Overview
Title
To amend the Federal Crop Insurance Act to require the Federal Crop Insurance Corporation to carry out research and development regarding a policy to insure table, wine and juice grapes against losses due to a freeze event, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The GRAPE Act is a plan to help protect grapes used for eating, making wine, and juice from getting damaged by cold weather. It tells a group to figure out how to make an insurance that helps grape farmers if their crops freeze, like a warm blanket for the grapes when it gets too cold.
Summary AI
H.R. 8359, known as the “Grape Research And Protection Expansion Act” or the “GRAPE Act,” is a proposed amendment to the Federal Crop Insurance Act. It mandates that the Federal Crop Insurance Corporation research and develop an insurance policy to protect table, wine, and juice grapes from losses caused by freeze events. The policy must be developed within one year of the Act's enactment and made available within 18 months, if certain conditions are met. Additionally, a report on the research and the policies developed is due to specific Congressional committees within two years.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Overview of the Legislation
The bill, introduced as H.R. 8359 in the House of Representatives on May 10, 2024, seeks to amend the Federal Crop Insurance Act. The primary goal of this amendment is to ensure that table, wine, and juice grapes are protected against losses resulting from freeze events. It mandates the Federal Crop Insurance Corporation (FCIC) to engage in research and develop an insurance policy specifically tailored for grape growers. The bill also outlines a timeline: the insurance policy must be available within 18 months, and a comprehensive report on the research and implemented policies is to be submitted to congressional committees within two years.
Significant Issues
One of the main issues with the bill is the lack of detailed criteria for selecting "qualified persons" to conduct the necessary research and development. This absence of specificity could lead to perceptions of favoritism or bias in choosing who will take part in this significant initiative. Furthermore, while the bill mandates the delivery of a report summarizing the research outcomes and policies, it does not specify metrics or criteria to evaluate the policies' success or effectiveness, potentially allowing ineffective measures to persist.
Moreover, there is concern about the potential for wasteful spending. Without adequate oversight of the funding used for research and development or insurance contracts, taxpayer money may not be optimally utilized. This is particularly sensitive given the political nature of agricultural subsidies and insurance.
The short title of the act, titled the “Grape Research And Protection Expansion Act” or the “GRAPE Act,” while concise, lacks detailed information about the act's broader implications. Such vagueness may hinder the understanding of stakeholders about the legislation's full purpose and its potential impacts.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
The broader public might view this bill favorably as it aims to shield grape producers from economic hardships caused by freeze events. Given the agricultural industry’s susceptibility to unpredictable weather, such insurance policies could provide financial stability to grape growers, potentially affecting prices and availability of grape products in the market, which can benefit consumers.
For grape producers, the legislation offers a potential safety net, ensuring that freeze damage does not spell financial ruin. This benefit, however, hinges on the efficacy and availability of the insurance policy developed. If these policies are well-designed and timely implemented, they could significantly bolster the financial security of grape producers.
On the flip side, without clear mechanisms for evaluating policies' success, grape producers might end up with inadequate coverage, which would fail to alleviate their concerns about freeze-related losses. Additionally, if favoritism in the selection process for research and development is perceived, it might lead to mistrust among stakeholders, potentially disadvantaging smaller or less connected agricultural entities.
In summary, while the bill has the potential to provide considerable benefits by protecting grape growers from weather-related losses, it is crucial that the issues of transparency, effectiveness criteria, and oversight are adequately addressed to ensure its success and equitable implementation.
Issues
The lack of detailed criteria in Section 2 for selecting 'qualified persons' to conduct research and development could lead to potential favoritism or biased selection processes. This issue may concern the general public as it could result in unfair advantages to certain entities and not others.
Section 2 mandates a report on the effectiveness of the policies developed for insuring grapes against freeze events, but it does not specify clear measures or criteria for evaluating their success. This lack of evaluation criteria might result in ineffective policies that fail to adequately protect grape producers.
The short title in Section 1 does not provide specific information about the act's contents or implications, potentially making it difficult for stakeholders to understand the purpose and impact of the legislation.
There is a potential concern in Section 2 regarding whether the funding for research and development or insurance contracts could lead to wasteful spending if not properly overseen, as it involves taxpayer money and could be politically sensitive.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The act mentioned in this section is called the Grape Research And Protection Expansion Act, which can also be referred to as the GRAPE Act.
2. Policy to insure table, wine, and juice grapes against losses due to a freeze event Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the Federal Crop Insurance Act to require research and development of an insurance policy for table, wine, and juice grapes against losses from freeze events. It mandates that a policy be made available within 18 months, and a report on the research findings and available policies be submitted to congressional committees within two years.