Overview
Title
To redesignate the Salem Maritime National Historic Site as the Salem Maritime National Historical Park, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 1161 wants to change the name of the Salem Maritime National Historic Site to Salem Maritime National Historical Park and look into adding more places to the park to make it bigger and better.
Summary AI
S. 1161 proposes to rename the Salem Maritime National Historic Site to the "Salem Maritime National Historical Park." It mandates that any legal references to the old name be updated to reflect this change. The bill also requires the Secretary of the Interior to conduct a study on expanding the boundaries of the park to include additional sites in Salem, Massachusetts, associated with its maritime, military, and coastal defense history. The findings of this study must be reported to specific Congressional committees within three years after funding is provided.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
This bill proposes to change the name of the Salem Maritime National Historic Site to the Salem Maritime National Historical Park. Additionally, it directs the Secretary of the Interior to evaluate whether more areas connected to maritime, coastal, and military history around Salem, Massachusetts, should be included in the National Park System. The bill also outlines a requirement for a report to be submitted to congressional committees after funds for the study are allocated.
Summary of Significant Issues
Redesignation Implications
One of the prominent issues with this bill is the lack of justification for the redesignation of the historic site to a historical park. The bill does not specify the reasoning behind this change or the benefits that it is expected to bring. Furthermore, the redesignation could lead to unforeseen costs related to updating signs, maps, and various official documents.
Boundary Study Concerns
The boundary study intended to explore the feasibility of expanding the National Park System in the Salem area has its own set of issues. The timeline for delivering the study's findings is not explicitly defined; it is linked to the availability of funds rather than having a set date, which can result in delays. Additionally, the budget for conducting the study is not specified, leaving financial aspects unaddressed, which may lead to unchecked spending.
The geographic scope defined as "Salem, Massachusetts, and its vicinity" is rather vague, possibly causing ambiguity in determining the study area. A more precise definition would help in clarifying which specific sites and resources are to be considered.
Potential Impact on the Public
The broader public could see mixed impacts from the redesignation and boundary study. On the positive side, redesignation might increase the visibility and significance of the Salem Maritime area, potentially attracting more visitors and boosting local tourism. This could also enhance public awareness of maritime and military history associated with Salem.
However, without a clear justification or an understanding of the potential costs associated with these changes, taxpayers might question whether the benefits outweigh the expenditures. Concerns about government spending and financial efficiency might be particularly significant if the study incurs high costs without producing tangible results.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For local businesses and the tourism industry in Salem, the redesignation could create opportunities by drawing in more tourists interested in historical parks, which may increase local revenue and stimulate the economy. Historical societies and stakeholders invested in preserving Salem's history might benefit from greater national recognition and funding that could come with the area's elevation to a historical park status.
Conversely, municipal authorities and local residents might face challenges related to administrative changes required by the redesignation. Costs associated with altered signage and promotional materials, without additional funding or planning support, might strain local resources.
In conclusion, while the bill aims to bring positive changes to the Salem Maritime area, it raises several issues that require careful consideration to ensure effective implementation and broad public benefit.
Issues
The section on 'Boundary study' (Section 3) lacks clarity regarding the timeline for the study report submission, as it is tied to the availability of funds rather than a specific date. This could lead to potential delays and a lack of accountability for the timely completion of the study.
Section 3 on 'Boundary study' does not specify the cost or budget required for conducting the study, which could potentially lead to unchecked or excessive spending without oversight.
The 'Boundary study' (Section 3) lacks specific geographic definitions for the 'study area,' merely referring to it as 'Salem, Massachusetts, and its vicinity'. This could lead to ambiguity and confusion regarding the scope of the study.
The 'Redesignation' (Section 2) might lead to unforeseen costs associated with changing signage, maps, and documents, as it does not address these potential expenditures explicitly.
The necessity and implications of the 'Redesignation' (Section 2) are not clearly justified in the bill, which may raise questions about the reasons for the change and whether it is warranted.
The bill makes no mention of any consultation with local stakeholders or historians regarding the redesignation of the historical site (Section 2), which could affect community acceptance and support.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section briefly states the title of the Act. It indicates that the Act can be called the "Salem Maritime National Historical Park Redesignation and Boundary Study Act."
2. Salem Maritime National Historical Park Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Salem Maritime National Historic Site is being renamed to the Salem Maritime National Historical Park. This change means that any mention of the historic site in U.S. laws or documents will now refer to the historical park.
3. Boundary study Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Secretary of the Interior to conduct a study to consider whether sites related to maritime, coastal, and military history in Salem, Massachusetts, and nearby areas could become part of the National Park System. The results of this study, including any recommendations, must be reported to certain Congressional committees within three years once funding is available.