Overview

Title

To establish the American Worker Retirement Plan, improve the financial security of working Americans by facilitating the accumulation of wealth, and for other purposes.

ELI5 AI

H.R. 2696 wants to help workers save money for when they stop working by giving them special savings accounts with extra money from the government. It sets rules to keep the saved money safe and makes sure that different people manage the money so no one person holds too much of it.

Summary AI

H.R. 2696, also known as the “Retirement Savings for Americans Act of 2025,” aims to improve the financial security of American workers by creating the American Worker Retirement Plan. This plan would allow workers, including independent contractors, to automatically enroll in retirement savings accounts with government matching contributions. The bill outlines regulations for investment management, account contributions, and withdrawals, while ensuring participants' accounts are protected and managed prudently. Additionally, the act introduces a Government Match Tax Credit to incentivize contributions and help workers save for their retirement.

Published

2025-04-07
Congress: 119
Session: 1
Chamber: HOUSE
Status: Introduced in House
Date: 2025-04-07
Package ID: BILLS-119hr2696ih

Bill Statistics

Size

Sections:
25
Words:
15,310
Pages:
75
Sentences:
348

Language

Nouns: 4,591
Verbs: 1,067
Adjectives: 844
Adverbs: 120
Numbers: 479
Entities: 817

Complexity

Average Token Length:
4.31
Average Sentence Length:
43.99
Token Entropy:
5.49
Readability (ARI):
24.47

AnalysisAI

The "Retirement Savings for Americans Act of 2025" is a legislative proposal aimed at enhancing the financial security of American workers by establishing the American Worker Retirement Plan. The Act introduces mechanisms for retirement fund management, mandates enrollment processes, and sets up a Government Match Tax Credit to encourage savings. It aims to provide a structured means for American workers to prepare for retirement, supplementing Social Security benefits with additional financial products managed with oversight by a newly established Board.

General Summary

The bill establishes a framework for the American Worker Retirement Plan, featuring a retirement fund and an advisory board to manage investments. It sets clear guidelines for participant enrollment, contribution limits, and tax treatments. Key elements include automatic enrollment of qualifying workers, with provision for opt-out, and contributions treated as Roth contributions, exempt from initial tax benefits. Moreover, the bill proposes a Government Match Tax Credit for eligible individuals, where the government matches a portion of their contribution to the retirement fund, encouraging savings.

Significant Issues

Several issues emerge from the bill's language and structure. Firstly, the bill grants substantial discretionary power to the Executive Director and Secretary of the Treasury, potentially leading to a lack of transparency and oversight. Secondly, the complex regulatory language and reliance on cross-references to other legal documents could make the bill hard to understand for most Americans. This complexity might create compliance challenges for employers and confusion among taxpayers. Lastly, the broad exemption powers given to the Secretary of Labor, without clear criteria for their application, risk arbitrary decisions and favoritism.

Public Impact

For the general public, the bill presents both opportunities and challenges. On the positive side, it aims to strengthen financial security for workers by supplementing Social Security with an additional retirement savings vehicle, promising a more stable financial future. However, the bill's complexities and potential issues might deter some from taking full advantage. Administrative expenses funded by the retirement fund could also inadvertently reduce the net benefits to participants if not properly managed.

Impact on Specific Stakeholders

Employers are likely to face significant impacts due to the enrollment processes and penalties for non-compliance. Concerns may arise over the administrative burden of enrolling workers and the financial strain of penalties for errors in implementation. Small business owners, in particular, might experience difficulties due to potentially high demands for compliance and financial record-keeping.

Participants, or workers, stand to benefit from additional retirement savings and matched contributions from the government. Still, they might find it challenging to navigate the enrollment process and understand the tax implications. Moreover, the enhancement of spousal and survivor rights in line with existing federal plans adds a layer of security for families, yet the procedures must be executed carefully to ensure these benefits materialize effectively.

In summary, the "Retirement Savings for Americans Act of 2025" is a robust attempt to improve the retirement preparedness of American workers through structured savings plans. Nevertheless, strategic oversight and clear communication will be crucial in its successful implementation, ensuring it delivers on its promise without unwarranted complications or financial pitfalls.

Financial Assessment

The "Retirement Savings for Americans Act of 2025" (H.R. 2696) aims to enhance the financial security of American workers by setting up retirement accounts with government support. This involves several financial mechanisms that warrant examination.

