Overview
Title
To prioritize funding for an expanded and sustained national investment in basic science research.
ELI5 AI
The "American Innovation Act" is a plan by the U.S. government to give more money to scientists so they can do important research that helps everyone, and it makes sure this money keeps coming even if other parts of the budget get cut.
Summary AI
S. 1276, known as the "American Innovation Act," aims to increase funding for basic science research in the United States. The bill outlines specific amounts to be appropriated each fiscal year from 2026 to 2035 for various agencies, including the National Science Foundation, the Department of Energy's Office of Science, the Department of Defense science and technology programs, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, and NASA's Science Mission Directorate. From 2036 onwards, funding will increase annually based on inflation. Additionally, the bill exempts these appropriations from budgetary sequestration, ensuring stable funding unaffected by automatic federal budget cuts.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The "American Innovation Act" is a legislative proposal introduced in the 119th Congress, designed to increase funding for basic science research in the United States. It outlines a plan to significantly boost appropriations for various scientific and technological programs over a ten-year period starting in 2026. The key entities benefiting from this bill include the National Science Foundation, the Department of Energy's Office of Science, the Department of Defense science and technology programs, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, and NASA's Science Mission Directorate. The funding is structured to increase annually, aligning with inflation as measured by the Consumer Price Index. Importantly, the bill exempts these appropriations from certain fiscal restrictions and budgetary scoring processes, aiming to create an environment conducive to long-term innovation investment.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several noteworthy issues arise from the bill's provisions. Firstly, the bill establishes a mechanism for annual funding increases tied to inflation, which could lead to unforeseen fiscal burdens if inflation rates surge unexpectedly. Secondly, by exempting the allocated funds from sequestration—budgetary cuts intended to enforce fiscal discipline—the bill potentially undermines flexibility in federal budget management. Furthermore, this exemption might raise concerns regarding accountability and transparency, as similar principles apply to its exclusion from PAYGO scorecards, systems designed to keep federal spending in check. Lastly, while the bill's intentions favor science and technology innovation, the complex language used in some sections can be challenging for the general public to interpret, limiting wider understanding.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, the bill holds the promise of fostering advancements in science and technology that can yield societal benefits, such as medical breakthroughs, improved energy solutions, and technological innovation. These enhancements can lead to better quality of life and drive economic growth, positioning the nation as a leader in global innovation.
However, the financial implications could also result in increased national debt if not managed prudently, leading to potential tax increases or reallocation of budgets that affect other public services, which might concern taxpayers and advocates of fiscal responsibility.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
The most significant positive impact of the bill would be on the scientific community, providing stable and increased funding that could facilitate long-term research projects and offer more opportunities for innovation and exploration. Universities and laboratories could see expanded research capacities, leading to educational and employment growth in scientific fields.
Conversely, government fiscal managers and budget watchdogs might view the exemptions from traditional budgetary constraints as risky, potentially setting precedents for other sectors to seek similar treatment. This could complicate efforts to maintain comprehensive fiscal oversight and discipline across all federal programs.
In conclusion, while the "American Innovation Act" is an ambitious step towards reinforcing the United States' commitment to science and technology, it comes with a set of challenges and controversies that warrant careful consideration and ongoing scrutiny to balance the commendable goals with sound fiscal management.
Financial Assessment
The "American Innovation Act" (S. 1276) outlines a significant financial commitment towards basic science research in the United States. This proposal specifies various appropriations across several key government agencies.
Financial Summary
The bill allocates substantial annual funding from fiscal years 2026 through 2035 for agencies such as the National Science Foundation, the Department of Energy's Office of Science, the Department of Defense's science and technology programs, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, and NASA's Science Mission Directorate. For example, the National Science Foundation is set to receive $9.735 billion in 2026, with a scheduled increase to $18.279 billion by 2035. Similarly, the Department of Energy Office of Science begins with $8.854 billion in 2026, rising to $16.624 billion by 2035. These figures underline a robust investment strategy in the nation's research capabilities.
