Overview
Title
To promote the development of renewable energy on public land, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to use land owned by everyone, like big parks, to make clean energy from the sun, wind, and hot rocks underground. It plans how to choose the best spots, share money made from the projects, and work with different groups to make sure everything is done right and fairly.
Summary AI
The bill, H. R. 9012, aims to promote the development of renewable energy, such as solar, wind, and geothermal, on public lands in the United States. It sets out a framework for identifying priority areas for energy projects, updating land use plans, and establishing economic incentives. The bill outlines a distribution of revenues generated from these projects to states, counties, and a Renewable Energy Resource Conservation Fund to support conservation efforts and improve public access. Additionally, it mandates the coordination with state, tribal, and other agencies to ensure sustainable and efficient development of renewable energy.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed bill, titled the "Public Land Renewable Energy Development Act of 2024," aims to enhance the development of renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and geothermal power on public lands in the United States. It outlines definitions relevant to the renewable energy sector and updates national energy production goals on federal lands. The bill also touches upon environmental impact assessments, revenue distribution, economic regulations, and permitting processes. Introduced by Mr. Levin, the bill was referred to the Committees on Natural Resources and Agriculture.
Summary of Significant Issues
The bill introduces ambitious targets for renewable energy development, raising concerns about their feasibility and the absence of a supporting rationale or analysis. Moreover, it delegates significant authority to the Secretary of the Interior, which might lead to subjective applications and potential bias in identifying priority areas for energy projects. The delegation of permitting processes to state offices risks inconsistency across states, potentially leading to unequal project approval standards. The economic guidelines set forth for rental rates and capacity fees could lead to disparities and inconsistencies. Lastly, the structured revenue distribution percentages may prove inflexible over time, potentially impacting the adaptability of financial planning for states and counties.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill could significantly increase renewable energy development on public lands, potentially aiding in reducing carbon footprints and contributing to cleaner air and environmental sustainability. Increased access to renewable energy could offer consumers more diverse energy sources, promoting competition and possibly lowering energy costs over time. However, the bill's ambitious targets and the lack of clear frameworks could lead to implementation challenges, causing delays that might affect public perception and reliance on renewable energy advancements.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Government Agencies: The bill places substantial responsibility on federal and state agencies, particularly the Secretary of the Interior, potentially affecting how these bodies coordinate and carry out renewable energy projects. The agencies might face challenges in ensuring projects comply with new standards and benefit from revenue distribution while balancing environmental concerns.
Energy Developers: Renewable energy developers stand to benefit from expanded opportunities on public lands and potential incentives for projects in priority areas. However, they might face uncertainty in rental rate assessments and permitting processes, especially given the decentralization to state offices, which could introduce variability.
States and Local Governments: States and counties will receive a share of revenue from these projects, potentially enhancing local economies and funding renewable energy initiatives. Yet, the rigid allocation percentages might limit their ability to adapt to changing financial circumstances, affecting long-term budget planning and fiscal stability.
Environmental and Tribal Organizations: These stakeholders might benefit from project impact mitigation efforts funded through the Renewable Energy Resource Conservation Fund, aiding local environmental protection causes. Nonetheless, the adequacy of these efforts will depend on the bill's implementation and ongoing environmental oversight.
In summary, while the bill aims to fortify the country's renewable energy landscape using public lands, its success hinges on the implementation of its provisions and effective coordination among federal, state, and local agencies.
Issues
Section 3: The bill proposes a significant increase in renewable energy goals on Federal land from '25' to '60' by the deadline shift from '2025' to 'December 31, 2030', yet fails to provide a rationale, feasibility analysis, or potential funding required to meet these ambitious targets, raising concerns about the practicality and strategic foresight of such changes.
Section 4: The broad discretionary powers granted to the Secretary in designating priority areas for renewable energy projects may lead to subjective interpretations, potential bias, or favoritism in renewable energy planning and land use decisions, requiring more specific guidelines to ensure fairness and transparency.
Section 5: The delegation of permitting authority to State Renewable Energy Coordination Offices might result in inconsistent processing standards across states, potentially leading to disparities in project approvals and posing challenges to uniform federal oversight of renewable energy developments.
Section 6: The economic terms regarding rental rates and fees depend on averages from the Pastureland Rents Survey and Implicit Price Deflator-Gross Product Index, potentially leading to income disparities due to variances in regional market data, along with unclear capacity fees that may lead to inconsistencies in fee assessments.
Section 7: The rigid allocation percentages for distributing revenues may constrain flexibility in addressing evolving financial needs and market conditions over the two-decade implementation period, potentially impacting state and county budgets and priorities.
Section 4 & Section 5: The bill mentions the need for updating environmental impact statements and offers incentives for projects in priority areas but lacks specific details and timelines for these updates, potentially delaying renewable energy project implementations and affecting environmental and community readiness.
Section 8: The lack of defined oversight mechanisms or clear jurisdictional boundaries for the Secretary’s responsibilities could lead to ambiguities in land management, affecting the efficacy of enforcing multiple use and sustained yield principles.
Section 6: The process for establishing bond requirements for decommissioning lacks clarity on maintaining updated net cost estimates and salvage values, possibly leading to financial shortfalls in decommissioning and reclamation efforts.
Section 7: The exclusion of filing fees from the general revenue disposition framework could result in financial imbalances, with agencies benefiting from cost recovery despite the potential impacts on broader revenue distribution and equitable resource allocation.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that the law is called the “Public Land Renewable Energy Development Act of 2024.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section defines terms used in the bill related to renewable energy, including what qualifies as "covered land," an "energy storage project," and "renewable energy project." It clarifies types of "Federal land," "public land," and areas identified as "priority" for energy projects, and identifies the "Secretary of the Interior" as the key authority figure.
3. Updating national goals for renewable energy production on Federal land Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section updates national goals for renewable energy production on Federal land by increasing the target from 25 to 60 and extending the deadline to December 31, 2030. It also requires the Secretary of the Interior, along with other federal officials, to revise these goals within 18 months of this amendment's enactment.
4. Land use planning and updates to programmatic environmental impact statements Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines land use planning for renewable energy projects, requiring the Secretary to designate priority areas on public lands while ensuring compliance with multiple use principles and national renewable energy goals. It emphasizes periodic review and updates of priority and exclusion areas, mandates coordination with relevant stakeholders, ensures compliance with environmental laws, and allows incentives for developing renewable energy in designated areas.
5. Improving wind and solar energy project permitting Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill section proposes changes to improve the permitting process for wind and solar energy projects, including allowing state offices to process applications, setting guidelines for cost recovery agreements, and addressing environmental requirements. It prioritizes projects in designated areas and details when competitive processes should be used if multiple applications are submitted for the same site.
6. Increasing economic certainty Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines how rental rates and fees for renewable energy project leases should be determined, mandating they do not exceed rates on private land in the same area and allowing the use of average cash rents from official surveys. It also describes guidelines for setting up bond requirements for decommissioning such projects, emphasizing site-specific costs minus salvage value without a minimum per acre amount.
7. Disposition of revenues; Renewable Energy Resource Conservation Fund Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes how revenues from wind and solar energy projects on federal land will be divided among states, counties, and a special fund for renewable energy projects from 2025 to beyond 2045. It also establishes the Renewable Energy Resource Conservation Fund to support environmental and recreational improvements in regions affected by these projects, and outlines the fund's investment, usage, and reporting processes.
8. Savings clause Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The savings clause ensures that even with this Act, the Secretary and the Secretary of Agriculture will continue to manage public lands according to established laws, following principles like multiple use and sustained yield, for planning land use, processing permits, and carrying out environmental reviews.