Overview
Title
To amend titles 11 and 28 of the United States Code to modify the compensation payable to trustees serving in cases under chapter 7 of such title; to extend the term of certain temporary offices of bankruptcy judge, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024 wants to give more money to people who help with money problems in courts, called trustees, because they haven't had a raise in a long time, and it also plans to let certain special judges work longer to help with the growing number of cases.
Summary AI
The Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024 aims to update compensation for Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees, who have not seen an increase since 1994. The bill proposes increasing their pay per case from $60 to $120, adjusted for inflation, without altering existing filing fees. It also seeks to extend the term of some temporary bankruptcy judgeships from 5 to 10 years to manage rising caseloads more effectively. The changes would impact compensation and fees related to bankruptcy cases, ensuring the system remains self-supporting and fair to users.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The bill titled "Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024" seeks to amend titles 11 and 28 of the United States Code. Primarily, it proposes adjusting the compensation for trustees in chapter 7 bankruptcy cases and extending the term for certain temporary bankruptcy judge positions. Specifically, it suggests increasing trustee compensation from $60 to $120 per case and holding this figure to inflation. Additionally, the bill proposes a method for reallocating remaining fees across various funds and extends certain judicial terms from 5 to 10 years.
Significant Issues
Several issues arise from the proposed changes, notably the increase in trustee compensation without a detailed justification or impact analysis on statutory increases in spending. The extension of judicial terms also lacks sufficient explanation, creating concerns over prolonged expenditures and potential inefficiencies.
The reallocation of fees among funds might also indicate prioritization without public clarity, raising concerns about equitable and fair distribution. Furthermore, the removal of specific subsections without sufficient explanation potentially risks removing essential oversight, leading to transparency issues.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, the bill aims to improve the bankruptcy process's efficiency and effectiveness, potentially allowing cases to be handled more smoothly by compensating trustees adequately. However, since these changes might lead to increased spending, they could indirectly affect how taxpayer resources are allocated.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees, the bill represents a positive change as it increases their compensation, which hasn't been revised since 1994, realistically aligning with inflation and continued increases in responsibilities.
However, for funding bodies and fiscal agents, the lack of clarity in how funds are allocated might demand more scrutiny and could lead to questions about budgetary priorities and fairness in financial distributions.
Judicial systems could benefit from extended judge terms by providing continuity and stability within the temporary judicial roles. However, the effect on efficiency and overall system functionality remains subject to debate due to the sweeping nature of the extensions without detailed impact studies.
Overall, the bill introduces changes that might streamline bankruptcy practices but also requires careful consideration of financial impacts, equitable resource distribution, and transparency to ensure the adjustments serve the public's best interest without leading to unnecessary government expenditures.
Financial Assessment
The Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024 introduces several key financial changes concerning the compensation of Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees and the allocation of fees. These financial adjustments aim to address longstanding compensation issues and ensure the efficient operation of the bankruptcy system, but they may also raise questions about transparency and efficiency.
Trustee Compensation
The bill proposes an increase in the compensation for Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees from $60 to $120 per case. This adjustment aims to update the trustee fees, which have remained unchanged since 1994, despite increases in related costs such as salaries and attorney fees. While the bill asserts that this raise is both appropriate and overdue, it could raise issues regarding how the new compensation level was determined. Critics may question the methodology that nominated $120 as the new standard, potentially considering it excessive without a detailed breakdown justifying the amount.
Fee Distribution
In addition to trustee compensation, the bill addresses the distribution of fees collected under section 1930(a)(1)(A) of title 28, United States Code. After compensating trustees, the remaining fees are designated for various funds: $63.51 goes to the Special Fund under section 1931, $25 to another Special Fund according to Public Law 109-171, and $51.49 to the United States Trustee Fund. These allocations are intended to ensure adequate funding for the bankruptcy system. However, the lack of explicit reasoning for this specific distribution could lead to concerns about whether resources are being distributed fairly and transparently, or if there is unexplained prioritization at play.
Temporary Judges and Fee Extensions
The extension of the term for certain temporary bankruptcy judgeships from 5 to 10 years aims to cope with increasing caseloads. This change does not directly involve spending but may lead to sustained financial obligations over a longer term. Observers might question whether extending the terms is the most cost-effective method to handle increased demand, potentially perceiving it as an unnecessary prolongation of expenditures without clear justification.
The bill also involves adjustments in bankruptcy fee structures, particularly around quarterly fees in Chapter 11 cases. The detailed implications of these fee changes are not provided, which could contribute to a perception of an opaque financial structure. For those tracking public funds, such ambiguity can result in doubts regarding unforeseen costs and the general public's understanding of these financial operations.
