Overview
Title
To establish the Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 9691 wants to make a special park to remember a man named Julius Rosenwald and the schools he helped build a long time ago, where kids of different colors could learn together. This park will have important places, and people will take care of it so everyone can learn and remember these schools.
Summary AI
H.R. 9691 aims to establish the Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park to honor Julius Rosenwald, a philanthropist who collaborated with African-American communities to build thousands of schools in the segregated South. The bill seeks to preserve representative sites, including specific schools and parts of the Sears complex in Chicago, and create a network to connect these historical sites nationally. This initiative will be organized by the National Park Service, which will administer the park, promote educational programs, and offer grants for preservation efforts.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled the "Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park Act," seeks to establish a new unit within the United States National Park System. This unit is dedicated to commemorating the life and legacy of Julius Rosenwald, a prominent philanthropist, and the impact of the Rosenwald Schools. These schools were co-developed with Booker T. Washington to provide educational opportunities for African-American children in the segregated South. The bill outlines plans to create a network that links existing Rosenwald School sites and establish a visitor center in Chicago, Illinois. Additionally, the bill details the establishment of partnerships among local, state, and federal entities for managing these historical sites and supporting educational initiatives.
Summary of Significant Issues
Financial Uncertainty
A major concern with this bill is the lack of specified funding sources or budgets for establishing and maintaining the Rosenwald Schools National Network and Historical Park. This absence could lead to financial uncertainty, potentially risking public funds and complicating effective management of the project.
Favoritism in Partnerships
The bill grants the Secretary of the Interior expansive authority to enter into cooperative agreements with various public and private entities. Without clear criteria for these partnerships, there is a risk of favoritism, which could impact equitable distribution of resources and benefits.
Vague Criteria for Site Inclusion
The criteria for adding schools or sites to the Park and Network focus on 'significance, integrity, and need for management.' These terms lack specificity, raising concerns over potentially biased decision-making regarding which sites are selected.
Lack of Timeline for Implementation
The bill does not define timelines or deadlines for crucial actions, such as establishing the Network or creating a network symbol. This could lead to delays in the implementation process, potentially affecting the act's effectiveness and accountability.
Focus on One Person's Legacy
While the bill rightly highlights Julius Rosenwald's contributions, it may disproportionately spotlight his role over others who played significant parts in African-American educational history. This focus might raise concerns about inclusivity and proper representation of all involved historical figures.
Potential Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill is poised to positively impact public understanding and appreciation of significant historical contributions to African-American education and philanthropic history. By establishing a national historical park and a corresponding network, the public can gain better access to educational resources and historical narratives that were previously less prominent.
However, the issues of funding uncertainty and potential favoritism in cooperative agreements could lead to public scrutiny and concerns over efficiency and fairness, especially regarding taxpayer resources.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Local Communities
Communities housing existing and proposed Rosenwald School sites could benefit significantly from increased tourism, educational opportunities, and federal support for preserving these heritage sites. This could contribute to local economic development and a strengthened cultural identity.
Educational Institutions
Schools and educational programs involved in this network might gain vital historical insights and resources to enhance their curriculums. A positive impact on education could result, expanding students' understanding of civil rights history and the legacy of philanthropic endeavors in education.
Government and Non-Governmental Organizations
Entities involved in entering cooperative agreements could potentially see benefits through support in collaborative projects and increased visibility. However, the potential for uneven distribution of agreements and resources might lead to rivalry or dissatisfaction among organizations not selected as partners.
In conclusion, while the bill lays down a framework for preserving an important part of cultural and educational history, addressing its significant issues could further strengthen its intended impact and benefits for stakeholders involved.
Issues
The bill does not specify a budget or funding source for establishing and maintaining the Rosenwald Schools National Network or the National Historical Park, which could lead to financial uncertainty and implications of potential mismanagement of public funds. (Sec. 2, Sec. 5)
The provisions allowing the Secretary to enter into cooperative agreements with a broad range of entities could lead to favoritism unless clear criteria are established to ensure equitable partnerships. This could impact the fair distribution of resources and benefits. (Sec. 4, Sec. 5)
The criteria for adding schools or sites to the Park and Network are vague, particularly regarding their 'significance, integrity, and need for management,' which could lead to arbitrary or biased decision-making. (Sec. 5)
The lack of a defined timeline or specific deadlines for key actions, such as establishing the Network or creating a network symbol, might cause delays in implementation and accountability issues. (Sec. 5)
There is a focus on the life and legacy of Julius Rosenwald, potentially emphasizing his contributions over others in African-American educational history, which might lead to concerns about inclusivity and representation. (Sec. 2)
The ability for the Secretary to acquire land or interests near the Park may lead to increased federal land ownership without clear guidelines or accountability measures, potentially raising public concerns over federal overreach. (Sec. 4)
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act states that the law can be referred to as the “Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park Act.”
2. Purposes Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The purposes of the Act are to establish a National Park System unit to honor Julius Rosenwald's life and legacy by recognizing his philanthropic efforts, particularly the creation of Rosenwald Schools, which promoted education for African-American children in the segregated South. The Act also aims to preserve representative Rosenwald School sites, create a headquarters and visitor center in Chicago, and connect the remaining schools through a network in the National Park Service to share their historical significance.
3. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines key terms used in the Act, including “Map” as the map titled “Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park,” “Network” as the Rosenwald Schools National Network, “Park” as the Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park, and “Secretary” as the Secretary of the Interior.
4. Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Julius Rosenwald and Rosenwald Schools National Historical Park is established as a new National Park unit, contingent upon sufficient land acquisition. The park will include key historical sites like the Sears Roebuck Complex in Chicago and the San Domingo Rosenwald School in Maryland, among others. The Secretary of the Interior will manage and preserve these areas, promote educational programs, and ensure public access, while also developing a management plan and using cooperative agreements for further site development. Additionally, the park will interpret the legacy of Julius Rosenwald’s work with Booker T. Washington to establish schools in the South.
5. Rosenwald Schools National Network Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Rosenwald Schools National Network section outlines that the Secretary of the Interior will establish a program within the National Park Service to recognize sites related to Julius Rosenwald and the Rosenwald Schools. The Secretary will manage the program, create educational materials, provide grants, conduct research, and work with various government and private entities to ensure these sites are recognized and preserved.