Overview
Title
To extend the Federal recognition to the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill is about officially recognizing a group of people called the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, which means they'll get help from the government, like special services and a place to live.
Summary AI
H.R. 6859, titled the "Gabrielino/Tongva Nation Recognition Act of 2023," proposes to grant federal recognition to the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation. This recognition would make the tribe and its members eligible for federal benefits and services typically available to recognized Indian tribes. The bill outlines the process for establishing a membership roll and provides for the transfer of up to 300 acres of land into trust for the tribe, which can be used for a reservation. Additionally, it ensures that existing rights or claims of the tribe are not diminished by this new recognition.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
H.R. 6859, known as the “Gabrielino/Tongva Nation Recognition Act of 2023,” aims to extend federal recognition to the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation. This recognition bestows eligibility for federal services and benefits upon the Tribe and its members. The bill outlines the historical context and legal milestones of the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, emphasizing its longstanding presence and interactions with federal and state authorities. It also details the processes and implications of this recognition, including the eligibility for services, maintenance of a membership roll, and the transfer of land to the Tribe.
Significant Issues
Several significant issues arise from the proposed legislation:
Financial Implications: The bill does not specify the financial implications or costs associated with extending federal recognition and services to the Tribe. This omission could lead to uncontrolled spending or a lack of budgetary oversight.
Implementation Details: There is a lack of clarity regarding how federal recognition will be implemented and which particular federal laws will apply. This ambiguity could complicate the practical application of the recognition process and impact compliance.
Geographic Limitations: The specification of Los Angeles County as the service area for benefits could overlook Tribe members living outside this region, possibly resulting in inefficient resource allocation.
Membership Roll Challenges: The tight deadline for the Tribe to submit a membership roll may not provide sufficient time to ensure its accuracy and could potentially lead to disputes or oversights.
Lack of Oversight Mechanisms: The absence of outlined mechanisms for auditing or reviewing the provision of federal services and benefits may hinder the ability to monitor and ensure the efficient use of resources.
Land Acquisition Process: The broad authority granted to the Secretary to acquire land without clearly defined criteria or limitations could lead to biases or improper acquisition practices.
Property Transfer Autonomy: Allowing the Tribe to transfer property interests without further approval could result in the unregulated sale of assets, potentially affecting the Tribe's future economic stability.
Confusion Over Naming: The use of various names for the Tribe could lead to inconsistency and confusion regarding the application of the bill's provisions.
Impact on the Public
The public broadly may perceive this bill as a step towards rectifying historical oversights and injustices faced by the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation. By providing federal recognition, the bill acknowledges the Tribe's cultural and historical significance. However, the public may also be concerned about the financial implications of extending these services and the potential for inefficiencies or ambiguities in implementing the recognition.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Gabrielino/Tongva Nation: This bill is likely to have a positive impact on the Tribe, providing access to federal services and benefits that support the Tribe's cultural preservation, health, education, and overall well-being. The federal recognition could enhance the Tribe's ability to govern itself and manage its affairs more effectively.
Federal Government: The government faces the challenge of ensuring efficient allocation and oversight of resources. The bill's lack of detailed financial planning and implementation strategies may complicate its execution, necessitating careful management to avoid excess spending and ensure accountability.
Local Communities: Los Angeles County and surrounding areas might experience an increase in federal resources and benefits dedicated to tribal members, which could have positive economic and social effects. However, the limited geographic scope might lead to tensions if members living outside the defined service area feel underserved.
This proposed legislation seeks to rectify historical grievances and affirm the rights and sovereignty of the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, yet the concerns over financial implications, implementation details, and effective resource allocation remain points of potential contention.
Issues
The bill extends Federal recognition to the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, allowing them eligibility for Federal services and benefits without specifying the associated financial implications or costs, potentially leading to significant governmental expenditure without financial oversight (Sections 4 and 5).
The process for implementing Federal recognition is not detailed, leaving ambiguity about how it will be operationalized and which Federal laws will be applicable or exempt (Sections 4).
The specification of Los Angeles County as the service area for the Tribe's benefits may ignore the potential needs of Tribe members residing outside this area, risking resource misallocation (Section 5).
The section on 'Membership Roll' imposes a tight deadline for submission, which may be insufficient for ensuring accuracy and transparency, potentially leading to disputes or errors (Section 7).
There are no mechanisms outlined for auditing or reviewing the provision of Federal services and benefits, which might hinder accountability and effective use of resources (Section 5).
The broad authority granted to the Secretary to acquire land within 90 days without checks or specific criteria may lead to favoritism or improper practices, as it lacks clarity on the process or limitations (Section 8).
The ability of the Tribe to transfer interests in real property without further approval could lead to potential economic issues for the Tribe if significant assets were to be sold off without sufficient oversight (Section 8).
The various names used for the 'Tribe' could lead to confusion and a lack of consistency in the application or interpretation of the bill's provisions (Section 2).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill specifies that the official name for this act is the “Gabrielino/Tongva Nation Recognition Act of 2023.”
2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section provides definitions for specific terms used in the Act. It explains that "member" refers to a person who is a citizen and enrolled in the Tribe, "Secretary" refers to the Secretary of the Interior, and "Tribe" refers to the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation, which is also known by other names.
3. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress acknowledges the longstanding history and presence of the Gabrielino/Tongva Nation in the Los Angeles Basin and surrounding areas, detailing their recognition and interactions with federal and state authorities over time, including landmark acts and resolutions, culminating in a membership comprising over 700 Tribal citizens today.
4. Federal recognition Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Federal recognition is granted to the Tribe, meaning that they are officially acknowledged by the federal government. All federal laws that generally apply to Native American tribes, including the Indian Reorganization Act, will also apply to this Tribe unless specified otherwise in the Act.
5. Federal services and benefits Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Members of the Tribe mentioned in this bill are eligible for all federal services and benefits provided to Indian tribes, regardless of whether they live on or near a reservation. The service area for these benefits is defined as Los Angeles County, California, and this applies even if new land is acquired or a reservation is established after the bill's enactment.
6. Reaffirmation of rights Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section of the bill ensures that the Tribe or its members do not lose any rights or privileges they had before the bill was passed. It also states that the Tribe's legal claims to rights or privileges wrongfully taken away before the bill became law are unaffected, unless specified otherwise in the bill.
7. Membership roll Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Tribe is required to submit a list of its members to the Secretary within thirty days of the law being passed. The Tribe's Constitution, along with any amendments or relevant Tribal laws, will set the rules for membership. Once the Secretary receives the list, a notice will be published in the Federal Register, and the Tribe will be responsible for keeping the list up-to-date.
8. Transfer of land Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the process and conditions under which the Secretary will acquire and hold land in trust for a Tribe, including an initial reservation of up to 300 acres, deemed part of restoring lands for federally recognized tribes. It also allows the Tribe to manage, lease, or sell certain non-trust lands without further U.S. approval.