Overview
Title
To require the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Secretary of Health and Human Services to make available to the public on the websites of their respective departments certain information relating to individuals processed through U.S. Customs and Border Protection or Department of Health and Human Services facilities, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 299 wants to make sure everyone can see certain details about people who come into the U.S. without permission, like where they're from, how old they are, and if they've done anything illegal. This information will be on two government websites and updated every week.
Summary AI
H.R. 299, also known as the “Transparency of Migration Act,” is a bill introduced in the 119th Congress. It mandates that the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Secretary of Health and Human Services make certain information public on their department websites. This information includes details about individuals who are unlawfully in the U.S. and processed through U.S. Customs and Border Protection or Health and Human Services facilities, such as their country of origin, age, gender, and any criminal convictions they might have. The data will be updated weekly to ensure transparency.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Overview of the Bill
The proposed bill, known as the "Transparency of Migration Act," aims to increase transparency regarding individuals unlawfully present in the United States who are processed through U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) or Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) facilities. Introduced to Congress by Ms. Malliotakis, the bill mandates that the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Secretary of Health and Human Services make certain information about these individuals publicly available on their respective websites. This information includes details such as the number of individuals apprehended, their countries of origin, ages, genders, states they are sent to or released in, and any criminal convictions they may possess.
Significant Issues and Concerns
Privacy and Data Protection: The bill's requirement to disclose information on criminal convictions poses potential privacy issues. Releasing sensitive personal data, especially criminal records, raises concerns about compliance with data protection laws. Balancing transparency and privacy rights seems to be a significant issue that needs thorough consideration.
Lack of Specificity in Public Disclosure: The term "public availability" is not clearly defined in the bill, potentially leading to differing interpretations. This could result in variances concerning the format or details of the data shared, leading to inconsistencies and potential misuse of the information.
Financial and Administrative Implications: The bill does not specify funding sources or budget allocations for collecting, processing, and updating the information weekly. This absence could strain financial resources of the departments involved and affect their overall operations. The necessity for weekly updates might demand considerable administrative resources, leading to logistical challenges.
Accountability and Data Accuracy: Without specifying who is responsible for ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the information, the bill raises concerns about the potential for errors and misuse. Clear accountability measures are essential to maintain the credibility and integrity of the data released to the public.
Potential Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
Public: For the general public, particularly those interested in immigration policies, the bill could provide enhanced transparency about how individuals are processed through immigration systems. However, the concerns surrounding data privacy and the potential misuse of detailed demographic information may impact public perception negatively.
Stakeholders in Data Security: Privacy advocates might view this legislation as a challenge to data protection norms, voicing concerns over the potential for privacy infringement and data misuse. They might demand greater safeguards and clarity on how personal information is protected.
Government Departments: U.S. Customs and Border Protection and the Department of Health and Human Services may face increased pressure to manage the logistics and financial implications of the bill's requirements. Without additional budget allocations, these departments might struggle to meet the weekly update demands, affecting their ability to perform other essential functions.
Legal and Immigration Experts: Professionals working in these fields might express concern about the balance between transparency and privacy rights. They may play a crucial role in shaping the legal discourse around this bill, advocating for amendments to address its potential downsides.
In summary, while the "Transparency of Migration Act" aims to promote greater transparency in immigration processes, it raises significant questions around privacy, resource allocation, and legal compliance. Balancing these factors will be crucial in determining the bill's effectiveness and reception by the public and stakeholders.
Issues
The requirement in Section 2 to make information publicly available, specifically related to 'criminal convictions,' could result in significant privacy concerns, as it deals with sensitive personal data that might contravene data protection laws.
The lack of clarification in Section 2 regarding the definition of 'public availability’ and the manner of information disclosure could lead to different interpretations and potential misuse of sensitive demographic and criminal record data, raising security concerns.
Section 2 does not specify any budget or funding sources for the collection, processing, and updating of the data, potentially leading to unallocated spending or financial strain on existing resources, which may have significant financial implications.
The absence of accountability measures in Section 2 regarding who will oversee the accuracy and reliability of the information made public could lead to errors or misuse without any clear responsibility, impacting the credibility of released data.
The logistical challenge posed by the requirement in Section 2 to update the information weekly could require significant administrative resources, possibly straining departmental capabilities and affecting other operational areas.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the act states that it can be called the "Transparency of Migration Act".
2. Public availability of information relating to individuals processed through U.S. Customs and Border Protection or Department of Health and Human Services facilities Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of Homeland Security and the Secretary of Health and Human Services are required to publicly share weekly updates on their websites about individuals who are illegally in the U.S. and held or released by U.S. Customs and Border Protection or processed through Department of Health and Human Services facilities. This information includes details on the number of individuals, their countries of origin, ages, genders, locations where they are sent or released, and any criminal convictions they may have.