Overview
Title
To require institutions of higher education to disseminate information on the rights of, and accommodations and resources for, pregnant students, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
This bill wants colleges to tell students about special help and rights they have if they are having a baby, so they don't feel alone or unfairly treated, and to make sure students can find this info in places like emails and websites.
Summary AI
H. R. 6914 requires colleges and universities to provide information to students about their rights and available resources if they become pregnant. The bill addresses the challenges pregnant students may face, including discrimination and lack of support, and insists that educational institutions list resources for pregnant students on campus and in the community. It also requires institutions to inform students about how they can file complaints if they believe their rights have been violated. Information about these rights and resources must be shared through emails, in student handbooks, at orientations, and on the institutions' websites.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The "Pregnant Students’ Rights Act" is a legislative proposal aimed at ensuring that students at higher education institutions receive comprehensive information about their rights, accommodations, and available resources if they become pregnant. This bill acknowledges the unique challenges that pregnant students face, particularly those who are unsure of their rights under Title IX, which helps protect against discrimination in educational institutions due to pregnancy. The bill mandates colleges and universities to provide this essential information through various channels, including emails, student handbooks, orientations, and school websites.
Significant Issues
Several issues are identified with the current draft of the bill:
Unfunded Mandates: The requirement to distribute information broadly across multiple platforms at educational institutions does not come with specified funding or resources. Institutions may struggle to meet these mandates without additional support.
Lack of Clarity on Accommodations: The bill lacks specific details on what 'accommodations' for pregnant students should entail, possibly resulting in inconsistent application across different schools.
Ambiguity in Legal Language: The legal references regarding rights under Title IX are not extensively clarified for those unfamiliar with the law, which might limit the understanding and application of these protections.
Undefined 'Period of Study': Institutions are required to email information at the start of each 'period of study,' but the term is not defined, leaving room for interpretation and inconsistency.
No Consequences for Non-compliance: The bill does not outline any repercussions for institutions that fail to comply with the information dissemination requirements, potentially undermining its effectiveness.
Impact on the Public
If enacted, this bill could positively impact the general student population by promoting awareness of rights and resources, thus helping pregnant students make informed decisions without fearing academic penalties or discrimination. The emphasis on resource availability might also foster a more inclusive and supportive academic environment.
However, the lack of detailed guidelines and resources for institutions might lead to variability in how effectively different colleges and universities implement the requirements. This inconsistency could result in disparities in the support and information accessible to students across various institutions.
Impact on Stakeholders
Students: The primary beneficiaries of this bill are pregnant students and those who may become pregnant. By ensuring they receive timely and relevant information, the bill attempts to mitigate some of the pressures and challenges they face. However, the impact will heavily depend on how well schools adhere to and implement the information dissemination requirements.
Higher Education Institutions: Colleges and universities could find themselves facing challenges due to the potential unfunded nature of the mandate. Without clear guidelines or financial support, institutions may struggle to comply, which could lead to inconsistent outcomes in implementing the bill's requirements.
Educational Administrators and Policymakers: These stakeholders might need to consider additional resources or support mechanisms to ensure successful implementation. This would include clarifying ambiguous terms and providing clear guidelines on accommodations to improve uniformity in implementation.
Overall, while the bill aims to address a significant gap in support and resources for pregnant students, careful consideration and further refinement may be needed to ensure it achieves its intended outcomes without placing undue burdens on educational institutions.
Issues
Section 3 - Unfunded Mandates: The requirement for institutions to perform information dissemination activities is not supported by specified funding or resources, potentially leading to unfunded mandates that institutions may struggle to comply with.
Section 3 - Lack of Clarity on Accommodations: The section lacks specificity regarding the nature of 'accommodations available' for pregnant students, which may lead to inconsistent implementation across different institutions.
Section 2 - Ambiguity in Legal Language: The language regarding the rights to accommodation and prohibitions against discrimination under title IX could be clearer for readers unfamiliar with legal references, potentially limiting its effectiveness.
Section 3 - Undefined 'Period of Study': The bill mandates that institutions email each student at the start of each 'period of study,' yet this term is not defined, leading to potential inconsistencies in implementation.
Section 3 - No Consequences for Non-compliance: The bill does not address potential consequences for non-compliance by institutions, which might limit its efficacy in ensuring students are informed about their rights and available resources.
Section 3 - Update Frequency of Resource Information: There is no guidance on how often and in what manner the resources list should be updated, which could result in institutions providing outdated information.
Section 3 - Minimal Compliance at Health Centers: The requirement to disseminate information 'at student health or counseling centers, if any' lacks specificity on how this should be accomplished, potentially leading to minimal compliance.
Section 2 - Undefined 'Academic Disparity': The term 'academic disparity' is not defined in the findings, leading to potential ambiguity in understanding the specific challenges faced by pregnant students.
Section 2 - Vague Language on Institutional Reprisal: The phrase 'fear institutional reprisal' is vague, and the bill does not specify examples of potential repercussions, limiting clarity for those interpreting the document.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that its official name is the “Pregnant Students’ Rights Act.”
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress finds that female college students who experience unplanned pregnancies may feel pressured to have an abortion due to concerns about academic failure and lack of support. It highlights that a large number of abortions are among college-age women, who may not be aware of their rights under Title IX, which protects them from discrimination during pregnancy, and underscores a need for better resources and support for those who choose to carry their pregnancies to term.
3. Notice of pregnant student rights, accommodations, and resources Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Each college or university must provide information to students about the rights and resources available to pregnant students, including accommodations and how to file pregnancy-related discrimination complaints. This information should be shared via email, in student handbooks, during orientation, at student health centers, and on the school’s website.