Overview
Title
To amend the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 to establish a dairy nutrition incentive program, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
S. 1021 is a plan to encourage people getting food assistance to buy more milk, cheese, and yogurt by giving them extra help and money to do so. It also checks how well these efforts work, but people are worried because it doesn't clearly say what foods count or how well the money is being used.
Summary AI
S. 1021 seeks to amend the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 by creating a dairy nutrition incentive program aimed at boosting the consumption of dairy products, such as milk, cheese, and yogurt, among people receiving supplemental nutrition assistance. The bill includes provisions for grants and cooperative agreements with eligible entities like state and local governments or nonprofits to carry out projects that focus on encouraging dairy purchases. Additionally, the bill mandates regular evaluations of these projects to measure their effectiveness and appropriate funding to support the program. The bill also plans to transition existing healthy fluid milk incentives projects into this new incentive framework, ensuring continuity and leveraging any additional program flexibilities.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The "Dairy Nutrition Incentive Program Act of 2025" proposes significant changes to the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008, aiming to establish a program that encourages the purchase and consumption of dairy products by individuals receiving Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits. The legislation outlines creating a system of incentives to encourage SNAP beneficiaries to choose dairy products when shopping for their households.
General Summary of the Bill
At its core, the bill seeks to increase the consumption of naturally nutrient-rich dairy products such as milk, yogurt, and cheese by incentivizing their purchase through SNAP. This is aimed to be achieved by providing grants to eligible entities, such as state governments and nonprofit organizations, to develop and test methods to promote dairy consumption. Additionally, the bill mandates an annual budget of $10 million to fund these projects, ensuring a consistent financial commitment to the program's objectives.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several issues arise within the bill that may affect its implementation and effectiveness:
Narrow Definition of Dairy Products: The bill's definition of what constitutes a "dairy product" might exclude beneficial dairy-based foods if they don't have milk as the first or second ingredient. This could limit product diversity available to SNAP beneficiaries.
Unclear Performance Metrics: The bill allocates significant funding without specifying clear performance metrics or outcomes. This lack of accountability could lead to inefficient use of funds.
Evaluation Standards: It lacks well-defined criteria for evaluating the effectiveness of funded projects, potentially leading to inconsistent evaluation methodologies.
Administrative Burdens: Smaller entities might find the application process for funding more burdensome, possibly favoring larger organizations with more resources.
Funding and Financial Assistance Ambiguity: There is a lack of specificity regarding the limits of additional financial assistance for technology upgrades, which could lead to unregulated spending.
Impact on the Public
The bill's primary aim is to improve dietary quality among SNAP recipients by promoting dairy consumption, which might positively impact public health by increasing the intake of essential nutrients. If implemented effectively, this could lead to improved nutritional outcomes for economically disadvantaged populations.
However, given that the program narrowly defines eligible dairy products, there could be potential limitations on the variety of products available to consumers, which might not align with the varied dietary preferences and health needs of all SNAP beneficiaries.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Dairy Industry: The dairy industry stands to benefit considerably from this bill due to increased demand for dairy products, potentially boosting sales and production.
Small Businesses and Local Producers: Those in the dairy sector could face challenges due to the potential administrative burden of applying for grants, as well as the technological demands associated with implementing point-of-sale incentives.
SNAP Beneficiaries: While they may benefit from increased purchasing power for dairy products, there is a concern about whether these incentives will truly meet their diverse nutritional needs, given the restrictive definitions within the bill.
Nonprofits and Government Agencies: These entities could access funding to develop and implement projects. However, the demand for rigorous evaluation and application protocols might stretch their resources, depending on the size and technological capabilities of these organizations.
Overall, the "Dairy Nutrition Incentive Program Act of 2025" presents a well-intentioned effort to leverage governmental support to improve nutritional outcomes for low-income individuals, but its effectiveness may be hampered by the outlined issues that necessitate careful consideration and potential revision.
Financial Assessment
The proposed bill, S. 1021, introduces several financial components aimed at supporting the establishment and operation of a dairy nutrition incentive program. The bill outlines specific appropriations and financial allocations, as well as mechanisms for funding the program's associated activities.
Financial Allocations
The bill mandates $10,000,000 of mandatory funding per fiscal year to be appropriated from the Treasury to support the dairy nutrition incentive program. This funding is intended to be used for the creation and administration of projects that promote the consumption of dairy products among recipients of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP).
In addition to this, there is an authorization of appropriations for an additional $10,000,000 for fiscal year 2025 and each fiscal year thereafter. These funds are intended to augment the mandatory funding to further carry out the activities of the incentive program. It is specified that only funds appropriated in advance will be available under this additional authorization.
