Overview
Title
To amend the Higher Education Act of 1965 to provide for a Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan as an income contingent repayment plan.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to make it easier for people to pay back their student loans by letting them pay based on how much money they make. If they make small payments for a certain number of years, the rest of what they owe could be forgiven, which means they don't have to pay it back anymore.
Summary AI
The bill S. 1220 proposes changes to the Higher Education Act of 1965 to introduce a new student loan repayment plan called the "Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment (SOAR) plan," which is an income contingent repayment option. It allows borrowers to make monthly payments based on their income, with the option to have some or all of their remaining loan balance forgiven after a certain number of qualifying payments. The bill also outlines specific eligibility criteria, payment calculation methods, and procedures for determining a borrowerâs monthly payment obligations. Additionally, it mentions the phase-out of certain existing repayment plans while adding new conditions to the eligibility for loan discharge.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed legislation, titled the "Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment Act," seeks to amend the Higher Education Act of 1965, introducing a new repayment plan for student loans. Known as the Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan, the bill aims to provide an income-contingent repayment option to make loan payments more manageable for borrowers, improve the terms of repayment, and potentially offer loan forgiveness after a set period of consistent payments.
General Summary of the Bill
The bill introduces an income-contingent repayment plan that sets monthly payments according to the borrower's income, with the intention of reducing the financial burden on low-income borrowers. It outlines conditions under which loans may be forgiven after 10 to 15 years of qualifying payments. The bill seeks to phase out previous repayment plans such as the Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and Income Contingent Repayment (ICR), providing a new framework for structuring repayment in terms of borrowers' financial circumstances over time.
Significant Issues
Complexity and Accessibility: The bill is characterized by complex legal language and numerous cross-references, making it challenging for the general public to comprehend without legal expertise. This complexity may hinder widespread understanding and accessibility.
Computational Challenges: Calculating the "monthly payment obligation" involves intricate calculations based on income, family size, and other financial factors. Such complexity could result in confusion among borrowers regarding their obligations and complicate the management of repayments.
Privacy Concerns: To determine repayment eligibility, the bill requires borrowers to disclose sensitive tax information. This requirement raises ethical concerns about the potential infringement on borrowers' privacy rights.
Administrative Efficiency: Implementing the detailed procedures for eligibility determination could result in inefficiencies and delays. The detailed criteria and processes may pose administrative burdens that complicate effective execution.
Payment Processing: The flexibility allowed in terms of payment installments or lump sums could complicate payment tracking, leading to administrative inefficiencies or errors in processing payments.
Impact on the Public
The broader public would likely experience both benefits and challenges from this bill. On the positive side, borrowers with limited income may find relief from reduced monthly payments, providing them with financial stability and reducing default rates. On the negative side, the complexities involved might deter some potential applicants who cannot fully grasp the intricacies without guidance.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Borrowers: Those with lower incomes stand to benefit significantly from reduced payment requirements, potentially improving their financial well-being. However, the complexity in determining eligibility and understanding the payment obligations might discourage some borrowers from enrolling in or benefiting from the plan fully.
Loan Servicers: These organizations may face increased administrative challenges and costs in adapting to the new repayment procedures and managing the diverse repayment options offered by the act.
Policy Makers and Educators: There is an opportunity to address public concerns, simplify the language used, and clarify the eligibility criteria, thereby improving the bill's effectiveness and reception among the public.
Tax Authorities and Privacy Advocates: Striking a balance between the need for financial information to implement the plan and respecting privacy rights will be crucial. Ensuring robust privacy protections could alleviate concerns about data safety and misuse.
In summary, the "Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment Act" has the potential to greatly benefit borrowers needing financial relief, but it also presents significant challenges in terms of complexity, administration, and potential privacy issues. Addressing these issues effectively will be critical to ensuring the successful implementation and acceptance of the proposed changes.
Financial Assessment
The bill S. 1220 introduces a new student loan repayment plan named the "Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment (SOAR) plan." This plan is aimed at offering an income-contingent repayment method, meaning that borrowers' payments will be calculated based on their income levels. The financial aspects of the bill center on the calculation of these payments and the possible loan forgiveness after a certain number of qualifying payments. This commentary will explore the financial references within the bill and discuss related issues.
Financial References Within the Bill
A significant financial reference in the bill is the determination of a borrower's monthly payment obligation. It establishes that the payment amount will be calculated based on a borrower's income, specifically noting:
- For income that is less than or equal to 250 percent of the poverty line, the monthly payment is $0.
