Overview
Title
An Act To direct the Secretary of State to develop a strategy on efforts to strengthen subnational cooperation between the United States and Mexico, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H. R. 2789 is a plan to help the U.S. and Mexico work together better by focusing on stopping drug problems and helping towns near the border. The plan also wants to make it easier for people in the Caribbean to use banks, and it will keep Congress updated on how well this is going.
Summary AI
H. R. 2789, known as the “American Cooperation with Our Neighbors Act,” aims to enhance cooperation between the United States and Mexico at local and regional levels. The bill directs the Secretary of State, along with the U.S. Agency for International Development, to create a strategy focused on improving law enforcement partnerships to combat drug trafficking, engaging local governments and communities, and supporting border towns. Additionally, it requires a review to improve financial access in Caribbean Community member states (CARICOM). The bill mandates regular updates to Congress on the strategy's implementation and effectiveness.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, titled the "American Cooperation with Our Neighbors Act," aims to enhance subnational cooperation between the United States and Mexico. This is primarily for improving joint efforts at the local and state levels to tackle significant issues such as drug trafficking, focusing on fentanyl and other synthetic opioids. The bill instructs the Secretary of State and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) to develop a detailed strategy within 270 days, followed by an update in two years, to be submitted to specific congressional committees. Additionally, the bill mandates a review by the Department of State, in collaboration with the Department of Treasury, to identify improvements for financial access within the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) member states.
Summary of Significant Issues
Key issues identified in the bill include:
Vague Definitions and Timelines: The bill's use of broad terms like "subnational cooperation" lacks concrete definitions, which could lead to inconsistent interpretations and applications. The 270-day timeline for creating the strategy may result in a rushed process, compromising the quality and effectiveness of the plan.
Data Sharing and Bureaucratic Delays: The requirement for notifications to multiple congressional committees before sharing data could introduce delays, impeding timely collaboration essential for addressing urgent issues like drug trafficking.
Security and Information Protection: The necessity for unclassified submissions of the strategy raises concerns about how sensitive information, particularly regarding law enforcement, will be safeguarded.
CARICOM Review: The absence of a clear timeline for the completion and submission of a report on financial access to CARICOM states may lead to delays. The lack of specific criteria for the review can result in broad and potentially inconsistent outcomes.
Impact on the Public and Stakeholders
The bill has implications for a wide array of stakeholders:
Local and State Governments: Positive impacts could arise from improved cooperation and resource sharing between the U.S. and Mexican localities. However, vague terms and hasty timelines could undermine these benefits, leading to inefficiencies or incomplete implementations.
Communities Affected by Drug Trafficking: Enhanced law enforcement collaboration aims to curb fentanyl trafficking, potentially improving local safety and health outcomes. Yet, an overly broad focus on border towns might neglect other impacted regions.
Congressional Committees: By requiring detailed notifications and updates, the bill allows for congressional oversight, but this process could slow down the necessary data sharing needed for effective operations.
CARICOM Member States: The bill's review of financial access opportunities could lead to increased investment and economic growth in the Caribbean region. However, without specific guidelines or benchmarks, these outcomes may vary.
Overall, the bill seeks to foster cooperation and address critical security challenges, but its success largely depends on the resolution of the outlined issues, particularly those concerning clarity, efficiency, and the safeguarding of sensitive information.
Issues
The definition and scope of 'subnational cooperation' in Section 2 are vague and lack clear guidelines, which could lead to differing interpretations and inconsistent application of the strategy across various levels of government and communities. This ambiguity is significant as it affects the core objective of the Act to improve cooperation.
The 270-day timeline for submitting the subnational cooperation strategy in Section 2 may be too short to develop a comprehensive and effective plan, potentially resulting in rushed or incomplete efforts. This could impact the bill's ability to achieve its goals, particularly in addressing complex issues like synthetic opioid trafficking.
The limitation on data sharing in Section 2(d) requires notification to multiple congressional committees, which could introduce bureaucratic delays and hinder timely collaboration efforts necessary to address urgent issues like drug trafficking.
The strategy update timeline of 2 years in Section 2(b) might not be frequent enough to keep pace with rapidly changing trends in fentanyl trafficking, thereby delaying necessary adjustments and improvements in the strategy.
Section 3 lacks a specified timeline for the completion and submission of the Department of State's review and report on financial access to CARICOM member states. This opens up potential for indefinite delays, which could affect economic relations and development in the CARICOM region.
The roles and responsibilities of the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Treasury in Section 3 are not clearly delineated, potentially leading to overlaps, inefficiencies, and disputes in conducting the review of access to finance in CARICOM member states.
The broad scope and lack of specific criteria in Section 3's review could result in arbitrary or inconsistent outcomes, leading to potential legal or political challenges regarding its application or results.
The absence of a plan to safeguard sensitive information as part of the 'unclassified' strategy requirement in Section 2(c) could raise security concerns, especially regarding sensitive data related to law enforcement and national security.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of this bill provides its short title, allowing it to be referred to as the "American Cooperation with Our Neighbors Act".
2. Subnational Cooperation Strategy Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines a plan for the U.S. to work with Mexico on local and state levels, aiming to increase cooperation in law enforcement and community engagement to tackle issues like drug trafficking. It requires the Secretary of State to submit this plan to Congress within 270 days, update it after two years, and limits sharing of certain data until Congress is notified.
3. Department of State review of access to finance in CARICOM member states Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of State, together with the Secretary of Treasury, will review ways to improve financial access for Caribbean Community (CARICOM) member states, including examining laws, reporting standards, and regional resources like embassies. A report of the findings will be sent to specific committees in Congress that oversee foreign affairs and financial services.