Overview
Title
To establish the Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site in the State of Florida, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 8012 is about giving a special award to a baseball park in Florida where Jackie Robinson, a famous baseball player, once played. This means people can learn more about his story there, but the park won't be run by the people who take care of national parks.
Summary AI
H.R. 8012 aims to designate Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, as the Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site. The bill connects this site to the African American Civil Rights Network, enhancing its educational and historical significance. While the site will not become part of the National Park System, the Secretary of the Interior is permitted to form partnerships for educational initiatives. Additionally, a study will be conducted to assess the site's importance and explore options for its preservation and management.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled the "Jackie Robinson Commemorative Site Act" (H.R. 8012), seeks to honor the legacy of Jackie Robinson by designating the Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, as a National Commemorative Site. This move aims to celebrate Robinson's impact on civil rights and baseball history. Notably, the bill integrates the site into the African American Civil Rights Network, illustrating its significance in the broader narrative of American civil rights. The bill also outlines that the Secretary of the Interior may form cooperative agreements for educational purposes regarding the site, and mandates a special resource study to evaluate the site's national significance and its potential inclusion in the National Park System.
Summary of Significant Issues
One of the significant issues with this legislation is the ambiguity around the designation of the Jackie Robinson Ballpark as a National Commemorative Site but not as a unit of the National Park System. This distinction might create confusion regarding the level of protection and management the site would receive. Additionally, the bill does not specify a budget or financial outline for the cooperative agreements or the special resource study, raising concerns about financial transparency and potential resource misallocation.
The bill uses vague language when referencing "appropriate public or private entities" eligible for cooperative agreements, which could lead to favoritism or misuse. Furthermore, while the bill prohibits land acquisition through condemnation, it lacks detailed preservation requirements, potentially limiting effective conservation efforts.
Another important issue is the lack of public involvement in the special resource study, which might lead to transparency concerns and limit stakeholder engagement.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, this bill can positively impact public awareness and education regarding civil rights and Jackie Robinson's legacy. Establishing the Jackie Robinson Ballpark as a commemorative site would highlight its historical importance, potentially boosting tourism and local economy in Daytona Beach. However, the ambiguity surrounding its status relative to the National Park System might limit the protections and resources allocated to it, affecting long-term preservation and educational initiatives.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For local communities, the bill could provide a sense of pride and historical acknowledgment, possibly leading to increased community engagement and tourism-related economic benefits. Education institutions and civil rights organizations might benefit from the proposed cooperative agreements by expanding educational outreach and public programming.
On the other hand, stakeholders invested in civil rights preservation might view the bill's lack of specificity in evaluating alternatives for site management as a missed opportunity to ensure comprehensive preservation strategies. Additionally, potential partners for cooperative agreements might face uncertainties due to vague criteria for eligibility, possibly leading to inconsistencies in partnership formation.
In conclusion, while the "Jackie Robinson Commemorative Site Act" aims to significantly recognize an important historical figure and site, several unresolved issues may impact its effectiveness. Addressing these concerns could enhance the bill’s potential to educate and inspire future generations concerning civil rights history and Jackie Robinson's enduring legacy.
Issues
The designation of the Jackie Robinson Ballpark as a National Commemorative Site but not a unit of the National Park System (Section 2.(b) and 2.(d)(2)) might create ambiguity or confusion about its level of protection and management, which could have implications for preservation standards and resource allocation.
There is no specific budget or financial allocation mentioned for the cooperative agreements or special resource study (Section 2.(d)(1) and 2.(e)(1)), raising concerns about clarity in spending or potential over-allocation of resources, which may lead to financial inefficiencies.
The term 'appropriate public or private entities' for cooperative agreements (Section 2.(d)(1)) is vague and lacks specificity on eligible entities. This lack of clarity might lead to favoritism or misuse of agreements, which could raise ethical concerns.
The prohibition on acquiring land through condemnation or otherwise (Section 2.(d)(3)(B)) is clear, but the lack of clarity on what exactly might be required for preservation may affect future actions, hindering effective preservation strategies.
The section outlining alternatives for preservation, protection, and interpretation (Section 2.(e)(2)) lacks specificity on criteria for evaluating these alternatives. This could lead to subjective decision-making, which may impact the effectiveness and fairness of preservation efforts.
There is no mention of how the public will be involved or informed during the special resource study (Section 2.(e)), which might raise transparency concerns, potentially affecting public trust and stakeholder engagement in the process.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this act states that it can be called the “Jackie Robinson Commemorative Site Act.”
2. Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill designates the Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, as a national commemorative site and integrates it into the African American Civil Rights Network. It authorizes the Secretary of the Interior to form agreements for educational purposes but restricts land acquisition rights, and mandates a study to assess the site's significance and potential inclusion in the National Park System.