From 2036 onward, the funding is designed to increase annually in accordance with the U.S. Consumer Price Index, which adjusts for inflation, ensuring the amounts keep pace with economic changes.
Issues and Implications
Several issues arise from the financial structure proposed by the Act:
Inflation-Based Adjustments: The provision that allows appropriations to increase annually based on inflation could lead to unpredictable and potentially excessive future spending. This approach, while protecting against inflation's eroding effects, raises concerns about fiscal responsibility and the long-term sustainability of such spending increases.
Exemption from Sequestration: By exempting these appropriations from sequestration (automatic federal budget cuts), the bill aims to secure stable funding for scientific research. However, this could limit financial flexibility and challenge budgetary discipline. The exemption might foster a lack of accountability in times of budgetary constraint, leading to potential controversy.
Exclusion from PAYGO: The bill explicitly exempts these appropriations from inclusion on Statutory and Senate PAYGO scorecards, which are typically used to enforce budget neutrality. By bypassing these mechanisms, the appropriations may not be accounted for in the broader fiscal landscape, raising questions about transparency and fiscal prudence.
Indefinite Availability of Funds: Funds are to remain available until they are fully spent, which could lead to indefinite financial liabilities. Such permanence may encourage delays and reduce the sense of urgency needed for efficient fund utilization, presenting a challenge in terms of government spending policy.
Complexity and Clarity: The legal and financial language of the subsections may present barriers to understanding for the general public. This complexity might result in misinterpretations and challenges for those not versed in legal or financial jargon, thereby impacting transparency and public engagement.
Overall, while the bill proposes a substantial and potentially transformative investment in U.S. scientific research, it raises questions about fiscal responsibility, transparency, and long-term financial planning. These aspects are crucial for ensuring that such an investment translates into tangible and sustained advancements in science and technology.
Issues
The appropriations clause in Section 2 allows for unrestricted increases based on the Consumer Price Index, which could lead to unplanned and potentially excessive future spending. This raises significant concerns about fiscal responsibility and could have widespread political and financial implications.
The exemption from sequestration stated in Section 2(d) could limit fiscal flexibility and accountability, as the funds appropriated would not be subject to deficit reduction measures. This has legal and financial implications and could be controversial due to its potential impact on budgetary discipline.
Section 2(e) exempts the appropriations from being entered on PAYGO scorecards, potentially undermining fiscal responsibility and transparency because these appropriations will not be considered in budget enforcement mechanisms. This could lead to political and ethical concerns regarding the bypassing of standard budgetary procedures.
Amounts appropriated under Section 2(b) are to remain available until expended, which could lead to indefinite liabilities and encourage a lack of urgency or accountability in utilizing the funds effectively. This has financial and accountability implications, making it controversial in terms of government spending policy.
Subsections (a) and (b) of Section 2 contain complex legal and financial language that may be difficult for a layperson to understand without specialized knowledge. This lack of clarity could result in misunderstandings or misinterpretations and presents issues in terms of public accessibility and transparency.
Section 1 is purely a Short title and does not provide substantive provisions for analysis or the opportunity for public scrutiny on potential biases or allocations, which can be politically and ethically relevant when considering the overall aims of the legislation.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this bill is called the "American Innovation Act," which serves as the official, short title of the legislation.
2. Appropriations for innovation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section authorizes specific amounts of money from the Treasury to be allocated to various science and technology programs from 2026 to 2036, including the National Science Foundation and the Department of Energy's Office of Science. Additionally, the funds are exempt from certain budget restrictions, and their effects won't be counted in specific budget scorecards.
