Overview
Title
To allow a period in which members of the clergy may revoke their exemption from Social Security coverage, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
This bill lets priests and ministers who decided not to pay into Social Security change their minds and start paying again if they do it in time. It also says the government should help them know about this choice.
Summary AI
H. R. 227, also known as the “Clergy Act,” allows members of the clergy who previously opted out of Social Security coverage to reverse that decision within a specified timeframe. Eligible clergy can apply to revoke their exemption for the 2028 or 2029 tax year by filing the necessary paperwork by the tax return due date for their second taxable year after 2027. Additionally, if the application is late and affects that taxable year, payment of owed Social Security taxes for that year must be included. The Internal Revenue Commissioner, along with the Social Security Commissioner, must also submit a plan to Congress to inform clergy about their eligibility to revoke their exemptions.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill titled H.R. 227, introduced in the 119th Congress, aims to allow a period during which members of the clergy can revoke their previously claimed exemption from Social Security coverage. This legislation is referred to as the "Clergy Act." It essentially opens a window for ministers and certain religious practitioners to opt back into participating in Social Security, starting after December 31, 2027.
General Summary of the Bill
H.R. 227 provides an opportunity for clergy members, who formerly opted out of Social Security, to reverse that decision under specific conditions. The revocation allows them to re-enter the Social Security system for taxable years beginning after 2027. The bill also requires these individuals to pay any applicable taxes from the years they remained exempt but decide to revoke the exemption. Furthermore, the bill mandates the creation of an informational plan by the Internal Revenue Service and the Social Security Administration to educate affected religious figures about their rights to revoke previous exemptions.
Summary of Significant Issues
One major issue highlighted is the complexity of the bill's language, which might make it challenging for clergy members to understand their options and obligations without professional assistance. This could deter them from making informed decisions regarding their Social Security status. Additionally, the deadlines and requirements for revoking exemptions could impose significant financial burdens if not adhered to, potentially leading to unintended penalties for those unaware or unable to meet the deadlines.
The bill's directive to create an informational plan lacks specific criteria for measuring effectiveness, potentially leading to inefficiencies. Moreover, the legislation does not address consequences for failing to meet the 90-day deadline for developing this plan, potentially reducing accountability.
Broad Impact on the Public
The bill's broad impact lies in its attempt to offer financial security options to clergy members who might have previously opted out of Social Security. It addresses a gap for those who might reconsider their future financial needs, allowing them to integrate back into the safety net provided by Social Security. However, the complexity and potential financial strain involved in revoking exemptions could discourage participation and affect the bill's overall effectiveness.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For clergy members and religious organizations, this bill presents both an opportunity and a challenge. On one hand, it provides a path for those who wish to obtain Social Security benefits after reassessing their financial situations. On the other hand, the obligations accompanying the revocation could pose financial and administrative hurdles, particularly for smaller religious entities that may lack the resources for management and compliance.
Overall, while the bill introduces a potentially positive change by offering more flexibility to religious personnel regarding Social Security participation, its execution will depend heavily on effective communication and user-friendly processes to ensure that it serves its intended purpose without imposing undue burden.
Issues
The language used in Section 2 is complex and may be difficult for the average reader, including clergy members, to understand without legal or tax advisory assistance. This could hinder affected individuals from taking informed decisions regarding their Social Security exemptions.
Section 2 imposes a requirement for full payment of taxes if the application for revocation is filed late. This could pose a significant financial burden on clergy members who might either be unaware of the deadline or unable to meet it, potentially leading to unintended penalties.
The deadline for the filing of applications for revoking exemptions in Section 2 may not be widely known or easily tracked by those affected, potentially resulting in missed opportunities for revocation and financial penalties.
Section 3 does not specify criteria for evaluating the effectiveness of efforts to inform relevant religious individuals about the revocation of Social Security exemption, potentially leading to inefficiencies or ineffective execution of the plan.
The lack of clarity in Section 2 on what constitutes 'duly ordained, commissioned, or licensed ministers' could result in confusion or inconsistent application across different religious groups.
Section 3 specifies that a report and plan must be submitted within 90 days but does not mention any consequences or accountability measures if the timeline is not met, potentially reducing the urgency or effectiveness of compliance.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that the official shortened name for this legislation is the "Clergy Act."
2. Revocation by members of the clergy of exemption from social security coverage Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Ministers or members of religious orders who previously got an exemption from paying social security taxes can choose to cancel that exemption for tax years starting after December 31, 2027, by filing a special application before their tax return is due. Once they cancel the exemption, they can't apply for it again in the future, and they'll need to pay any back taxes owed for that year along with their application.
3. Report to congress Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, along with the Commissioner of Social Security, to create and submit a plan to specific congressional committees within 90 days of the Act's enactment. The plan should inform certain religious leaders and practitioners about their option to cancel a previous decision to opt out of Social Security participation.