Overview
Title
To direct the Secretary of Defense to carry out a pilot program to provide services from midwives to covered beneficiaries under the TRICARE program.
ELI5 AI
H. R. 9335 is a plan for the U.S. military to try having midwives help with baby deliveries for families of soldiers using TRICARE health benefits, and they will see if it works well over five years. If it helps moms and families and saves money, they might keep doing it longer.
Summary AI
H. R. 9335 is a bill proposing a pilot program for the U.S. Department of Defense to offer midwife services to TRICARE beneficiaries, which includes certain military members and their families. The program would last five years, with the potential to become permanent if successful. The bill also mandates regular reports to Congress on the pilot's implementation, costs, and outcomes, such as maternal health improvements and patient satisfaction. Definitions for terms like "covered beneficiary" and "covered midwife" align with existing legal references and professional certifications.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed bill, known as the "Maternal and Infant Delivery Wellness and Integration with Vital Expertise Support for Service Members Act of 2024" or the "MIDWIVES for Service Members Act of 2024," seeks to initiate a pilot program through the U.S. Department of Defense. This program aims to provide midwife services to individuals covered by the TRICARE health care program. The pilot is slated to run for five years with a possibility of it becoming permanent based on its success. The bill outlines the need for the Secretary of Defense to periodically report on the program's implementation, cost, demographic reach, effectiveness, and potential improvements.
Summary of Significant Issues
The bill highlights multiple uncertainties and potential issues:
Lack of Success Criteria: The bill does not clearly define what constitutes the program's 'success.' This vagueness might result in subjectivity during evaluations, which could affect whether the program is made permanent.
Selection and Training of Midwives: There are no specifications about a competitive selection process for participants, nor guidelines for aligning with international standards for midwifery practice. This could result in inconsistencies in service quality.
Financial Projections: While cost savings from the program are anticipated due to improved health outcomes, there is no provided methodology for calculating these savings, raising concerns about the reliability of these projections.
Reporting and Oversight: The Secretary's reports lack clear guidelines on data collection and assessment, potentially leading to inconsistency. In addition, no independent oversight mechanisms are included, raising accountability concerns.
Effectiveness of Midwifery: The bill does not discuss the comparative effectiveness of midwifery services versus conventional medical care. This omission complicates an objective assessment of the program's potential benefits.
Potential Impact on the Public
If successful, the bill could expand access to midwifery services for those covered under TRICARE, potentially leading to improved maternal and infant health outcomes. This could, in turn, alleviate some of the burdens on traditional healthcare facilities by offering alternative birthing options. The public could benefit through reduced healthcare costs related to maternal and infant care if the program is cost-effective.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Service Members and Families: This group stands to benefit the most from increased access to midwifery services, potentially experiencing improved outcomes in maternal and infant health due to focus on personalized care.
TRICARE and Department of Defense: These entities may face operational challenges, especially in ensuring consistency and quality across different states with varying credentialing requirements for midwives. Developing standardized protocols will be necessary for implementation.
Midwives and Healthcare Providers: The bill could increase demand for certified midwives, creating opportunities for these professionals. However, it may also create workforce challenges if there is not enough qualified personnel to meet the expanded demand.
Taxpayers: The financial implications of this bill, particularly the pilot program's cost-effectiveness, could affect taxpayers. Without a clear methodology for financial calculations, projections of cost savings remain uncertain.
The bill reflects a significant opportunity to integrate midwifery services; however, addressing the highlighted issues will be crucial in ensuring the program's success and sustainability.
Issues
Section 2: The provision for making the pilot program permanent lacks clear criteria or guidelines on what determines the program's 'success.' This absence could result in subjective evaluations exacerbating accountability and transparency issues.
Section 2: There is no mention of a competitive selection process or bidding for selecting participants to carry out the pilot program. This oversight may raise concerns about favoritism or a lack of transparency in the implementation.
Section 2: The pilot program does not specify who is responsible for training or certifying 'covered midwives' to international standards, especially given varying state credentialing requirements. This might lead to inconsistencies in service quality.
Section 2: The pilot program anticipates cost savings from improved health outcomes but lacks a methodology for calculating these savings, leading to potentially unreliable financial projections.
Section 2: The reports required from the Secretary lack specific guidelines on how data should be collected and assessed, possibly leading to inconsistencies and variability in reporting standards.
Section 2: The bill does not include any oversight mechanisms or independent evaluation procedures, which could lead to accountability issues concerning the program’s implementation and effectiveness.
Section 2: The effectiveness of midwifery in comparison to conventional medical care is not discussed, hindering the assessment of the program's potential impacts or necessity.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The act is officially named the "Maternal and Infant Delivery Wellness and Integration with Vital Expertise Support for Service Members Act of 2024," and it can also be called the "MIDWIVES for Service Members Act of 2024."
2. Pilot program to make midwife services available through TRICARE Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill proposes a pilot program that will last five years to offer midwife services to eligible people under the TRICARE program, with the option to make it permanent if successful. It requires the Secretary of Defense to report on various aspects of the program, including costs, participant demographics, and program effectiveness, and provides a specific definition for "covered midwife".