Overview
Title
To prohibit data brokers from transferring sensitive data of United States individuals to foreign adversaries, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The "Protecting Americans’ Data from Foreign Adversaries Act of 2024" is a rule that tries to stop people from selling or sharing important information about Americans, like their addresses or phone numbers, with certain countries that might cause problems for the U.S. The government wants to make sure no one cheats with this rule, and they will check to make sure everyone is following it.
Summary AI
The H.R. 7520, titled the "Protecting Americans’ Data from Foreign Adversaries Act of 2024," aims to stop data brokers from sharing or selling sensitive information about people in the United States to foreign adversaries. It defines sensitive data to include things like Social Security numbers, health details, financial information, and communications. The bill empowers the Federal Trade Commission to enforce this rule, treating violations as unfair or deceptive acts. The bill will take effect 60 days after it becomes law.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill titled "Protecting Americans’ Data from Foreign Adversaries Act of 2024" is designed to prevent data brokers from transferring sensitive information about United States individuals to foreign adversaries. Introduced in the 118th Congress, its primary purpose is to safeguard Americans' sensitive data, such as Social Security numbers, health records, and precise geolocation, from being accessed by countries or entities that may pose a threat to national security.
General Summary of the Bill
The core of the bill is centered around making it illegal for data brokers to sell or transfer sensitive information of U.S. residents to foreign adversaries or any entities controlled by them. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is tasked with the enforcement of this prohibition. The legislation outlines what constitutes sensitive data, including government-issued identifiers, health and financial information, and more. It also details what is meant by a "foreign adversary" or an entity "controlled by a foreign adversary," which relies on existing legal definitions.
Significant Issues
Several issues arise from the bill's current drafting. Firstly, the definition of a "foreign adversary country" is dependent on referencing another legal document, which may not be easily accessible or understood by all stakeholders. This could lead to confusion about which countries are considered foreign adversaries. Additionally, the bill does not specify the penalties for violations, potentially leading to uncertainties in compliance and enforcement.
The broad definition of "sensitive data" could pose challenges since it encompasses a wide range of information, some of which may be interpreted subjectively, such as "photos" or "calendar information." Moreover, the criteria for an entity to be considered "controlled by a foreign adversary" might be seen as too simplistic and not truly indicative of control or influence.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
For the general public, this bill could provide increased protection against potential misuse of their private data by foreign entities, enhancing their data privacy and security. However, the broad definitions in the bill might lead to complex compliance requirements for data brokers and other businesses that handle personal data.
Data brokers might face significant operational changes to comply with the new legal standards. This could involve tightening data access controls or fundamentally altering their business models. On the other hand, citizens who are concerned about privacy and data security may view this legislative effort as a positive step toward protecting their personal information from foreign exploitation.
Conclusion
Overall, while the bill aims to fortify the data security of U.S. individuals by blocking transactions with foreign adversaries, it brings along challenges in its current form. Specifying penalties and refining definitions may be necessary to ensure clarity and effective enforcement. The impact on data brokers and benefits to U.S. citizens must be carefully balanced to achieve the intended goals of enhanced national security and privacy protection.
Issues
The definition of 'foreign adversary country' relies on cross-referencing section 4872(d)(2) of title 10, United States Code, which could create difficulties for stakeholders in identifying affected countries (Section 2).
The lack of specific penalties for violations by the Federal Trade Commission could create uncertainty around enforcement and compliance consequences for data brokers (Section 2).
The broad and extensive definition of 'sensitive data', which includes items like 'calendar information' and 'photos', may pose enforcement and compliance challenges due to potential ambiguity (Section 2).
The use of a 20 percent ownership stake as a criterion to determine if an entity is controlled by a foreign adversary might be seen as arbitrary and not indicative of actual control or influence (Section 2).
Excluding 'service providers' from the definition of 'data broker' could create loopholes where entities may reclassify themselves to avoid regulation (Section 2).
The document lacks provisions for addressing changes in the list of 'foreign adversary countries', potentially complicating ongoing compliance (Section 2).
The bill does not discuss data protection or disposal methods for sensitive data, which could have ethical and privacy implications (Section 2).
Precise geolocation information being defined with a range up to 1,850 feet might be seen as insufficiently precise for some contexts or too restrictive for others, potentially affecting its applicability and interpretation (Section 2).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this bill states that the official name of the legislation is the “Protecting Americans’ Data from Foreign Adversaries Act of 2024.”
2. Prohibition on transfer of sensitive data of United States individuals to foreign adversaries Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section, it is illegal for data brokers to share sensitive data of Americans with foreign adversaries or entities they control. The Federal Trade Commission is responsible for enforcing this rule, and sensitive data includes personal information like Social Security numbers, health records, and precise location data.