Overview
Title
An Act To amend the Federal Reserve Act to prohibit the Federal reserve banks from offering certain products or services directly to an individual, to prohibit the use of central bank digital currency for monetary policy, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 5403 is a bill that says the U.S. government cannot use a special kind of digital money called "central bank digital currency" or CBDC, to make rules about money without first asking permission from Congress. It also makes sure that this money can't be given to people directly and must keep people's money secret and safe.
Summary AI
H.R. 5403, known as the "CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act," aims to amend the Federal Reserve Act to restrict the Federal Reserve banks from offering products or services directly to individuals and from issuing a central bank digital currency (CBDC). It prohibits the use of CBDCs in monetary policy and further bans the Federal Reserve from testing such currencies without Congress's approval. The bill also reinforces privacy protections by excluding open, permissionless, and private dollar-denominated currencies that safeguard user privacy from these restrictions. Additionally, it expresses Congress's position against the Federal Reserve's development or use of a CBDC for monetary policy purposes.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill, titled the CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act, aims to amend the Federal Reserve Act with specific prohibitions related to central bank digital currencies (CBDCs). It seeks to restrict Federal Reserve banks from directly offering financial products or services to individuals, including the issuance of digital currencies similar to CBDCs. Furthermore, it prohibits the Federal Reserve and the Secretary of the Treasury from developing or issuing a CBDC without Congressional authorization. The Act also explicitly states that CBDCs should not be used for implementing monetary policy and bars any testing of CBDCs unless explicitly permitted by Congress.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several significant issues arise from this bill:
Limiting Financial Innovation: The prohibition on Federal Reserve banks directly issuing or testing CBDCs without Congressional approval could hinder the United States' ability to keep up with global digital currency advancements. This regulatory hurdle might delay necessary innovations in the financial system.
Ambiguities in Language: The language in the bill around terms like "digital assets that are substantially similar" and "open, permissionless, and private currency" is vague. Such ambiguities could lead to varying interpretations and potential legal challenges.
Monetary Policy Tools: The bill's prohibition on using CBDCs for monetary policy lacks a clear rationale. This limitation might restrict the Federal Reserve from utilizing potentially valuable tools that could offer economic flexibility and responsiveness.
Redundancy and Confusion: The bill contains redundant definitions of "central bank digital currency" concerning both the Federal Reserve and the Treasury, which could cause confusion.
Impact on the Public
The public might experience both positive and negative impacts from this bill. On one hand, the prohibition could protect individual privacy by preventing the federal government from directly managing digital currencies akin to CBDCs or surveilling transactions. On the other hand, by potentially slowing technological adaptation, the bill might limit the public's access to innovative financial services that could enhance convenience and efficiency in monetary transactions.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For financial institutions and tech companies involved in digital currency development and blockchain technology, this bill could have negative implications. The stringent prohibitions and required Congressional authorization for CBDC advancement might stifle innovation and hinder competitive positioning globally. Conversely, privacy advocates may view this bill positively, as it appears to emphasize safeguarding individual privacy and limiting governmental control over digital currencies.
Federal Reserve officials and policymakers might face constraints as they navigate the evolving financial landscape. This bill restricts their ability to experiment with and implement digital currencies, potentially limiting their toolkit for responding to economic challenges. Congress, however, would gain more regulatory oversight, which could lead to a more structured and cautious approach to integrating digital currencies into the financial system.
Overall, while aiming to reinforce privacy and limit federal control over personal financial interactions, the bill presents challenges in keeping pace with rapid global advancements in digital finance.
Financial Assessment
The "CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act," as described in H.R. 5403, does not contain explicit references to spending, appropriations, or direct financial allocations. Instead, the bill outlines prohibitions and restrictions related to the Federal Reserve's handling of central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) and other related financial technologies. These restrictions and their ramifications can be understood concerning the identified issues.
Restrictions on Financial Technology
The bill seeks to restrict the Federal Reserve from issuing or testing central bank digital currencies directly or indirectly without Congressional approval. This could have financial implications by potentially delaying the Federal Reserve's ability to respond to technological advancements in global financial markets. Such a prohibition could result in the U.S. financial system lagging behind other nations that adopt and integrate digital currencies into their economies more swiftly. This delay might affect the U.S.'s competitive edge in international financial innovation.
Congressional Oversight and Potential Delays
Sections 5 and 317 introduce Congressional oversight requirements before the Federal Reserve or the Treasury can take significant steps toward developing a CBDC. This requirement, while aimed at providing a check on the central bank's activities, could result in significant delays in the adoption of new digital currency technologies. Such delays may impact the financial system's responsiveness and the Federal Reserve's capability to engage in innovative financial practices.
