Overview
Title
To establish a clear and consistent biological definition of male and female.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 9218 is a bill that wants to make clear rules about what it means to be male or female, saying there are only two types based on how a person is born, and it doesn't think that someone choosing their own gender counts in this definition.
Summary AI
H.R. 9218, titled the “Defining Male and Female Act of 2024,” seeks to establish a clear and consistent legal definition of the terms male and female, along with related terminology. The bill asserts that there are only two sexes, male and female, defined biologically and observable at or before birth. It also clarifies that gender and sex are distinct concepts, with gender identity not being equivalent to sex. Additionally, the bill provides definitions for terms such as woman, man, girl, boy, mother, and father, aiming to prevent misunderstandings and reinforce the traditional meanings of these terms.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill, titled the "Defining Male and Female Act of 2024," seeks to implement a clear and consistent biological definition of the terms "male" and "female." It asserts that these are the only two sexes, defined by specific reproductive functions—sperm production for males and egg production for females. It further outlines that these definitions are to be adhered to in interpreting any acts of Congress or regulations by federal agencies. The bill excludes concepts such as gender identity from these definitions, emphasizing that sex is biologically determined and not a matter of self-identification.
Summary of Significant Issues
One key issue with the bill is its strict binary definition of sex, which does not account for intersex individuals who may not fit neatly into the categories of "male" or "female." Additionally, the exclusion of "gender identity" from the definition of "sex" could conflict with existing anti-discrimination laws that protect gender identity. The language in the bill might also provoke public debate given its resistance to evolving understandings of gender. Furthermore, by defining sex based on reproductive potential, it may marginalize individuals who don't meet these criteria due to medical conditions or personal circumstances.
Impact on the Public Broadly
Broadly, the bill could lead to widespread implications for how legal definitions of sex are applied in various contexts, including healthcare, education, and employment. By emphasizing a strict binary understanding of sex, the bill may impact access to services or protections for those who identify outside this binary, such as non-binary or transgender individuals. Its adoption could also influence societal perceptions and conversations around sex and gender, potentially heightening debates and leading to legal challenges from advocacy groups.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For individuals who identify as transgender or non-binary, the proposed definitions may result in reduced legal recognition and protection, as the bill moves away from acknowledging gender identity as a separate concept from biological sex. This could affect their experiences in environments such as workplaces or schools, where gender identity inclusion is a priority.
Conversely, proponents who advocate for a return to traditional biological understandings may view this as a positive development, arguing that it brings clarity and consistency to legal definitions of sex. However, healthcare providers and educators might face challenges in adapting to definitions that do not align with current medical and social understanding, leading to potential conflicts in policy implementation.
Overall, this legislation could significantly shape public and legal discourse on gender and sex, affecting a wide range of individuals and institutions across the nation.
Issues
The bill's strict binary definition of sex as male or female, without considering intersex individuals or acknowledging the complexity of gender identity, could conflict with current scientific understanding and social perspectives, leading to potential legal challenges. This issue is particularly significant in Sections 2 and 3.
The exclusion of 'gender identity' from the definitions of 'sex' and 'gender' may not align with existing anti-discrimination policies regarding gender identity at federal and state levels, potentially leading to inconsistencies in legal protections. This is a major issue in Section 3.
The language used to reaffirm the 'longstanding meaning and understanding of sex' implies a resistance to contemporary understandings of gender and sex, potentially fueling public debate and controversy, especially given the lack of specific scientific or legal precedents cited in Section 2.
The bill's language suggesting that sex is 'not determined by stipulation or self-identification' conflicts with current practices and understandings within many medical and social fields, which could lead to misunderstanding or non-compliance. This is emphasized in Section 2.
By defining 'male' and 'female' based on potential reproductive functions, the bill might exclude individuals who do not or cannot fit these biological roles, creating ethical concerns around inclusivity and representation, as seen in Section 3.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this bill states that it may be called the “Defining Male and Female Act of 2024.”
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress states that there are only two biological sexes, male and female, determined by physical characteristics, which are observable even before birth. It highlights the confusion arising from terms like gender identity and expression and asserts the importance of reaffirming the traditional understanding of sex to ensure legal clarity and equal treatment.
3. Definition of sex, male, female, and related terms Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the United States Code to define terms related to "sex," with "male" and "female" being biologically determined categories. It clarifies that "gender" relates to natural differences between males and females and does not include concepts like gender identity or gender expression.
9. Definition of sex, male, female, and related terms Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines terms like "sex", "male", and "female" based on biological characteristics, specifies definitions for "man", "woman", "boy", and "girl" as human males and females at different ages, and clarifies "mother" and "father" as female and male parents, respectively. It also distinguishes "gender" as referring to biological differences or as a synonym for sex, and explicitly states that "gender identity" is not the same as "sex" or "gender".