Overview
Title
To reinstate pre-pandemic telework policies of Executive agencies, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill wants to bring back the same work-from-home rules for government workers that were used before COVID. If workers don't follow these rules, they could lose their jobs, and someone will check to see if people working from home are being paid the right amount based on where they are working.
Summary AI
H.R. 7080, titled the “Earn Your Keep Act,” aims to bring back the telework policies that Executive agencies had in place before the COVID-19 pandemic. This bill requires the head of each Executive agency to reinstate these previous telework policies within 30 days of the bill being enacted. If any employee does not follow the reinstated telework policy, they will be removed from their position, and their job will be eliminated. Additionally, the Comptroller General must submit a report to Congress within 60 days, analyzing the locality pay and the geographic locations of the telework sites used during the pandemic.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The bill titled "Earn Your Keep Act" seeks to mandate the reinstatement of telework policies that were in place for Executive agencies as of December 31, 2019. This move reflects a desire to return to pre-pandemic norms regarding work-from-home arrangements. The bill proposes that, within 30 days of enactment, heads of Executive agencies must reinstate these previous telework policies. Furthermore, it imposes strict measures, such as removing employees from service if they fail to follow the reinstated telework arrangements. Additionally, the bill calls for a report by the Comptroller General to analyze locality pay and geographical locations of teleworking employees during the pandemic.
Significant Issues
Strict Compliance and Employee Removal: The bill outlines severe consequences for employees not adhering to reinstated telework policies by mandating their removal and eliminating their positions. Such stringent measures may not consider valid reasons for noncompliance, such as health issues or personal circumstances, raising ethical and legal concerns.
Conflict with Collective Bargaining Agreements: The bill intends to prioritize the reinstated telework policies over any conflicting agreements, including collective bargaining agreements. This could lead to conflicts with existing labor rights protected under other federal laws, potentially resulting in legal disputes.
Aggressive Timeline for Implementation: Executive agencies are given only 30 days to revert to the old telework policies. This timeline might be too short for agencies to adequately adjust and communicate these changes to their staff, potentially causing confusion and operational disruptions.
GAO Study Requirement: The bill requires a comprehensive study on locality pay and teleworking during the COVID-19 pandemic within 60 days. Considering the complexity involved, such a prompt requirement may be too ambitious and result in challenges in producing a thorough and accurate report.
Definition Clarity: The bill includes both "telework" and "remote work" under the same definition, but does not distinctly differentiate between the two, potentially leading to inconsistent interpretations and practices among different agencies.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, particularly those employed by Executive agencies, this bill represents a significant shift back to pre-pandemic work norms. It could lead to decreased flexibility for employees who have adapted to or prefer telework setups established during the pandemic. On a broader societal level, this reversion may also affect public perceptions of work-life balance and the future of remote work.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Executive Agency Employees: Employees would face a potential rollback in work-from-home flexibility, which could impact those who have adapted their personal lives around more flexible telework arrangements. The threat of job elimination for noncompliance could cause anxiety and dissatisfaction in the workforce.
Federal Labor Unions: The bill's potential to override collective bargaining agreements is likely to draw pushback from labor unions, which advocate for employee rights and protections. This aspect might lead to organized resistance and could result in legal battles over the sanctity of labor agreements.
Agency Administrators: Agency heads would bear the challenge of quickly reverting to past policies and ensuring proper communication and adherence, which may strain resources and operational efficiencies.
Government Oversight Bodies: The requirement for a rapid locality pay analysis might stretch the resources of the Government Accountability Office, increasing the workload significantly within a short timeframe, thereby impacting the quality and depth of the report.
In conclusion, while the "Earn Your Keep Act" aims to restore pre-pandemic telework policies, it raises significant procedural, legal, and ethical concerns that merit careful consideration and debate before implementation.
Issues
The requirement under Section 2(c) to remove any employee who does not comply with the reinstated telework policy and eliminate their position might be considered harsh and potentially unethical. This approach may not adequately account for legitimate reasons for noncompliance, such as disability accommodations or family leave issues, leading to potential legal challenges and public backlash.
The language in Section 2(b), which states that the reinstated telework policy shall apply in place of any conflicting provision of a teleworking, collective bargaining, or other employment agreement, could result in legal conflicts with collective bargaining agreements that might be protected under existing federal laws. This raises significant legal concerns about the bill overriding established labor rights.
The expedited timeline outlined in Section 2(a), which requires the reinstatement of pre-pandemic telework policies within 30 days, may not allow adequate time for Executive agencies to prepare and communicate changes to employees. This could lead to operational issues, employee confusion, and negative perceptions among the workforce.
The imposition of a requirement in Section 2(d) for the GAO to conduct a study on locality pay within 60 days may be considered rigorous given the complexity and potential variety of locality pay scenarios across numerous agencies. The practicality and feasibility of conducting such a comprehensive study in a short period could be questioned.
The definitions in Section 2(e), where 'telework' and 'teleworking' include remote work, may create confusion because the bill does not clearly differentiate between remote work and teleworking. This lack of clarity could result in inconsistent interpretations and implementations across different agencies.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill specifies its short title, which is “Earn Your Keep Act.”
2. Reinstatement of pre-pandemic Executive agency telework policies Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill requires each Executive agency to revert to their telework policies from December 31, 2019, within 30 days of the bill's enactment. If any employee does not follow these reinstated telework policies, they will be removed from their position, which will be eliminated. Additionally, the Comptroller General must report to Congress about the pay rate and work location of teleworking employees during the COVID-19 pandemic.