Money References
- FOUNDATION.—For the National Science Foundation— (A) for fiscal year 2026, $9,735,000,000; (B) for fiscal year 2027, $10,447,000,000; (C) for fiscal year 2028, $11,205,000,000; (D) for fiscal year 2029, $12,016,000,000; (E) for fiscal year 2030, $12,886,000,000; (F) for fiscal year 2031, $13,818,000,000; (G) for fiscal year 2032, $14,818,000,000; (H) for fiscal year 2033, $15,892,000,000; (I) for fiscal year 2034, $17,043,000,000; (J) for fiscal year 2035, $18,279,000,000; and (K) for fiscal year 2036 and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount appropriated under this paragraph for the previous fiscal year, increased by the percentage increase (if any), during the previous fiscal year, in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2) DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, OFFICE OF SCIENCE.—For the Office of Science at the Department of Energy— (A) for fiscal year 2026, $8,854,000,000; (B) for fiscal year 2027, $9,501,000,000; (C) for fiscal year 2028, $10,191,000,000; (D) for fiscal year 2029, $10,929,000,000; (E) for fiscal year 2030, $11,720,000,000; (F) for fiscal year 2031, $12,568,000,000; (G) for fiscal year 2032, $13,477,000,000; (H) for fiscal year 2033, $14,453,000,000; (I) for fiscal year 2034, $15,501,000,000; (J) for fiscal year 2035, $16,624,000,000; and (K) for fiscal year 2036 and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount appropriated under this paragraph for the previous fiscal year, increased by the percentage increase (if any), during the previous fiscal year, in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. (3) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMS.—For the Department of Defense science and technology programs— (A) for fiscal year 2026, $23,109,000,000; (B) for fiscal year 2027, $24,799,000,000; (C) for fiscal year 2028, $26,259,000,000; (D) for fiscal year 2029, $28,525,000,000; (E) for fiscal year 2030, $30,590,000,000; (F) for fiscal year 2031, $32,803,000,000; (G) for fiscal year 2032, $35,178,000,000; (H) for fiscal year 2033, $37,725,000,000; (I) for fiscal year 2034, $40,459,000,000; (J) for fiscal year 2035, $43,392,000,000; and (K) for fiscal year 2036 and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount appropriated under this paragraph for the previous fiscal year, increased by the percentage increase (if any), during the previous fiscal year, in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. (4) NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF STANDARDS AND TECHNOLOGY SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL RESEARCH AND SERVICES.—For the scientific and technical research and services of the National Institute of Standards and Technology at the Department of Commerce— (A) for fiscal year 2026, $1,244,000,000; (B) for fiscal year 2027, $1,335,000,000; (C) for fiscal year 2028, $1,431,000,000; (D) for fiscal year 2029, $1,535,000,000; (E) for fiscal year 2030, $1,646,000,000; (F) for fiscal year 2031, $1,765,000,000; (G) for fiscal year 2032, $1,893,000,000; (H) for fiscal year 2033, $2,030,000,000; (I) for fiscal year 2034, $2,177,000,000; (J) for fiscal year 2035, $2,335,000,000; and (K) for fiscal year 2036 and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount appropriated under this paragraph for the previous fiscal year, increased by the percentage increase (if any), during the previous fiscal year, in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
- (5) NATIONAL AERONAUTICS AND SPACE ADMINISTRATION SCIENCE MISSION DIRECTORATE.—For the Science Mission Directorate at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration— (A) for fiscal year 2026, $7,880,000,000; (B) for fiscal year 2027, $8,457,000,000; (C) for fiscal year 2028, $9,070,000,000; (D) for fiscal year 2029, $9,727,000,000; (E) for fiscal year 2030, $10,431,000,000; (F) for fiscal year 2031, $11,186,000,000; (G) for fiscal year 2032, $11,995,000,000; (H) for fiscal year 2033, $12,864,000,000; (I) for fiscal year 2034, $13,796,000,000; (J) for fiscal year 2035, $14,796,000,000; and (K) for fiscal year 2036 and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount appropriated under this paragraph for the previous fiscal year, increased by the percentage increase (if any), during the previous fiscal year, in the Consumer Price Index for all urban consumers published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. (b) Availability.—Amounts appropriated under subsection (a) shall remain available until expended. (c) Definitions.—In this section: (1) DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMS.—The term “Department of Defense science and technology programs” means the appropriations accounts that support the various institutes, offices, and centers that make up the Department of Defense science and technology programs.