Relating Financial References to Identified Issues
The mandatory funding of $10,000,000 per fiscal year poses an issue due to the absence of clear performance metrics or outcomes specified in the bill. Without these accountability measures, there is a potential for inefficient or wasteful use of public funds. The bill's structure lacks specific accountability mechanisms that ensure funds are being spent effectively and efficiently on projects that achieve their intended objectives.
Another issue is the financial ambiguity in the allowance for additional financial assistance under Section 31(c)(5). The provision that allows requests for funds to offset initial costs related to electronic benefits transfer technology does not have specified limits. This lack of financial constraints could lead to uncontrolled spending, raising concerns over budgetary discipline and oversight.
Lastly, the bill places substantial discretion in the hands of the Secretary regarding the evaluation and continuation of projects, which includes financial decisions. Without stringent accountability measures or consequences for noncompliance, there is a risk that projects could continue receiving funding without demonstrating efficacy, thereby potentially leading to misallocation of resources.
In conclusion, while the bill provides a clear financial framework to promote the increased consumption of dairy products through incentives, the lack of defined performance metrics and financial limits presents a significant challenge. Ensuring accountability and proper oversight in how funds are utilized will be crucial for the successful implementation of the program.
Issues
The definition of 'dairy product' in Section 31 may lead to ambiguity or exclusion of certain products that could be beneficial, as it might be too restrictive by requiring milk to be the first or second ingredient. This could limit the range of products that are eligible for incentives, impacting the diversity of dairy products available to recipients of the supplemental nutrition assistance program.
The program mandates $10,000,000 of mandatory funding per fiscal year in Section 31(f), without specifying performance metrics or outcomes. This lack of clear accountability could lead to inefficient or wasteful spending of public funds.
The criteria for scientifically valid evaluation methods in Section 31(d)(2) are not clearly defined. This may lead to inconsistent evaluation standards and affect the program's ability to measure success and impact effectively.
The administrative burden for smaller entities applying for grants or cooperative agreements in Section 31(c) might be high, potentially favoring larger organizations with more resources. This could disadvantage small entities and reduce competition and innovation.
The term 'naturally nutrient-rich dairy' in Section 31(a)(4) is not precisely defined, which may allow for a wide range of products that do not necessarily meet the intended nutritional objectives of the program.
Section 31 grants the Secretary significant discretion in the evaluation and continuation of projects without clear accountability measures or consequences for noncompliance. This could lead to projects continuing without demonstrating efficacy or proper compliance.
The report submission schedule in Section 31(e) is biennial, which may not provide timely updates on the program's progress or issues. More frequent reporting could be beneficial for ongoing oversight and adjustment of the program.
The allowance for additional financial assistance in Section 31(c)(5) lacks specified limits, which could lead to uncontrolled spending. This financial ambiguity might raise concerns over budgetary discipline and oversight.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section titled "Short title" specifies that the law can be referred to as the “Dairy Nutrition Incentive Program Act of 2025.”
2. Dairy nutrition incentive program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Dairy Nutrition Incentive Program, established by an amendment to the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008, aims to increase the purchase and consumption of nutritious dairy products by providing incentives to households receiving food assistance. The program offers grants to eligible entities, prioritizes projects that maximize direct incentives for participants, and requires independent evaluations to measure effectiveness, with $10 million allocated annually and additional funding authorized.
Money References
- “(f) Funding.— “(1) MANDATORY FUNDING.—There is appropriated to the Secretary, out of any funds in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, $10,000,000 for each fiscal year to carry out this section.
- “(2) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.— “(A) IN GENERAL.—In addition to the funds made available under paragraph (1), there is authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary to carry out this section $10,000,000 for fiscal year 2025 and each fiscal year thereafter.
31. Dairy nutrition incentive program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes a federal dairy nutrition incentive program to encourage people on the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) to buy more dairy products like milk, yogurt, and cheese by offering special point-of-sale incentives. It provides funding for eligible entities, like state governments and nonprofits, to create projects that offer these incentives and requires evaluations to determine their effectiveness, with mandatory funding of $10 million per year and additional appropriations for future years.
Money References
- MANDATORY FUNDING.—There is appropriated to the Secretary, out of any funds in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, $10,000,000 for each fiscal year to carry out this section.
- (2) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.— (A) IN GENERAL.—In addition to the funds made available under paragraph (1), there is authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary to carry out this section $10,000,000 for fiscal year 2025 and each fiscal year thereafter.