the potential for new recreational areas and reformulating existing land management practices.
Summary of Significant Issues
The bill presents several complex issues that may affect its implementation. A significant concern is the allowance for oil and gas extraction through directional drilling while prohibiting surface disturbance. This provision could result in potential environmental impacts that might conflict with conservation goals. Furthermore, hiring modern fire suppression methods and defining necessary road maintenance are vague terms that could lead to varied interpretations and inconsistent application.
Moreover, the broad authority given to management without clear oversight in Special Management Areas raises transparency concerns. There are questions regarding possible bias in policies related to land exchanges and grazing, alongside the challenge of interpreting guidelines referenced from external documents. The bill's provisions for temporary road construction in emergencies need stricter regulation to prevent misuse. Finally, the use of complex legal descriptions for land boundaries may impede public engagement due to difficulty in understanding.
Potential Broad Impact on the Public
The public may perceive this bill as a double-edged sword. On one hand, it presents an opportunity for enhanced environmental conservation across significant tracts of land, which could maintain Wyoming's natural beauty and promote outdoor recreation. On the other hand, the provisions allowing industrial activities like oil and gas drilling might be seen as compromising these goals, potentially leading to public apprehension regarding environmental protection.
Public access and recreation could be improved through careful implementation of travel management plans and the establishment of motorized recreation areas. However, the complexity and lack of clarity in language within the bill could lead to public misinterpretation and potential opposition.
Potential Impact on Specific Stakeholders
The bill affects various stakeholders, ranging from energy companies to conservationists and local communities. Energy companies may find opportunities in the exceptions for directional drilling, which allow resource extraction under specific conditions. However, the restrictions are stringent, potentially limiting extensive development.
Conservation groups are likely to support the bill’s emphasis on preserving wilderness areas, although they may express concerns over potential resource extraction loopholes. Local communities stand to benefit from increased tourism and recreation opportunities, yet they might face disruptions from ongoing land management changes.
Ranchers and agricultural stakeholders may find some provisions beneficial, particularly those upholding grazing rights. However, they could encounter challenges related to restricted land access and vehicle usage, influencing their operational flexibility.
Overall, achieving a balance between development and conservation will be vital for the bill’s success, ensuring the legislation meets Wyoming’s environmental goals while considering economic interests.
Issues
The provision allowing the Secretary of the Interior to lease oil and gas resources through directional drilling while prohibiting surface occupancy and disturbance could present a loophole for energy extraction that may raise environmental concerns. Sections 3(b)(7)(B), 6(b)(6)(B), 8(b)(5)(B), and 8(c)(5)(B) discuss this exception.
Lack of clarity in terms like 'modern methods of fire suppression' and 'necessary maintenance or repairs' in fire and road management sections might lead to varying interpretations, potentially impacting enforcement and environmental protection. Refer to Sections 3(a)(1)(D), 4(b), and 3(a)(1)(C).
The broad authority granted without clear oversight in territory management, especially in Special Management Areas and Wilderness Areas, may result in decisions with insufficient transparency or accountability. Relevant Sections include 3(b), 8, and 4.
The potential bias or favoritism in land exchanges and grazing policies, especially in the Sweetwater Rocks and other Special Management Areas, could raise ethical and legal concerns about equitable resource management. Refer to Sections 4(b), 4(e)(3), and 4(b)(8).
Provisions related to grazing that refer to external documents for guidelines might cause confusion and lack of transparency for stakeholders not familiar with those documents. See Sections 3(a)(3)(B) and 6(a)(2)(B).
The prohibition on new roads but allowance for temporary roads in emergencies across different management areas could lead to potential misuse if not strictly regulated. Sections 3(a)(1)(C), 5(b)(2), and 8 discuss road construction and maintenance.
The absence of a specified timeline for implementing specific land management or improvement plans, such as the travel management plans for special management areas, could lead to delays in execution and potential inconsistencies. Refer to Section 4(b)(3) and 6(c)(C).
The ambiguity in the phrase 'any substantially similar rule' related to BLM rule application could lead to legal disputes over interpretation, impacting land management and compliance. Refer to Section 7.
Complex language in designating boundaries and areas might make it difficult for the general public to understand, potentially affecting public engagement and support. This is evident in Sections 3, 4, and 6.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it will be officially known as the "Wyoming Public Lands Initiative Act of 2023."
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines several key terms used in the Act: "Bureau" refers to the Bureau of Land Management, "Department" means the Department of the Interior, "Director" is the Director of the Bureau of Land Management, "emergency" describes a situation needing quick action due to immediate danger to people's safety or to property, "range improvement" is as defined in the Public Rangelands Improvement Act, and "State" refers specifically to Wyoming.