- For income above 250 percent of the poverty line, the payment will be 5 percent for undergraduate loans and 10 percent for other loans, which shows a tiered approach pegged to income and loan type.
The bill also contains provisions for loan forgiveness. If a borrower has made a specific number of paymentsâ120 monthly payments for undergraduate loans or 180 monthly payments for other loansâthe remaining loan balance could be forgiven. This aspect highlights significant financial relief to borrowers meeting these criteria.
Relation to Identified Issues
Complex Language and Accessibility
The bill employs complex calculations for determining the monthly payment obligations and loan forgiveness criteria. These calculations involve percentages and proportional income adjustments relative to the poverty line, as well as the division of loan types, which may be difficult for general borrowers to comprehend. Consequently, there is a potential for misunderstandings that could lead to mismanagement of personal finances or loan repayments.
Privacy and Administrative Concerns
The requirement for borrowers to disclose financial and tax information to verify eligibility raises privacy concerns. Borrowers might feel uneasy about sharing sensitive information, which could discourage them from using the repayment plan. The administrative process behind gathering this information could also increase operational costs to the government, diluting financial efficiency.
Moreover, the administration of such intricate calculations and payment tracking requirements under the new repayment plan could introduce inefficiencies. For instance, handling and processing low monthly payments, described in the Minimal Payment Obligation clause, could lead to administrative spending that outweighs the value of these small payments themselves.
Restrictions on Existing Repayment Plans
The bill places new restrictions on existing plans, like the Pay As You Earn (PAYE) and Income Contingent Repayment (ICR) plans, where borrowers might lose flexibility if they do not comply with stringent criteria. These restrictions could affect borrowers financially, especially those with high income variability or those who are unable to provide immediate tax documentation, making some individuals feel unfairly treated.
Conclusion
In summary, the financial aspects of the bill propose a structured and income-sensitive approach to loan repayment, but they also bring forth potential issues such as complexity, privacy concerns, and administrative costs. Understanding these financial references and their implications is crucial for both borrowers who intend to utilize this plan and for policymakers who will implement and manage these provisions.
Issues
Section 2: The complex language and numerous cross-references make the bill difficult for the general public to understand without legal expertise, potentially limiting its accessibility and transparency.
Section 2: The provisions for calculating the 'monthly payment obligation' involve intricate calculations that may be challenging for borrowers to understand, leading to potential confusion and mismanagement of repayments.
Section 493E: Determining eligibility for repayment plans could conflict with privacy concerns due to the requirement of disclosing sensitive tax information, raising ethical issues regarding borrower privacy rights.
Section 2: The rules regarding restrictions on repayment plans like PAYE and ICR may limit borrower flexibility and could disadvantage those unable to meet specific criteria, potentially leading to claims of unfair treatment.
Section 493E: Administrative complexities could arise due to the detailed procedures required for eligibility determination and recalculations, leading to potential inefficiencies and delays in implementing the repayment plan.
Section 2: The process for a borrower to pay in multiple installments or a lump sum could complicate payment tracking, potentially leading to administrative inefficiencies or errors in payment processing.
Section 493E: Potential for wasteful administrative spending due to small payment thresholds in the 'Minimal Payment Obligation' clause, where costs of managing such payments may outweigh the benefits.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act states its official short title, which is the âSavings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment Act.â
2. Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan amends the Higher Education Act of 1965, introducing an income contingent repayment option for student loans. This plan reduces monthly payments for low-income borrowers, provides options for loan forgiveness after consistent payments over a set period, and outlines specific conditions for eligibility and loan repayment calculations.
Money References
- The term âeligible loanâ means a loan made, insured, or guaranteed under part B or D. â(2) MONTHLY PAYMENT OBLIGATION.â â(A) IN GENERAL.âThe term âmonthly payment obligationâ, when used with respect to a borrower, means that for such borrower the monthly payment amount due on the total amount of eligible loans made to such borrower that is equal to, except as provided in subparagraph (B)â â(i) $0 for the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is less than or equal to 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)); plus â(ii) 5 percent of the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is greater than 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)), prorated by the percentage that is the result of dividing the borrower's original total loan balance attributable to eligible loans received for the borrower's undergraduate study by the original total loan balance attributable to all eligible loans, divided by 12; plus â(iii) for loans not subject to clause (ii), 10 percent of the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is greater than 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)), prorated by the percentage that is the result of dividing the borrower's original total loan balance minus the original total loan balance of loans subject to clause (ii) by the borrower's original total loan balance attributable to all eligible loans, divided by 12.