Conclusion
Overall, the financial references in the Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024 strive to update and streamline bankruptcy-related compensation and fees. However, the proposed financial adjustments and allocations may lead to further scrutiny regarding their transparency and justification. Whether these adjustments will effectively balance the needs of bankruptcy system users with fiscal responsibility remains an open question.
Issues
The increase in compensation for chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees from $60 to $120 per case (Section 2) may raise concerns about increased spending and lack of justification for how this amount was determined, which might lead to questions about transparency and the potential for unnecessary or excessive government expenditure.
The extension of the term for temporary bankruptcy judges from 5 years to 10 years (Section 5) could result in unnecessary prolonged spending without clear justification, raising potential concerns about the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of this legislative change.
The changes to the allocation of fees among various funds (Section 3) lack detailed reasoning, potentially suggesting favoritism or unexplained prioritization, which might lead to doubts about the fair distribution of resources and the legislative intent behind these changes.
The lack of clarity in the amendment changes regarding bankruptcy fees (Section 4) and the extension of timelines without explanation could create an opaque financial structure, possibly resulting in unforeseen costs and lack of public understanding.
The elimination of subsection (e) in Section 3 without explanation could lead to concerns about the removal of important provisions or oversight and may diminish transparency in the legislative process.
The adjustment of compensation with the claim that it is 'appropriate, overdue, and proportionate' (Section 2) is somewhat subjective, lacking concrete criteria for determining these terms, which could lead to questions about the objectivity and fairness of the compensation changes.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill gives the law its name: the “Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2024.”
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress outlines the need for the bankruptcy system to be self-sustained and fairly share its costs among users, highlighting chapter 7 trustees' essential roles. Due to inflation and stagnant pay since 1994, compensation for these trustees will be increased from $60 to $120 per case, adjusting for inflation, while existing judicial positions are preserved.
Money References
- (6) Due to the work of the chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees, millions of dollars are also disbursed annually to private creditors of all types including medical providers, unsecured creditors, small businesses, and micro-enterprises such as domestic support providers.
- As in 1994, bankruptcy trustees receive only $60 per case (composed of $45 from subsection 330(b)(1), and $15 from subsection 330(b)(2), of title 11 of the United States Code) in nearly ninety percent of chapter 7 cases, and they receive no compensation at all for cases in which the filing fee is waived by the Bankruptcy Court.
- In contrast, the $60 paid to chapter 7 trustees has remained the same and has not even been increased for inflation.
- Based on CPI estimates, the $60 of in 1994 would be the equivalent of over $125 today.
- (9) This Act and the amendments made by this Act— (A) increase the compensation of chapter 7 bankruptcy trustees to the level that is appropriate, overdue, and proportionate with the level that was intended in 1994, by increasing their total compensation to $120 per case and ensuring that the amount is indexed for inflation; (B) ensure adequate funding of the United States trustee system; and (C) support the preservation of existing bankruptcy judgeships that are urgently needed to handle existing and anticipated increases in business and consumer caseloads.
3. Trustee compensation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines changes to trustee compensation by increasing the pay rate from $45 to $105 and altering how remaining fees are distributed to various funds, including the Special Fund, a fund established by Public Law 109–171, and the United States Trustee Fund. Additionally, some subsections in relevant U.S. Code are revised, such as removing and redesignating certain subparagraphs.
Money References
- (a) Compensation of officers.—Section 330 of title 11, United States Code, is amended— (1) in subsection (b)(1) by striking “$45” and inserting “$105”, and (2) by striking subsection (e). (b) Remainder of fees.—Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the remainder of fees collected under section 1930(a)(1)(A) of title 28, United States Code, after compensating trustees under section 330(b)(1) of title 11, United States Code, shall be deposited as follows: (1) $63.51 in the Special Fund established under section 1931 of title 28, United States Code, (2) $25 in the Special Fund established in accordance with section 10101(b) of Public Law 109–171, and (3) $51.49 in the United States Trustee Fund established under Section 589a of title 28, United States Code.
4. Bankruptcy fees Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Section 4 of the bill modifies certain provisions related to bankruptcy fees in the United States Code. It extends the period in one clause from 5 years to 10 years and adjusts a numerical reference from 0.8 to 1.1, while also changing certain references to the year 2031 instead of 2026.
5. Extension of term of certain temporary offices of bankruptcy judge Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill section proposes to extend the duration of certain temporary bankruptcy judge positions from 5 years to 10 years, amending previous laws such as the Bankruptcy Administration Improvement Act of 2020 and the Bankruptcy Judgeship Act of 2017 to reflect this change.
6. Effective date; application of amendments Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The discussed section outlines when the changes made by the Act will start taking effect, which is generally on October 1 following the Act's enactment. There are specific rules for cases involving officer compensation and bankruptcy fees that detail when these amendments apply based on the type of bankruptcy case and specific fee conditions.