Overview
Title
An Act To amend parts B and E of title IV of the Social Security Act to improve foster and adoptive parent recruitment and retention, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 3058 is a plan to help make it easier for people who want to take care of children who don’t have families. It asks each state to create a teamwork plan, with the help of community groups, to find more people who can look after these kids and make sure they feel safe and welcomed.
Summary AI
H.R. 3058 aims to improve the recruitment and retention of foster and adoptive parents in the United States. The bill amends parts B and E of title IV of the Social Security Act, requiring each state to adopt a family partnership plan that involves community stakeholders and uses data to assess needs and measure progress. These plans will focus on increasing recruitment of diverse families and addressing challenges faced by foster and adoptive families. Additionally, states must report annually on foster family capacity, challenges in meeting the needs of foster children, and efforts to recruit families that reflect the racial and ethnic backgrounds of these children.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The "Recruiting Families Using Data Act of 2023," formally known as H.R. 3058, seeks to amend parts of the Social Security Act to enhance the recruitment and retention of foster and adoptive parents. The bill requires each state to devise and execute a "family partnership plan." This plan should involve various stakeholders, such as birth and adoptive families, service providers, and youth with foster care experience. The plans aim to solve several issues, including recruitment, licensure, and the engagement of foster and adoptive families, through the strategic use of data. Additionally, starting in fiscal year 2025, an annual report must be submitted to Congress detailing state-by-state information on foster care capacities, challenges, and efforts to recruit families reflecting the racial and ethnic background of foster care children.
Significant Issues
A notable issue is the complexity of the language used in the bill, particularly in Section 2 regarding the family partnership plan. This complexity may lead to inconsistent implementation across states, which could affect the uniformity of foster care reforms nationwide. Another significant concern is the absence of a dedicated budget for states to implement these measures, which might strain resources and delay effective action. Furthermore, the bill allows states needing legislative changes to extend the compliance deadline, but it does not set a definitive timeframe for enforcement, potentially leading to prolonged delays.
In Section 3, collecting detailed state-by-state data could impose considerable administrative costs on states. The bill lacks clear guidance on how the collected data will be utilized to drive meaningful improvements in foster care systems. The broad language concerning the demographics and characteristics of foster families may lead to inconsistent data collection, complicating efforts to maintain nationwide standards.
Impact on the Public
For the general public, the bill underscores a concerted effort to improve the foster care system, which could lead to more stable and permanent placements for children in need. By emphasizing data-driven strategies, the bill attempts to address systemic issues in foster care recruitment and retention, potentially leading to better outcomes for children and families.
However, if the bill's challenges are not addressed, its implementation could be uneven across different states, limiting its positive impact. The absence of specified funding may hinder states' ability to successfully execute the required plans, delaying potential improvements.
Impact on Stakeholders
Families and Children in Foster Care: If effectively implemented, the bill could greatly benefit children and families involved in foster care by increasing placement stability and permanency. Including feedback from families and children could make the system more responsive to their needs.
State Governments and Agencies: State agencies might face challenges in adapting to the new requirements due to the lack of allocated funding and the complexity of the mandated plans. There could be significant administrative and financial burdens without additional federal support.
Community-Based Organizations: The involvement of community-based service providers in formulating family partnership plans could provide valuable local insights. However, there is a risk of potential bias or favoritism if these organizations are not inclusively or equitably engaged.
In conclusion, while the "Recruiting Families Using Data Act of 2023" proposes commendable changes that could improve foster care recruitment and retention, it also presents challenges that need to be carefully managed to ensure uniform, efficient, and fair implementation across all states.
Issues
The complexity and potential difficulty of interpreting the language in Section 2 of the bill regarding the development and implementation of a family partnership plan may lead to inconsistent implementation across states, affecting nationwide foster care policies.
Section 2 does not address an allocated budget to support states in implementing the new measures, which could strain state resources and delay effective action.
There is a lack of clarity in Section 2 about how the effectiveness of the family partnership plans will be evaluated, posing risks to accountability and efficiency in improving foster care systems.
Section 2 allows for a delay in implementation if state legislation is required, but does not impose a deadline for compliance, which could result in significant delays in enforcing the new standards.
In Section 3, the requirement for detailed state-by-state data collection on foster and adoptive families could impose significant administrative costs on states without clear guidance on how the collected data will be used to drive meaningful improvements.
The broad wording in Section 2 regarding the collection of data on 'the number, demographics, and characteristics of licensed foster families' may lead to inconsistent data collection across states, complicating efforts to compare and utilize the data effectively.
Possible favoritism or bias in the consultation process for the family partnership plan, as outlined in Section 2, may arise due to the absence of checks or guidelines, potentially privileging certain community-based service providers or organizations.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the act specifies that it can be referred to as the "Recruiting Families Using Data Act of 2023."
2. State plan amendment Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill proposes changes to the Social Security Act requiring states to create and implement a "family partnership plan" to enhance foster and adoptive family recruitment and retention. These plans must involve community input, use data to improve placements, and report annually on foster care capacities and challenges, with a compliance start date of October 1, 2024, unless state legislation requires more time.
3. Inclusion of information on foster and adoptive families in annual child welfare outcomes report to Congress Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to the Social Security Act requires that a report is submitted annually to Congress starting in fiscal year 2025, which includes detailed State-by-State information on foster and adoptive families. This report should cover the number and demographics of these families, reasons potential families are not used, challenges to becoming or remaining a foster or adoptive parent, and difficulties in recruiting families that reflect the racial and ethnic backgrounds of children in foster care.