Overview
Title
An Act To establish the Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site in the State of Florida, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H. R. 8012 wants to make a baseball park in Florida, where Jackie Robinson played, a special place that teaches about civil rights, but it will not belong to the National Park group. The government will look at how important this place is but promises not to take the land away from people who own it.
Summary AI
H. R. 8012 aims to designate the Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, as the Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site. It will be part of the African American Civil Rights Network but not a unit of the National Park System. The Secretary of the Interior is authorized to make agreements for educational purposes and will also conduct a study to evaluate the site's potential significance and management alternatives. The bill ensures local property rights are not affected and does not allow the Secretary to acquire land through condemnation.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill titled "Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site Act" addresses the designation of the Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, as a national commemorative site. Although it becomes part of the African American Civil Rights Network, it is not integrated into the National Park System. The bill empowers the Secretary of the Interior to engage with entities for educational and interpretative initiatives. It also mandates a study to evaluate the site’s national significance and explore its potential designation as a unit of the National Park System.
Summary of Significant Issues
One prominent issue is the lack of clarity around funding. The bill does not specify where the money will come from for cooperative agreements made by the Secretary of the Interior for educational programs. There's a concern that this may lead to unclear or uncontrolled spending.
The bill also states that the Jackie Robinson Ballpark will not be part of the National Park System. This might impact the level of federal oversight, protection, and funding, which could hinder its long-term preservation.
The bill requires a resource study to assess the significance of the site and consider preservation strategies. However, there is no detail on how this study will be funded or what criteria will dictate its conclusions. This vagueness might lead to uneven outcomes regarding the site's future.
Furthermore, the Secretary's authority is limited in areas such as land acquisition and local zoning, which could restrict efforts to maintain and develop the site effectively.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, especially those interested in civil rights history and baseball, this bill provides a potential enhancement to the site through educational programs. If successful, these efforts could enrich public understanding of Jackie Robinson's legacy and the broader civil rights movement.
However, the uncertainty surrounding funding and preservation strategies may create uneven benefits. Without clear federal involvement, the site's maintenance and the quality of its educational offerings might suffer.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Local Community and Stakeholders: The local community in Daytona Beach stands to gain from the site's increased recognition, which could boost tourism and local economies. However, the lack of federal protection might pose challenges in developing the site to its full potential.
Educational and Historical Organizations: These entities could benefit from cooperative agreements provided they receive adequate funding. They may play significant roles in developing content and programs that highlight Jackie Robinson’s historic impact.
Government Entities: The state and local government face the challenge of navigating potential limitations in site development due to constraints on land acquisition and local zoning laws. Additionally, the lack of a clear federal funding pathway places pressure on these entities to come up with resources.
In summary, while the bill presents an opportunity to honor a significant historical site associated with Jackie Robinson and the civil rights movement, it raises several issues that need addressing to ensure it fulfills its potential. Without concrete funding and criteria for preserving and enhancing the site, stakeholders might find it difficult to achieve the intended educational and commemorative goals.
Issues
The bill does not specify the budget or funding sources for the cooperative agreements to be made under Section 2(d)(1), which could lead to concerns about undefined spending and fiscal accountability.
The terms of cooperation with public or private entities for interpretive and educational purposes under Section 2(d)(1) are vague, potentially allowing funds to be directed inappropriately and causing a lack of transparency.
The designation of the Jackie Robinson Ballpark site as not being a unit of the National Park System under Section 2(d)(2) may result in a lack of federal protection or funding, compromising long-term preservation efforts.
The study mandated in Section 2(e) lacks specific funding or resource allocations, which could limit its feasibility and thoroughness, raising concerns about the study's potential effectiveness and integrity.
The criteria for evaluating the site's national significance in the special resource study in Section 2(e)(1) are not specified, potentially leading to subjective or inconsistent conclusions about the site's importance.
The limitations on the Secretary's authority in Section 2(d)(3), particularly regarding land acquisition and local zoning, may create complications in efforts to preserve and develop the site.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides the short title for the Act, which is called the “Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site Act.”
2. Jackie Robinson Ballpark National Commemorative Site Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Jackie Robinson Ballpark in Daytona Beach, Florida, is designated as a national commemorative site and included in the African American Civil Rights Network, but it will not become a part of the National Park System. The Secretary of the Interior can make cooperative agreements for educational purposes and will study the site's significance, but cannot interfere with property rights or acquire land without permission.