Section 106: Distributions

This section introduces financial conditions for mandatory distributions. Participants with taxable incomes exceeding certain thresholds may receive distributions from the fund, linking retirement savings to income levels. This connection with taxable income and the possibility of compulsory fund withdrawal could pose challenges for individuals depending on their retirement savings for exclusive monetary support.

Sections 204: Investment Policies and Section of Asset Managers

The bill empowers the Board to ensure that no asset manager is responsible for managing more than the greater of $500 billion or 10% of the fund's assets. This financial cap aims to diversify asset management and mitigate exposure to risk. However, this large financial management amount raises concerns about oversight and the potential for financial mismanagement if fiduciary responsibilities are not well-defined.

Section 207: Bonding

The bonding requirement mandates that fiduciaries handling fund assets must be bonded, but the minimum bonding amount is set at $1,000 and may rise to $500,000 or higher upon regulation by the Secretary of Labor. This financial safeguard is intended to protect the fund against losses due to fraudulent or dishonest acts. The bonding requirement reflects a substantial financial safeguard against potential losses.

Section 301: Government Match Tax Credit

The section specifies a Government Match Tax Credit to incentivize contributions. The credit increases with income up to a specified 5% of income limit but phases out as income exceeds certain thresholds at a rate of $75 per $1,000 decrease. This phased credit creates a financial incentive for middle-income earners, though the complexity of the credit structure may lead to compliance and administrative challenges.

Implications Related to Identified Issues

  1. Transparency and Oversight: The financial allocations supporting the investment cap and bonding requirements necessitate robust oversight mechanisms. The lack of defined criteria for fiduciary duties could lead to inconsistent management practices or potential mismanagement.

  2. Complexity and Compliance: The phase-out of the Government Match Tax Credit introduces additional complexity, potentially complicating compliance for eligible taxpayers, especially if they are not financially literate.

  3. Ambiguity and Application: Lack of clarity regarding key financial terms and structures may pose challenges in applying these financial mechanisms equitably across all affected workers, increasing risks of discriminatory application or administrative burdens.

Overall, while the financial provisions of H.R. 2696 aim to secure and enhance the retirement prospects of American workers, vigilance in oversight and clear communication regarding these financial aspects are crucial for successful implementation and administration.

Issues

  • The substantial authority given to the Executive Director and the Secretary of the Treasury, particularly in sections 2, 105, and 203, might lead to lack of transparency, accountability, and broad discretionary power without sufficient oversight or checks.

  • The complex language and reliance on cross-references to the Internal Revenue Code and other external documents, such as in sections 105, 106, and 108, make the bill difficult to understand for taxpayers and stakeholders, potentially leading to compliance issues and misunderstandings.

  • The ambiguous definitions of key terms in section 2, such as 'business' and 'qualifying worker,' might lead to implementation challenges and regulatory confusion, impacting who is affected by the legislation.

  • The potential for wasteful spending and financial risks associated with the Government Match Tax Credit, as detailed in section 301, if contributions are not genuinely retained or if excess payments are not properly monitored and recovered.

  • The lack of clear criteria for fiduciary responsibilities and the potential for high financial and administrative risks in sections 206 and 204, particularly concerning asset management and the role of fiduciaries, could lead to financial mismanagement.

  • The broad exemption powers given to the Secretary of Labor in sections 206 and 207, without clear criteria or transparency, could lead to arbitrary application and favoritism in granting exemptions.

  • The enrollment process and penalty mechanisms outlined in sections 104 and 105 might create enforcement challenges for employers, particularly regarding penalties and rectifying enrollment errors, posing potential financial strain on businesses.

  • The undefined criteria and broad discretionary power granted to the Board and the Executive Director in establishing and managing investment policies, as outlined in sections 201 and 102, could lead to inconsistent application and lack of checks on strategic decisions.

Sections

Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.

1. Short title; table of contents Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Retirement Savings for Americans Act of 2025 aims to provide a framework for establishing retirement plans for American workers, detailing the management and investment of these plans, and introducing a government match tax credit to support retirement savings. The Act includes provisions related to the management and investment of retirement funds, eligibility and enrollment criteria, tax treatment, spousal protections, and the establishment of an oversight board and advisory council for effective plan administration.