Ambiguity and Legal Challenges
The bill's language includes terms such as "digital assets that are substantially similar" and "open, permissionless, and private currency," which are not clearly defined within the text. This ambiguity could lead to varied interpretations, possibly resulting in legal challenges. From a financial perspective, inconsistent definitions could create confusion regarding which digital assets are permissible and complicate the enforcement of these restrictions, potentially affecting stakeholders differently.
Prohibition on Monetary Policy Use
The bill also stipulates that CBDCs cannot be used as tools for monetary policy (Section 4). There is no financial rationale or justification provided for this limitation, which could be viewed as hindering the central bank's ability to utilize all possible tools to maintain economic stability. By limiting these tools without clear reasoning, the bill may restrict the Federal Reserve's financial flexibility to address economic challenges.
Overall Financial Impact
While the bill does not delineate direct financial expenditures or funding allocations, its implications on the financial system are significant. By imposing these restrictions, the legislation could influence the speed and manner in which the United States engages with future digital financial technologies. Stakeholders in the financial sector should consider these potential impacts, as they may affect market operations and the broader economic landscape.
Issues
The prohibition on Federal reserve banks from directly issuing a central bank digital currency (CBDC), as stated in Section 2, could limit the Federal Reserve's ability to adopt new financial technologies, potentially putting the U.S. at a disadvantage in global financial innovation.
The requirement for Congressional authorization before the Federal Reserve or Treasury can develop or issue a CBDC, as outlined in Sections 5 and 317, could lead to delays in adapting to digital currency advancements, impacting the financial system's responsiveness to innovation.
The ambiguity in the definition of 'digital assets that are substantially similar under any other name or label', referenced in Sections 2 and 4, could lead to varied interpretations and potential legal challenges.
The lack of clear rationale for the prohibition of using CBDCs for monetary policy, as found in Section 4, could be seen as limiting monetary policy tools without sufficient justification, potentially hindering economic flexibility.
The redundancy in defining 'central bank digital currency' in both the Federal Reserve and the Treasury contexts, as noted in Sections 5 and 317, may cause confusion and reflects a need for clearer, unified definitions.
The prohibition on testing CBDCs without Congressional authorization, discussed in Section 8, could stifle innovation and experimentation, making it difficult for the Federal Reserve to adapt to future financial technologies.
The vague terms such as 'open, permissionless, and private currency' in Section 6, without clear definitions or standards, could lead to inconsistent enforcement and application of the law.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it can be officially called the "CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act."
2. Prohibition on Federal reserve banks relating to certain products or services for individuals and prohibition on directly issuing a central bank digital currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed amendment to the Federal Reserve Act prohibits Federal reserve banks from offering products or services directly to individuals, maintaining accounts for individuals, or issuing digital currencies similar to a central bank digital currency to individuals.
3. Prohibition on Federal reserve banks indirectly issuing a central bank digital currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text outlines a new rule added to the Federal Reserve Act, stating that Federal reserve banks are not allowed to indirectly offer a central bank digital currency to individuals through financial institutions or other intermediaries. However, this rule does not apply to digital currencies that are open, permissionless, private, and preserve the privacy protections similar to traditional U.S. coins and cash.
Money References
- “(B) Subparagraph (A) may not be construed to prohibit any dollar-denominated currency that is open, permissionless, and private, and fully preserves the privacy protections of United States coins and physical currency.”.
4. Prohibition on the use of central bank digital currency for monetary policy Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section prohibits the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors and the Federal Open Market Committee from using central bank digital currency or similar digital assets for executing monetary policy.
5. Central bank digital currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill amends the Federal Reserve Act and the United States Code to prohibit the Federal Reserve System and the Secretary of the Treasury from creating or issuing a central bank digital currency unless Congress specifically authorizes it. A central bank digital currency is defined as digital money that is directly linked to the Federal Reserve or the central bank.
16A. Central bank digital currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that the Federal Reserve is not allowed to create or launch a central bank digital currency without approval from Congress. It defines this currency as digital money that would be a direct responsibility of the Federal Reserve and measured in the national currency.
317. Central bank digital currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that the Secretary of the Treasury is not allowed to instruct the Federal Reserve to create a central bank digital currency without approval from Congress. It also explains that a central bank digital currency is a type of digital money that is a direct liability of the central bank and is valued in the national currency.
6. Protection for open, permissionless, and private currency Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that the Act, along with its amendments, does not apply to any digital currency that is similar to the US dollar and maintains the same level of privacy as physical US coins and currency.
Money References
- This Act and the amendments made by this Act shall not apply to any dollar-denominated currency that is open, permissionless, and private, and fully preserves the privacy protections of United States coins and physical currency.
7. Sense of Congress Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress expresses its view that the Federal Reserve should not create or use a digital currency for controlling monetary policy.
8. Prohibition on central bank digital currency testing Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends the Federal Reserve Act to prohibit the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and Federal reserve banks from conducting or approving any tests related to central bank digital currency, unless Congress passes a new law allowing it.