Overview
Title
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide for S corporation reform, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The H.R. 8619 bill is about changing some rules for a special type of company called an S corporation, so they can do things like have more types of people as owners and make more money in different ways without getting extra penalties. It's like updating the rules for a game to make it fairer and more fun for everyone playing.
Summary AI
The H.R. 8619 bill aims to reform how S corporations are taxed and operates under the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. It includes provisions for handling gains when a shareholder dies, allows nonresident aliens and IRAs to be shareholders, and increases the amount of passive income S corporations can receive without penalty. The bill also repeals taxes on some deferred compensation plans and simplifies the rules for transferring suspended losses when a shareholder dies.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed legislative bill, referred to as the "S Corporation Modernization Act of 2024," aims to revise existing rules under the Internal Revenue Code for S corporations. These businesses, often structured for tax efficiency, would face new guidelines concerning built-in gains, shareholder eligibility, and income rules.
General Summary
S corporations are subject to specific tax regulations, and this bill seeks to modify how these entities function in several important ways. Key changes include updating how built-in gains are treated when a shareholder dies, altering the criteria for passive investment income, allowing nonresident aliens to hold shares in S corporations, and expanding shareholder eligibility to include Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs). Additionally, the bill removes the requirement to include certain deferred compensations in gross income.
Significant Issues
Several substantial issues have been raised regarding the bill. First, increasing the limit for passive investment income from 25% to 60% (Section 3) could encourage tax avoidance, benefiting companies that rely on passive income like interest and dividends. Next, allowing nonresident aliens to be shareholders (Section 4) introduces complexity, possibly leading to misuse and compliance challenges. Another issue is the potentially favorable treatment of built-in gains upon a shareholder's death (Section 2), which could advantage those with sophisticated financial planning. Furthermore, the inclusion of IRAs as shareholders (Section 6) creates new financial dynamics that could affect tax revenues. Last, repealing rules concerning deferred compensation (Section 8) might change how these compensations are managed tax-wise, leading to exploitation without adequate analysis of the repercussions.
Impact on the Public
The bill could have broad impacts on the general public, mainly through its potential influence on tax revenues and economic activities of small and medium-sized businesses. If these changes promote the growth and expansion of S corporations, there might be positive effects, such as increased job creation and economic activity. Conversely, the changes could reduce tax revenues if tax avoidance strategies become prevalent, possibly shifting more tax burden onto individuals and other business types.
Impact on Stakeholders
The bill could benefit stakeholders within the S corporation framework, primarily shareholders and corporate managers, by providing more flexible and beneficial tax arrangements. However, these benefits are likely more accessible to larger and more financially sophisticated entities, potentially disadvantaging smaller businesses or those without access to top-tier tax advice.
Financial institutions and investment firms might find new opportunities with the inclusion of IRAs as shareholders, but this could also complicate the retirement savings landscape if unintended tax advantages arise. Additionally, the potential for enhanced tax strategies might lead to regulatory scrutiny and increased compliance costs for these businesses.
In conclusion, the bill presents a mix of modernization and complexity. The potential for abuse and inequities may necessitate careful monitoring and adjustments to ensure its fair application and to safeguard public interest.
Issues
The bill's amendment that increases the passive investment income limit for S corporations from 25% to 60% (Section 3) could disproportionately benefit certain corporations that mainly rely on passive income, potentially encouraging tax avoidance strategies and leading to misuse of S corporation status.
The repeal of inclusion in gross income of deferred compensation under nonqualified deferred compensation plans (Section 8) might pose financial impacts due to its potential to alter existing compensation structures, leading to possible exploitation of tax benefits without proper analysis of consequences.
The allowance of nonresident alien individuals as S corporation shareholders (Section 4) introduces complex legal and tax implications that may lead to compliance issues and tax strategy manipulation, raising ethical and financial concerns.
The treatment of S corporation built-in gain amount upon death of shareholder (Section 2 and 1369) involves complex financial and legal terms, which might unfairly favor those with sophisticated financial strategies, thereby increasing tax strategy exploitation among wealthy individuals.
The expansion of S corporation eligible shareholders to include IRAs (Section 6) raises financial implications that are not fully explored, potentially allowing for financial strategies that could lead to loss of tax revenue or tax advantages being exploited.
The language across several sections (such as Section 2, 1369, and 4) is overly technical, making it challenging for stakeholders without tax expertise to fully understand the changes, possibly leading to misinterpretation and legal ambiguities.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title; reference Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section gives the official name "S Corporation Modernization Act of 2024" to the Act and states that any changes or removals mentioned in the Act are to be related to sections of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, unless specifically stated otherwise.
2. Treatment of S corporation built-in gain amount upon death of shareholder Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines how S corporations manage built-in gains after a shareholder's death. It allows shareholders to deduct these gains over 15 years, with special rules for deducting gains from selling different types of property, and includes conditions for stock transfers and reporting requirements.
1369. Treatment of S corporation built-in gain amount upon death of shareholder Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes how to handle certain tax deductions for shareholders of S corporations when the shareholder passes away. It allows deductions based on the built-in gain of the corporation's stock, which can be spread over 15 years or adjusted if the corporation's property is sold, while also detailing rules for different types of property, transfers of stock, and calculations involving gains and deductions.
3. Modifications to S corporation passive investment income rules Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill modifies S corporation rules by increasing the passive investment income limit from 25% to 60% and eliminating termination for excessive passive income. It also amends definitions and exceptions related to passive income and sets these changes to start for tax years after December 31, 2023.
4. Nonresident alien individuals permitted as S corporation shareholders Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section allows nonresident aliens to own shares in S corporations and outlines how gains or losses from selling this stock are taxed as if they are connected to the corporation's U.S. business activities. Additionally, it requires these corporations to withhold taxes on income connected to such business activities when owned by nonresident aliens and sets rules for disposing of S corporation stock, starting from January 1, 2024.
1447. Withholding tax on nonresident alien S corporation shareholder’s pro rata share of effectively connected income Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that an S corporation with taxable income connected to U.S. business activities must pay a withholding tax if it has a nonresident alien as a shareholder. It explains how the tax amount is calculated, the allowance of a tax credit for nonresident alien shareholders, and special rules for stock dispositions, while authorizing the Secretary to establish regulations for implementing these provisions.
5. Employees of a firm counted as a single shareholder toward shareholder limit of S corporation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section proposes changes to the rules for S corporations, allowing all employees of a corporation and its wholly owned businesses to be counted as a single shareholder. It also permits nonresident aliens to be shareholders if they are connected to an employee, and introduces regulations for withholding taxes on their income, effective for tax years starting after December 31, 2023.
6. Expansion of S corporation eligible shareholders to include IRAs Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress is expanding who can own shares in an S corporation by allowing Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), including Roth IRAs, to be shareholders, and from January 1, 2024, the sale of these stocks by IRAs related to S corporation elections will not violate prohibited transaction rules.
7. Transfer of suspended losses incident to death Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the law to allow losses that were not deducted before a person’s death to be transferred to their beneficiaries. This change applies to cases where the death occurs after the law is enacted.
8. Repeal of inclusion in gross income of deferred compensation under nonqualified deferred compensation plans Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section removes the obligation to include deferred compensation from nonqualified deferred compensation plans in gross income by eliminating section 409A and making various adjustments to related tax code sections. These changes will be applicable to taxable years starting after December 31, 2023.