2. Definitions Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section provides definitions for various terms used in the Act, such as "account," referring to specific retirement accounts set up under the bill, and "Board," referring to the American Worker Retirement Investment Board. It also explains what qualifies as a "business," "earnings," "existing retirement plan," "participant," "qualifying worker," and other related terms, helping to clarify who and what is covered under the Act's provisions.

3. Relationship to Social Security Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The funds paid out from the Fund to participants and former participants are additional to what they receive from Social Security benefits, unless specified otherwise in this Act.

4. Government benefits Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

In this section, it states that for people under 65, money in an account and any contributions made to it should not affect their eligibility for Federal public assistance benefits.

101. The American Worker Retirement Fund Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The American Worker Retirement Fund is established in the U.S. Treasury to collect and invest money from contributions under specific sections of this Act and the Internal Revenue Code. The money in the Fund is used for investments, administrative costs, distributions, loans, and insurance purchases, and it ensures the exclusive, nonforfeitable benefit of participants, protecting their funds from most legal claims, except certain obligations like child support or federal taxes.

102. Investment of American Worker Retirement Fund Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines the rules for how the American Worker Retirement Fund is to be invested, including specific types of investment options like government bonds, fixed-income funds, and stock index funds. It describes the responsibilities of the Board and the Executive Director in managing these investments, stipulates that participants cannot exercise voting rights on securities owned by the Fund, and requires regular performance reports to be sent to participants.

103. Eligibility Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

A worker who qualifies can join the Fund after finishing the enrollment process outlined in section 104. If someone stops participating, they can no longer contribute to the Fund but will keep control of their account and can make investment choices, subject to the withdrawal rules in section 106.

104. Enrollment Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The bill section outlines the rules for enrolling qualifying workers into a Fund, which involves a joint effort by the Secretary of the Treasury and the Executive Director to create an enrollment process, including for independent contractors. It mandates automatic enrollment with an opt-out option, sets penalties for employers failing to comply, and specifies how contributions and penalties are handled.

105. Contributions Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines how participants can contribute to their accounts with a Fund, including regular and additional contributions, like catch-up contributions and tax refunds. It also sets limits on contributions and explains that these funds are treated as Roth contributions, meaning they are not tax-deductible, and specifies the joint regulations prescribed by the Secretary of the Treasury and the Executive Director.

106. Distributions Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

Former participants of a fund can choose to withdraw their account balance in different ways, such as receiving payments as an annuity, a single payment, or multiple payments. They may also transfer their balance to another retirement plan. If a former participant dies, their spouse can maintain or withdraw the account, but cannot contribute further. Participants can also borrow from their account or make early withdrawals under specific conditions, but must follow certain rules outlined by the Executive Director.

Money References

  • — (1) IN GENERAL.—A participant shall receive a distribution from the Fund if the participant’s gross income for a taxable year exceeds the dollar threshold (as adjusted by the Secretary of the Treasury) established under section 414(q)(1)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986.

107. Accounts Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Executive Director is responsible for managing individual accounts for participants who contribute to a fund, ensuring the accounts reflect all contributions and allocated earnings or losses. The balance in each account is calculated by adding up all contributions and allocations, then subtracting any amounts that have been paid out.

108. Tax treatment Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

For tax purposes, the section states that the same rules applied to the Thrift Savings Fund will also be applied to the American Worker Retirement Fund, unless specified otherwise in the Act.

109. Spousal protections; survivor rights Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines that spousal protections and court orders, as defined in existing U.S. laws, will similarly apply to the governance of a specific Fund and its participants. The Executive Director must create regulations to ensure that these protections and survivor rights are as similar as possible to those provided by the Thrift Savings Plan for its members.

201. The American Worker Retirement Investment Board Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section establishes the American Worker Retirement Investment Board within the U.S. Government's executive branch, outlining its composition, including member appointments by the President with Senate consent, and terms. It specifies the Board's responsibilities such as policy establishment, oversight of the Fund's investments, and implementation of financial literacy requirements, while also detailing its powers and limitations, particularly in investment decisions.

202. The American Worker Retirement Plan Advisory Council Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The American Worker Retirement Plan Advisory Council is a group created by the Board, consisting of 7 members chosen by the Chair, who have experience in investment management, small business operations, or providing investment advice. The council’s main purpose is to give advice on investment policies and the administration of certain parts of the Act, and its decisions require approval by a majority of its members.

203. Executive Director Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Board is responsible for appointing an Executive Director who has significant experience in managing financial investments and pension plans. The Executive Director's duties include executing the Board's policies, managing the Fund, and overseeing the implementation of the Act, with the authority to appoint personnel, procure services, and delegate functions as needed.