3. Designation of land in Carbon County, Wyoming Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section designates certain lands in Carbon County, Wyoming, as wilderness areas and special management areas with guidelines for their administration and protection. It includes specific provisions for maintaining roads, handling wildfires, grazing, and restrictions on new road constructions and commercial timber harvesting, while also outlining how lands released from wilderness study designations should be managed.
4. Designation of land in Fremont and Natrona Counties, Wyoming Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section of the bill designates certain lands in Fremont and Natrona Counties, Wyoming, as wilderness areas and special management areas, and outlines management practices for these lands. It also includes guidelines for motorized vehicle use, land exchanges, grazing, and infrastructure maintenance, along with the establishment of new conservation areas and motorized recreation areas, and releases certain wilderness study areas from further consideration.
5. Designation of land in Johnson and Campbell Counties, Wyoming Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section designates specific land areas in Wyoming as management areas, outlining guidelines for their administration. It prohibits new permanent roads and the use of motorized vehicles, except in certain cases like emergencies or forest health, restricts infrastructure development, and withdraws these lands from mining and leasing, although oil and gas resources can be accessed using specific methods.
6. Designation of land in Washakie and Hot Springs Counties, Wyoming Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text designates areas of land in Washakie and Hot Springs Counties, Wyoming, including the Bobcat Draw Wilderness and the Cedar Mountain Special Management Area, with specific guidelines for their management, preservation, and use. It sets rules for activities like grazing, motorized vehicle use, and resource extraction while directing future planning and study for these lands to ensure environmental protection and recreational opportunities.
7. Application of BLM rule Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed rule by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), titled “Conservation and Landscape Health,” and any similar rules, will not be applicable to the land mentioned in this Act.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section specifies that the official title of the Act is the “Wyoming Public Lands Initiative Act of 2023.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines terms used in the Act, such as "Bureau" for the Bureau of Land Management, "range improvement" as defined in the Public Rangelands Improvement Act of 1978, "Secretary" for the Secretary of the Interior, "State" referring to Wyoming, and "wilderness area" as designated in section 3.
3. Designation of wilderness areas Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section designates certain areas in the state as wilderness under the Wilderness Act, meaning they will be protected as part of the National Wilderness Preservation System. These areas include the Encampment River Canyon Wilderness, Prospect Mountain Wilderness, Upper and Lower Sweetwater Canyon Wilderness, and Bobcat Draw Wilderness, and specific boundaries and exclusions for each area are described.
4. Administration of wilderness areas Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section explains how the Secretary will manage wilderness areas according to existing laws, with the ability to handle fires and disease by coordinating with local agencies. It also clarifies that grazing already happening before the law was enacted can continue, and it assures that activities outside these areas are not restricted just because they can be seen or heard from within the wilderness.
5. Release of Wilderness Study Areas Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the release of specified wilderness study areas, declaring them as having been sufficiently evaluated for potential wilderness designation. Any portion of these areas not designated as wilderness is to be managed according to existing federal laws, land management plans, and specific provisions for each area, allowing for certain activities like mineral leasing with restrictions, and implementing management measures such as developing travel management plans.
6. Establishment of Dubois Badlands National Conservation Area Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes the Dubois Badlands National Conservation Area, covering about 4,446 acres of federal land, to conserve and protect its natural and cultural resources. The area will be managed to maintain its ecological and recreational values, with restrictions on uses like motorized vehicles and grazing, and it is withdrawn from most forms of mining and land appropriation.
7. Establishment of Dubois Motorized Recreation Area Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Dubois Motorized Recreation Area, covering about 367.72 acres of federal land, has been officially established and will be managed by the Bureau. A fence will be built along its western boundary, and a plan for managing motorized vehicle use in the area will be developed after the fence is completed.
8. Establishment of Special Management Areas Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The document establishes several Special Management Areas (SMAs) on Federal lands for purposes like enhancing natural, historic, recreational, and ecological values. These areas have specific rules, such as no new road construction and limited vehicle access. Activities like grazing are allowed under specific laws, and while these areas are generally protected from mining and resource extraction, certain oil and gas leases are possible if accessed from outside the SMAs without surface disturbance.
9. Lander Slope Area of Critical Environmental Concern and Red Canyon Area of Critical Environmental Concern Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the transfer and management of certain lands in Fremont County, Wyoming, including exchanging federally managed land for state-owned land in areas of environmental concern and conducting a study on developing motorized recreation areas. It also establishes a Fremont County Implementation Team to assist in managing these efforts, exempting it from the Federal Advisory Committee Act.
10. Study of land in Hot Springs and Washakie Counties Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Secretary to conduct a study on the possibility of developing new special motorized recreation areas in Hot Springs and Washakie Counties. The study will focus on federal lands, excluding areas where motorized vehicles are restricted, and will involve public input and collaboration with local state parks and county entities. A report with the findings must be submitted to Congress within two years.