Overview
Title
To amend title 49, United States Code, to prohibit staged collisions with commercial motor vehicles, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H. R. 2662 is a new rule that says you can't pretend to have a car crash with a big truck to get money because it's dangerous and wrong. If someone gets hurt really bad or dies because of it, the person who caused it could go to jail for a long time.
Summary AI
H. R. 2662, known as the “Staged Accident Fraud Prevention Act of 2025,” amends title 49 of the United States Code to make it illegal for someone to intentionally cause or arrange a staged collision with a commercial motor vehicle. If someone causes such a collision, they can face fines, imprisonment for up to 20 years, or both. If the collision results in serious injury or death, the penalties increase to at least 20 years in prison. The bill also ensures that a person cannot be prosecuted under this law if they have already been tried for the same incident under state or territorial laws.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The proposed bill, titled the "Staged Accident Fraud Prevention Act of 2025," aims to amend the United States Code to specifically address the issue of staged collisions with commercial motor vehicles. Essentially, it seeks to impose strict penalties on any individual who deliberately causes or orchestrates a collision with a commercial vehicle. If an intentional crash results in serious injury or death, the penalties become substantially more severe. Notably, a federal charge under this law cannot proceed if the individual has already faced prosecution for the same act at a state level.
Significant Issues
One of the main issues with the bill is its failure to define what constitutes a "staged accident." Without this definition, the scope and enforcement of the law remain ambiguous, potentially leading to inconsistent application across different jurisdictions. Similarly, terms like "serious bodily injury" and "intentionally" are not clearly defined, which could result in varied interpretations and enforcement by local authorities and courts.
The bill also includes a clause preventing federal prosecution if an individual has been tried at the state level for the same incident. This provision could inadvertently create a loophole, allowing perpetrators to escape further prosecution, depending on prior state-level outcomes.
Lastly, the bill lacks specific details about any programs or measures beyond criminal penalties that could prevent staged collisions, making it challenging to evaluate its potential effectiveness in deterring such crimes.
Potential Public Impact
Broadly, if enacted, the bill could potentially deter deliberate accidents involving commercial vehicles by imposing severe legal consequences. This could benefit the general public by reducing the number of fraudulent insurance claims, thereby potentially lowering insurance costs over time. However, the lack of clarity in critical legal definitions might lead to uneven enforcement, which could undermine public trust in the legislation's effectiveness.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Commercial Vehicle Operators and Insurance Companies: These stakeholders stand to benefit from the bill. Reducing staged collisions would likely decrease fraudulent insurance claims and associated costs, thereby enhancing operational safety and profitability.
Legal and Judicial Systems: The bill could present challenges for legal practitioners and courts, given the potential necessity to interpret ambiguous terms and manage the limitation on prosecution provision. This could lead to increased litigation and prolonged legal procedures.
Individuals and Criminal Justice Stakeholders: Individuals wrongly accused of staging accidents may face significant legal challenges due to the severe penalties outlined in the bill. Moreover, the lack of clarity around terms like "intentionally" and "serious bodily injury" could result in discrepancies in legal outcomes, depending on interpretation.
In conclusion, while the bill aims to address a malicious form of criminal activity involving commercial vehicles, its effectiveness may be impeded by vague definitions and a potential prosecutorial loophole. A more comprehensive approach, including clear definitions and preventative strategies, could bolster its impact and acceptance across various sectors.
Issues
The definition and explanation of what constitutes a 'staged accident' are not provided, leading to potential ambiguity in understanding and applying the Act's provisions. This issue is critical as it underpins the entire focus of the legislation. [Section 1]
The term 'serious bodily injury' is not defined within the bill, which could result in inconsistent interpretations and enforcement across different jurisdictions. Providing a clear legal definition or referencing existing ones would be beneficial. [Section 2, '§ 80505. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles', subsections (a) and (b)]
The language around the term 'intentionally' could benefit from more precise legal definition to avoid ambiguity and ensure uniform application across cases. Given the gravity of the penalties, clarity in the concept of intent is crucial. [Section 2, '§ 80505. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles', subsections (a) and (b)]
The limitation on prosecution clause, which prevents federal prosecution if the person has been convicted or acquitted on the merits at the state level, might create a legal loophole and challenges in uniform enforcement of the law across states. [Section 2, '§ 80505. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles', subsection (c)]
The Act lacks specific information about any measures, programs, or interventions, making it difficult to assess its implications or effectiveness in achieving its stated purpose of preventing staged collisions. This absence of detail is a concern for those evaluating the potential impact and enforcement strategy of the legislation. [Section 1]
There is a need for clarity on judicial discretion regarding penalties, especially concerning subsections (a) and (b) where the duration of imprisonment varies significantly. This distinction could be perceived as inconsistent without further explanation. [Section 2, '§ 80505. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles']
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill is titled "Staged Accident Fraud Prevention Act of 2025" and states that this is the name by which the act will be known.
2. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
A new section in U.S. law introduces strict penalties for individuals who intentionally cause or organize car accidents with commercial vehicles. Depending on the severity, violators may face substantial fines and imprisonment up to 20 years, and if a serious injury or death occurs, imprisonment for a minimum of 20 years. However, a person cannot be charged under this federal law if they have already been convicted or acquitted for the same act under state or territorial law.
80505. Staging of motor vehicle collisions with commercial motor vehicles Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
A person who deliberately causes a crash with a commercial vehicle can face a fine and up to 20 years in prison. If the crash results in serious injury or death, the prison time is a minimum of 20 years. However, if someone has already been prosecuted for the same act under state or other jurisdiction laws, they cannot be prosecuted again under this section.