204. Investment policies and selection of asset managers Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines that the Board is responsible for creating investment policies aimed at wisely growing funds for retirement and keeping costs low. Additionally, it requires the Board to choose multiple asset managers, ensuring no single manager handles too much of the fund, and limits their contracts to a maximum of five years.

Money References

  • (b) Asset managers.—The Board shall select asset managers to manage the Fund, subject to the following conditions: (1) The Board shall select a number of asset managers necessary to ensure that no asset manager shall be responsible for managing the greater of— (A) $500,000,000,000; or (B) 10 percent of the Fund’s assets.

205. Administrative provisions Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines the administrative rules for the Board's operation. It requires the Board to meet at least monthly and whenever the Chair calls a meeting, specifies that a quorum of three members is needed for conducting business, and clarifies that vacancies do not affect the quorum's ability to act. Additionally, Board members receive daily pay and travel expenses from the Fund for their official duties.

206. Fiduciary responsibilities; liability and penalties Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines the responsibilities, liabilities, and penalties for fiduciaries managing a Fund. It defines key terms, prohibits certain transactions, allows exemptions by the Secretary of Labor, and specifies legal actions that can be taken in case of violations, including civil penalties and audits to ensure compliance.

207. Bonding Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section outlines the rules for bonding certain people who manage funds of a specific fund, requiring them to have a bond to protect against loss from fraud or dishonesty. There are exceptions for some financial institutions, and the Secretary of Labor has the authority to prescribe the bond amount, ensure the bond meets specific conditions, and grant exemptions where necessary.

Money References

  • (2) EXCEPTIONS.— (A) IN GENERAL.—Bond shall not be required of a fiduciary (or of any officer or employee of such fiduciary) if such fiduciary— (i) is a corporation organized and doing business under the laws of the United States or of any State; (ii) is authorized under such laws to exercise trust powers or to conduct an insurance business; (iii) is subject to supervision or examination by Federal or State authority; and (iv) has at all times a combined capital and surplus in excess of such minimum amount (not less than $1,000,000) as the Secretary of Labor prescribes in regulations.
  • Such amount shall not be less than 10 percent of the amount of funds handled, except that in no case shall such bond be less than $1,000 or more than $500,000, or such higher amount as the Secretary of Labor, after due notice and opportunity for hearing to all interested parties, and other consideration of the record, may prescribe.

208. Investigative authority Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Secretary of Labor has the authority to investigate and determine if someone has broken or is about to break certain rules, using the powers granted by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.

209. Exculpatory provisions; insurance Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

Any part of an agreement that tries to excuse a fiduciary from their responsibilities or liabilities is invalid. Additionally, funds may be used to buy insurance to protect fiduciaries from potential liabilities, regardless of whether the insurance allows the insurer to claim reimbursement from the fiduciary if they breach their duties.

210. Subpoena authority Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section grants the Executive Director the power to issue subpoenas to gather necessary materials for responsibilities under the Act, protects those who comply with subpoenas from being sued, allows courts to enforce compliance, and requires the Executive Director to establish relevant regulations.

301. Government Match Tax Credit Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The section introduces a Government Match Tax Credit for eligible individuals, allowing them a tax credit based on their gross income and contributions to the American Worker Retirement Fund. The credit percentages vary based on the contribution amount to the fund, and the credit is given as an overpayment, to be deposited into the individual's retirement account, with certain rules about maintaining contributions and adjusting excess payments.

Money References

  • “(2) PHASEOUT OF CREDIT LIMIT.—The limit determined under paragraph (1) for a taxable year shall be reduced by $75 for each $1,000 or portion thereof by which the eligible individual’s gross income exceeds the phaseout amount.

25F. Government Match Tax Credit Read Opens in new tab

Summary AI

The Government Match Tax Credit provides eligible individuals with a credit based on their gross income and contributions to the American Worker Retirement Fund, subject to certain limits and conditions. Contributions must remain in the fund for at least six months to avoid forfeiture, and any excess credit payments are adjusted through tax increases.

Money References

  • (2) PHASEOUT OF CREDIT LIMIT.—The limit determined under paragraph (1) for a taxable year shall be reduced by $75 for each $1,000 or portion thereof by which the eligible individual’s gross income exceeds the phaseout amount.