Overview
Title
To amend the Clean Air Act to eliminate a waiver under that Act, to eliminate an authorization for States to use new motor vehicle emission and new motor vehicle engine emissions standards identical to standards adopted in California, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill is like a rule that says California and other states can't make their own special rules to keep the air cleaner than what the whole country already decided. It's like saying everyone has to follow the same rules, even if some people want to be extra careful about keeping the air clean.
Summary AI
The bill S. 1072, known as the "Stop CARB Act of 2025", aims to modify the Clean Air Act by eliminating the waiver that allows California and other states to set their own emissions standards for vehicles, which are stricter than federal standards. It prohibits states from enforcing their standards for emissions from nonroad engines and vehicles, such as construction and farm equipment. The bill also repeals Section 177 of the Clean Air Act, removing the authorization for states to adopt California's vehicle emission standards.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The proposed bill, titled the "Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2025," seeks to amend the Clean Air Act. Its primary aim is to eliminate the ability of states, particularly California, to implement their own vehicle emission standards, which are often more stringent than federal standards. Additionally, the bill aims to standardize emission controls across the entire United States by repealing a waiver system that allowed states to adopt and enforce their own emission standards for nonroad engines and vehicles, such as those used in construction and farming. This legislative adjustment also involves making a series of changes to various sections of the Clean Air Act to remove any provisions that previously supported state-specific emission standards.
Significant Issues
A central issue with this bill is the potential restriction on states' rights to enforce stricter emission standards that address local environmental needs, especially if federal standards are considered less comprehensive. Furthermore, the automatic denial of all pending waiver applications without any case-specific review raises concerns about fairness and due process. There is also a lack of clarity regarding why California's specific standards are being targeted, without a clear analysis provided within the text to justify this decision. This absence of detail raises questions about the potential environmental impact of such a repeal.
Broad Public Impact
If enacted, this bill could lead to a more uniform set of emission standards across the United States, which might simplify regulatory compliance for manufacturers operating in multiple states. However, this uniformity may come at the expense of environmental protection, as stricter state standards that cater to specific environmental conditions or policy goals would be nullified. States like California, which have historically set more advanced standards, might be limited in their ability to combat local air pollution effectively without the ability to impose tougher regulations.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
The bill could have mixed implications for different stakeholders. Automakers and other manufacturers might view this legislation favorably due to the reduced complexity in meeting varying emission standards across states, potentially lowering compliance costs. Conversely, environmental advocacy groups and certain state governments, particularly those led by policymakers focused on climate action and public health, may perceive this bill negatively as it limits their regulatory autonomy and could potentially result in less robust protections against air pollution. Lastly, residents in states that suffer from significant air quality issues might experience adverse health impacts if stricter emission standards are repealed, possibly leading to increased public health costs in the long term.
Issues
The repeal of state waivers for emission standards (Section 2) might significantly impact states' rights to implement stricter environmental regulations, raising concerns about federal overreach and potential environmental consequences.
The complete denial of pending waiver applications without case-specific review (Section 2b) could be criticized for bypassing due process and disregarding nuanced environmental needs of individual states.
The lack of reasoning or analysis provided for repealing California's motor vehicle emission standards (Section 3) raises concerns about potential negative environmental impacts, especially given California's leadership in environmental regulation.
The subjective language of the bill's short title (Section 1) could lead to public misinterpretation of its intent and impact, promoting a divisive narrative about regulatory burden.
The broad prohibition on state standards for emission from nonroad engines or vehicles (Section 2d) could limit states' abilities to manage local environmental challenges effectively.
The bill's various amendments to the Clean Air Act (Sections 2 and 3) might lead to confusion and operational challenges due to the complexity and lack of a clear, consolidated summary of changes.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides the short title of the Act, which is to be called the “Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2025” or simply the “Stop CARB Act of 2025”.
2. Repeal of waivers of State standards Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section repeals waivers that allowed states to have their own standards for emissions control on nonroad engines and vehicles, such as those used in construction or farming. It also makes changes to various parts of the Clean Air Act to align with this new rule, meaning states can no longer enforce their own rules over federal ones on this issue.
3. Repeal of authorization to use California new motor vehicle emission standards Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill proposes repealing Section 177 of the Clean Air Act, which allowed California to set its own vehicle emission standards. Additionally, it calls for a minor change to another section of the Act, removing a sentence from Section 249(e)(3).