Overview
Title
To establish a policy regarding appraisal and valuation services for real property for a transaction over which the Secretary of the Interior has jurisdiction, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The AACE Act wants to make it easier for people who figure out the value of land or buildings for the government to work in any state if they’re allowed to in just one state. It also makes sure the rules for doing this are shared with everyone and that they check yearly to see how well the process is working.
Summary AI
H. R. 5443, also known as the "Accelerating Appraisals and Conservation Efforts Act" or "AACE Act," aims to streamline the appraisal and valuation services for real property transactions under the jurisdiction of the Secretary of the Interior. The bill allows appraisers to be licensed in just one state to provide services in any state, as long as the Secretary oversees the transaction. It also encourages the use of non-Federal appraisers, provided they meet certain criteria, and requires the Department of the Interior to submit annual reports to Congress assessing these practices. Additionally, the bill mandates the public availability of all policies related to these appraisal services.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed legislation, known as the "Accelerating Appraisals and Conservation Efforts Act" or the "AACE Act," seeks to streamline the appraisal and valuation process for real property transactions under the jurisdiction of the Secretary of the Interior. This bill introduces measures aimed at increasing flexibility and efficiency in how appraisal services are conducted for federal transactions across the United States.
General Summary
The core objective of the bill is to allow appraisers to perform valuation services for real estate transactions anywhere in the U.S., provided they are licensed or certified in at least one state. The legislation also emphasizes the use of non-Federal appraisers under certain conditions, such as unavailability or lack of cost competitiveness of appraisers certified in the state where the property is located. Additionally, the bill mandates annual reporting on appraisal services to Congress and requires the public disclosure of related policies and procedures.
Significant Issues
There are several noteworthy concerns associated with the bill:
Inconsistent Standards Across States: By allowing appraisers certified in one state to work on federal transactions nationwide, there is a risk of inconsistent appraisal standards. This inconsistency could affect property valuations and fairness across state lines.
Lack of Specificity in Appraiser Use: The bill permits the use of non-Federal appraisers but does not specify clear criteria for when and how they can be employed. This ambiguity could lead to misuse and questions regarding the integrity of the appraisal process.
Reporting and Accountability: While the bill requires annual reports to Congress, it does not enforce penalties for failing to submit these reports on time, which could undermine accountability and transparency.
Public Availability of Policies: The requirement to publicly disclose all related policies does not address issues of data protection or the management of sensitive information, posing potential risks of exposing confidential material.
Bias and Favoritism Risks: Allowing appraisers licensed in only one state to operate nationwide could lead to favoritism towards particular states or appraisers, which could negatively affect competitiveness and fairness.
Undefined Terms: The term "assignment qualified" used as a criterion for selecting appraisers is not clearly defined, leaving it open to interpretation and potential legal uncertainties.
Financial Implications: The potential cost differences between hiring non-Federal appraisers versus Federal appraisers are not addressed, which could lead to unanticipated expenses.
Impact on the Public
The bill may broadly impact the public by potentially speeding up the process of real estate appraisals involved in federal transactions. This could make it easier and faster for the federal government to engage in real property transactions, possibly benefiting conservation efforts and infrastructure projects.
However, the lack of uniform standards for appraisals could lead to disparities in property valuations, affecting stakeholders differently depending on state regulations and local real estate markets.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Positive Impacts: - Real Estate Developers and Investors: They may benefit from expedited appraisal processes, facilitating quicker turnarounds on projects requiring federal land transactions. - Federal Agencies: Increased flexibility in hiring appraisers might lead to improved efficiency in managing real property assets.
Negative Impacts: - State Regulators: They might face challenges in maintaining consistent appraisal standards across borders. - Local Appraisers: Favoritism towards non-Federal appraisers could reduce opportunities for local professionals, impacting their businesses. - Property Owners: Inconsistent appraisals could lead to disputes or inequities in property valuations, affecting property sales or acquisitions.
In conclusion, while the AACE Act aims to enhance federal appraisal service efficiency, it presents several challenges that need to be addressed to ensure fairness, consistency, and transparency in real property transactions under the federal jurisdiction.
Issues
The bill allows non-Federal covered appraisers to perform appraisal services in states where they are not certified under certain conditions (Section 2(b)). This could lead to inconsistent appraisal standards across different states, potentially affecting property valuations and fairness in real estate transactions.
Subsection 2(c) requires annual reporting to Congress but does not specify penalties for non-compliance or incentives for timely submission, potentially leading to delays or omissions and reducing accountability and transparency.
There is no clear mechanism to determine or verify the conditions under which a non-Federal covered appraiser can be used (Section 2(b)(2)). This lack of specificity might lead to potential misuse and questions about the integrity of appraisal processes.
Section 2(e) mandates public availability of all related policies and documents within 90 days but does not address data protection or sensitive information management, creating potential risks of exposing confidential material.
The provision allowing a covered appraiser to be licensed or certified in only one state could lead to favoritism towards specific states or appraisers from specific states (Section 2(a)), which might undermine fairness and competitiveness.
The term 'assignment qualified' in subsection 2(b)(2)(B) is not clearly defined, leading to ambiguous interpretations that could create legal uncertainties and challenges in compliance.
There is no assessment of the financial implications of hiring non-Federal covered appraisers or the potential cost differences with Federal appraisers (Section 2(b)), which might lead to unforeseen expenses impacting budgetary allocations.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act states that it can be referred to as either the "Accelerating Appraisals and Conservation Efforts Act" or simply the "AACE Act".
2. Appraisal and valuation services for real property Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that appraisers for real estate must be licensed or certified in at least one state to work on federal transactions anywhere in the U.S. It also requires the Department of the Interior to report annually on appraisal services, maintain public access to relevant policies, and ensures existing federal and state laws remain applicable except where noted.