Overview
Title
To amend title 10, United States Code, to ensure that members of the Armed Forces and their families have access to the contraception they need in order to promote the health and readiness of all members of the Armed Forces, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 9865 is a plan that wants to help soldiers and their families by giving them easier access to birth control without them having to pay extra money. This will also help them learn about making good family choices and staying ready and healthy.
Summary AI
H.R. 9865 aims to amend title 10 of the United States Code to ensure that members of the Armed Forces and their families have access to contraception without cost-sharing. It seeks to eliminate financial barriers for contraception for TRICARE beneficiaries and ensure sexual assault survivors in military facilities receive necessary emergency contraception. The bill also mandates the Department of Defense to establish educational programs on family planning for service members, emphasizing informed decisions and the availability of contraceptive options. Furthermore, the legislation underscores the importance of comprehensive family planning in improving health and military readiness.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed bill, titled the "Access to Contraception for Servicemembers and Dependents Act of 2024," aims to amend existing U.S. law to enhance access to contraception for members of the Armed Forces and their families. The primary goal is to promote health and readiness by ensuring that contraception is readily available and affordable. Key provisions include eliminating cost-sharing for contraceptives under the TRICARE program, providing pregnancy prevention assistance at military medical facilities for sexual assault survivors, and developing educational programs on family planning for military personnel.
Summary of Significant Issues
A significant issue with the bill is its potential impact on TRICARE's financial sustainability. By eliminating cost-sharing for contraceptives, the program might face financial strain without a clear plan to offset the lost revenue. This concern is particularly important given that TRICARE serves a large number of military families. Additionally, the bill emphasizes FDA-approved contraceptives, which might inadvertently favor certain pharmaceutical companies, potentially limiting innovation and competition in the contraceptive market.
The bill's provisions for sexual assault survivors involve nuanced language that could lead to inconsistencies in identifying and assisting survivors, potentially raising ethical concerns. Furthermore, the bill does not comprehensively address the provision of information in languages other than English, potentially disadvantaging non-English speaking survivors.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill seeks to enhance reproductive health services for military personnel and their families, contributing to improved health outcomes and overall readiness of the Armed Forces. By eliminating cost-sharing, the bill could make contraceptives more accessible to a significant portion of the military population, particularly benefiting those who previously faced financial barriers to obtaining necessary reproductive health services.
However, there are concerns about the financial impact on the TRICARE program, which serves millions of beneficiaries. If not managed properly, the program could face budgetary constraints, potentially affecting service delivery in other areas.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Armed Forces Members and Families: This group stands to benefit from improved access to contraceptive services and family planning education. The elimination of cost-sharing for contraceptives can alleviate financial pressures and lead to better personal health management for service members and dependents.
TRICARE and Healthcare Providers: While the bill's goals might enhance service member health and readiness, healthcare administrators may face challenges in managing costs without adequate reimbursement mechanisms for the loss of cost-sharing revenue.
Pharmaceutical Companies: The requirement for the use of FDA-approved contraceptives might benefit specific pharmaceutical players already in the market. However, this focus could inadvertently stifle innovation by limiting options to existing FDA-approved products.
Sexual Assault Survivors: The bill intends to provide more robust support through military medical treatment facilities, but inconsistent implementation due to language barriers and lack of specific guidance could mitigate the intended benefits.
Policy and Legal Experts: The advocacy-oriented language and lack of empirical support for some claims might provoke legal challenges or opposition from various interest groups, impacting the bill's overall effectiveness and acceptance.
In conclusion, while the intent of the bill aligns with enhancing healthcare access and readiness, careful consideration is necessary to address financial sustainability, ensure equitable access across language barriers, and balance market competition and innovation. These considerations are crucial as lawmakers seek to better serve the health needs of the Armed Forces and their families.
Issues
The bill's provision in Section 3 to eliminate cost-sharing for contraceptives under the TRICARE program could lead to increased overall costs and financial strain on the program if there is no clear plan to compensate for the loss of revenue from cost-sharing.
Section 2 and Section 3 could unintentionally favor certain pharmaceutical companies by highlighting only FDA-approved, -granted, or -cleared contraceptives, potentially overlooking future contraceptive technologies not yet approved, and thus limiting market competition.
The language and terminology used in Section 4 and Section 1074p concerning 'sexual assault survivor' and provisions for pregnancy prevention assistance could lead to inconsistencies and potential bias in identifying and assisting survivors without clear criteria or training, raising ethical concerns.
Section 5 discusses educating members of the Armed Forces on family planning without specifying a budget or funding source, leading to potential ambiguity and challenges in ensuring uniform implementation across military departments.
The emphasis throughout the bill, particularly in Section 2, on eliminating barriers to contraceptive access could be seen as advocacy rather than neutral language, which might lead to legal challenges or opposition from groups with conflicting views on reproductive rights.
There is an ethical and legal concern in Section 4 regarding ensuring that non-English speaking survivors receive equal care, as the bill lacks clear guidelines on how information will be provided in languages other than English.
The implementation of the bill, including in Sections 2 and 5, could face challenges due to vague definitions and lack of empirical evidence supporting claims made about the benefits of contraceptive access and family planning, potentially undermining its objectives.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill establishes its short title, which is the "Access to Contraception for Servicemembers and Dependents Act of 2024".
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress has made several findings about reproductive health in the military. These findings include the growing number of women and transgender individuals serving, the significant percentage who are of reproductive age, and the importance of reproductive freedom and access to contraception for health and equality. Despite coverage improvements, gaps remain in contraceptive access for non-active duty members and dependents, alongside the increased need for family planning education and resources. Recent policy changes aim to mitigate cost barriers, but further legislative action is required for comprehensive access and coverage.
3. Contraception coverage parity under the TRICARE program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the bill, it states that under the TRICARE program, no cost-sharing will be required for prescription contraceptives, contraceptive care, sterilization procedures, or related patient education and counseling for beneficiaries. This applies to services provided through retail or mail-order pharmacies, network providers under TRICARE Select, and those under TRICARE Prime.
4. Pregnancy prevention assistance at military medical treatment facilities for sexual assault survivors Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill requires military medical treatment facilities to provide sexual assault survivors with information and assistance related to emergency contraceptives. This includes delivering clear and accurate information, maintaining confidentiality, and supplying or prescribing emergency contraception upon request.
1074p. Provision of pregnancy prevention assistance at military medical treatment facilities Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section mandates that military medical facilities provide sexual assault survivors with information about emergency contraceptives, maintain confidentiality, and supply or prescribe emergency contraception if requested. It ensures that the information given is clear and comprehensible, and defines who qualifies as a "sexual assault survivor."
5. Education on family planning for members of the Armed Forces Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill requires the Secretary of Defense to create a standard curriculum for teaching family planning to Armed Forces members. It covers topics such as making informed family planning decisions, preventing unintended pregnancies and sexually transmitted infections, understanding the importance of family planning, accessing contraceptives, patients' rights to confidentiality, and managing unique military circumstances.