- â(B) MINIMAL PAYMENT OBLIGATION.âIf the calculation of the monthly payment amount due under subparagraph (A) for a borrower isâ â(i) less than $5, then the monthly payment obligation for such borrower is equal to $0; and â(ii) equal to or greater than $5 but less than $10, then the monthly payment obligation for such borrower is equal to $10.
- â(6) A monthly payment or the equivalent shall be satisfied by any of the following: â(A) A month in which the borrowerâ â(i) makes a monthly payment that is equal to not less than the monthly payment obligation of the borrower; or â(ii) has a monthly payment obligation of $0.
- â(C) A month in which the borrower receives a deferment or forbearance of repayment not described in subparagraph (B), but for which the borrower makes an additional payment equal to or greater than their monthly payment obligation (including a monthly payment obligation of $0), for a deferment or forbearance that ended within 3 years of the date of such additional payment and occurred on or after the date that is 180 days after the date of enactment of the Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment Act.
- â(D) A month in which the borrowerâ â(i) makes a payment pursuant to a repayment plan under section 493C or section 455(d)(1)(E), or another income continent repayment plan under section 455(d)(1)(D), or had a monthly payment obligation under such a plan of $0; â(ii) makes a payment under the standard repayment plan, as described in section 428(b)(9)(A)(i); or â(iii) makes a payment under a repayment plan with payments that are as least as much as they would have been under the standard repayment plan, as described in section 428(b)(9)(A)(i).
493E. Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan establishes a system for borrowers of certain student loans that allows them to limit their monthly payments based on their income, and offers loan cancellation after a set number of payments or years. It provides guidelines on how payments are allocated, how the plan can be managed and adjusted annually, and specific provisions for married borrowers.
Money References
- â (A) IN GENERAL.âThe term âmonthly payment obligationâ, when used with respect to a borrower, means that for such borrower the monthly payment amount due on the total amount of eligible loans made to such borrower that is equal to, except as provided in subparagraph (B)â (i) $0 for the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is less than or equal to 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)); plus (ii) 5 percent of the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is greater than 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)), prorated by the percentage that is the result of dividing the borrower's original total loan balance attributable to eligible loans received for the borrower's undergraduate study by the original total loan balance attributable to all eligible loans, divided by 12; plus (iii) for loans not subject to clause (ii), 10 percent of the portion of the borrower's, and the borrower's spouse's (if applicable), adjusted gross income (as defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) that is greater than 250 percent of the poverty line applicable to the borrower's family size as determined under section 673(2) of the Community Services Block Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)), prorated by the percentage that is the result of dividing the borrower's original total loan balance minus the original total loan balance of loans subject to clause (ii) by the borrower's original total loan balance attributable to all eligible loans, divided by 12. (B) MINIMAL PAYMENT
- OBLIGATION.âIf the calculation of the monthly payment amount due under subparagraph (A) for a borrower isâ (i) less than $5, then the monthly payment obligation for such borrower is equal to $0; and (ii) equal to or greater than $5 but less than $10, then the monthly payment obligation for such borrower is equal to $10. (b) Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment authorized.âNotwithstanding any other provision of this Act, the Secretary shall carry out a Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment plan program that complies with the following: (1) A borrower of any eligible loan may elect to have the borrower's aggregate monthly payment for all such loans not exceed the monthly payment obligation of such borrower.
- (6) A monthly payment or the equivalent shall be satisfied by any of the following: (A) A month in which the borrowerâ (i) makes a monthly payment that is equal to not less than the monthly payment obligation of the borrower; or (ii) has a monthly payment obligation of $0. (B)
- A month in which the borrower receives a deferment or forbearance of repayment not described in subparagraph (B), but for which the borrower makes an additional payment equal to or greater than their monthly payment obligation (including a monthly payment obligation of $0), for a deferment or forbearance that ended within 3 years of the date of such additional payment and occurred on or after the date that is 180 days after the date of enactment of the Savings Opportunity and Affordable Repayment Act.
- A month in which the borrowerâ (i) makes a payment pursuant to a repayment plan under section 493C or section 455(d)(1)(E), or another income continent repayment plan under section 455(d)(1)(D), or had a monthly payment obligation under such a plan of $0; (ii) makes a payment under the standard repayment plan, as described in section 428(b)(9)(A)(i); or (iii) makes a payment under a repayment plan with payments that are as least as much as they would have been under the standard repayment plan, as described in section 428(b)(9)(A)(i).