Overview
Title
To improve coordination between Federal and State agencies and the Do Not Pay working system.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 2716 is a plan to help make sure the government doesn't accidentally pay money to people who have passed away. It helps different parts of the government share information to stop these mistakes.
Summary AI
H.R. 2716, also known as the "Ending Improper Payments to Deceased People Act," aims to improve how federal and state agencies work together with the Do Not Pay system. This bill modifies a section of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, allowing the Social Security Commissioner to share data with the agency operating the Do Not Pay system, which helps prevent improper payments. The changes outlined in this bill will become effective on December 28, 2026.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill titled "Ending Improper Payments to Deceased People Act" aims to improve the coordination between federal and state agencies and optimize the "Do Not Pay" working system. Introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives, this legislation strives to prevent government payments issued to individuals who are deceased. It does so by mandating information sharing between the Commissioner of Social Security and the agencies operating the "Do Not Pay" system. This bill also modifies the expiration date of a related provision to December 28, 2026, which also serves as the effective date when these amendments will be implemented.
Significant Issues
There are several issues with the proposed bill that warrant attention:
Implementation Delay: The bill sets its effective date to December 28, 2026. This delay may raise concerns regarding the urgency and accountability of addressing the misuse of funds through improper payments to deceased individuals. The rationale behind this delay is not clearly provided, potentially impacting confidence in the legislative process and the system's efficiency.
Discretionary Language: The wording "to the extent feasible" offers the Commissioner of Social Security a level of discretion that could lead to non-uniform application or difficulties in compliance. Without a clear definition of what constitutes feasibility, implementation may vary drastically.
Ambiguity in Authorized Uses: The bill lacks clarity on what constitutes "authorized uses" of the data shared with the "Do Not Pay" system. This gap could lead to interpretations that might result in misuse or ethical and legal concerns, particularly in how the data is handled.
Complex Legal References: The bill relies heavily on legal jargon and references to previous legislative acts, potentially alienating those not familiar with legal documentation. This complexity may limit public understanding and participation in discussions about the bill.
Public Impact
For the general public, the bill seeks to ensure that taxpayer money is used effectively by preventing payments from going to deceased individuals. This enhancement can lead to better resource allocation and reduced government waste. However, the delayed implementation might mean that current inefficiencies and misuse continue unaddressed in the interim.
Stakeholder Impact
Government Agencies: They are both key actors and beneficiaries, as improved coordination can enhance their operational efficiency. However, agencies might face challenges in implementing changes within the new timeline and ensuring compliance with potentially vague requirements.
Social Security Administration: Directly impacted by the bill, it is tasked with managing data sharing with the "Do Not Pay" system. The discretion given to the Commissioner may streamline or complicate this process, depending on how feasibility is defined.
Public: While the intent is to prevent wasted government resources, individuals may express concerns over the delayed implementation and ambiguous terms that could result in inefficiencies continuing unchecked.
Legal Experts and Policy Analysts: They may find the bill's references and language complex, potentially hindering efforts to advocate for transparency and accountability. A clearer articulation of terms and timelines would be beneficial for comprehensive analysis and public dialogue.
Overall, the bill presents a critical approach toward enhancing coordination to prevent improper payments but faces scrutiny over its timeline, vagueness in key provisions, and its accessibility to those without legal expertise.
Issues
The amendment of the effective date to December 28, 2026, in Section 2 paragraphs (b) and (c), could be seen as delaying the implementation of the provisions of the bill. The rationale for this delay is not provided, which could lead to potential concerns about the accountability and urgency of addressing improper payments to deceased individuals.
The phrase 'to the extent feasible' in Section 2 paragraph (a) provides the Commissioner of Social Security with potentially excessive discretion regarding the provision of information to the Do Not Pay working system. This could lead to non-uniform implementation or issues with compliance, as the standard for feasibility is not defined.
The text in Section 2 paragraph (a) does not specify what constitutes the 'authorized uses' of the Do Not Pay working system. This ambiguity leaves room for interpretation and potential misuse of the authorized data-sharing agreements, which could raise legal and ethical concerns.
The use of legal references such as the 'Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021' and 'subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (3)' in Section 2 paragraph (a) might be unclear to individuals not familiar with legislative documents. This could impede understanding of the bill's provisions by the general public and stakeholders who are not legal experts.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The act is officially named the "Ending Improper Payments to Deceased People Act."
2. Improving coordination between Federal and State agencies and the Do Not Pay working system Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill section improves coordination by requiring the Social Security Commissioner to share information with the Do Not Pay system, under certain conditions, for preventing improper payments. Additionally, it changes the expiration date of a related provision to December 28, 2026, and sets this as the effective date for the amendments.